Rated 4.13 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I loved this product and would highly suggest.
I evenly applied this product to my bottom and top lashes and found that it lengthened them.And added volume. It was hard to remove which maybe good for some situations.
Most Helpful Critical Review Smudges.
This mascara holds my curl created by my eyelash curler on my incredibly stubborn, straight eyelashes. This is the first thing I look for in a mascara. Secondly, it adds a natural amount of volume and length. I would like a more dramatic look, but it does add more than what my normal eyelashes or other mascaras give me. The only thing I can't get over with this mascara is that it smudges throughout the day. Near the base of my bottom and top eyelashes as well as at the tip where my eyelashes touch my skin. It's not super noticeable, but it is very annoying and creates a greyish color around my eyes which is not pretty, at all. I'm constantly rubbing on my skin to try and get it off... L'Oreal, PLEASE BRING BACK THE ORIGINAL DOUBLE EXTEND WATERPROOF MASCARA! This mascara held my curl, created a dramatic look through volume and length, and did not smudge. I used it for 6+ years and now I can't find anything that even compares to it.
Reviewed by 522 customers Did not work for me
Christina from Fresno ca
Did not work for me
Waterproof ..ooops made a mistake
Sorry from Southport NC
Did not use! Took it out of package and realized I bought waterproof which I do not use!
If I HAD to wear mascara this would be the one!
Mo from New Braunfels, TX
I never needed mascara when I was younger but these days my lashes are a little thinner and sparse. I have black eyelashes but black mascara makes my lashes look bolder and I don't want a bold look! I want a natural appearance with some volume at my lash line. The black brown color is perfect for that natural look, plus it is waterproof and this formula nourishes the eyelashes.
I would call myself a mascara connoisseur
Kiki from Baton Rouge, La.
I have tried most every drugstore brand mascara. Although there are some good ones, I seem to always go back to the voluminous L'Oréal waterproof mascara. The cons are it gets old quick. I change it about every 2- 2.5 weeks . The upside is that the price Is affordable so it's not so bad when having to buy more often.
I would buy this a thousand times again.
Eyes from Dallas, TX
I use it in addition to another mascara in the same line. They are amazing and separating and plumping my lashes.
Snoo3999 from Saint Paul MN
Makes my lashes look lengthy and defined! It's a waterproof mascara so it does flake a tiny bit, which is ok. I wore it to a few beach days and it didn't smudge. I can tell it came off a little bit in the lake, but it never left me with dark eye bags or smudges on my face.
Don't buy this.
Katzeye from Wall,NJ
Have used this mascara for years. Decided to get it at Ulta. Big mistake. From the first time I used it, it seemed to be dried up. It is being returned.
Product not all that wet. Does not do much on my lashes.
Kare from Kalamazoo, Mi
Will not buy this product again. It is important to me to accent my eyes since I battled cancer for over a year and lost my eye lashes and brows. This product did nothing for me. I am out my money.
Lisa from Cincinnati
I guess all the negative reviews on here are from competing companies trying to knock this mascara. Because it is the best mascara I've ever used. My only complaint is that it is hard to get off at night, which is literally the point of the waterproof aspect. So it is worth it for me to take the extra time taking it off at night because it lasts all day long through sweat, tears, and does not crumble smudge or anything. Very pleased.
Survives my tears
Lou Lou from USA
I use this for events I know I will cry at...wedding, funerals, etc. Stays in place and helps me feel like people won't notice my puffy red cry eyes because my mascara is still in place.
CJ from IA
I have tried every expensive mascara and drug store mascara ever made, and I always come back to this one!
Have to Replace
jewels from Dalton, GA
Dried up, I will go back to store to get replacement
Jess from Los Angeles
I bought this product because of the price point and the reviews. I put it on and was immediately disappointed. It claimed to be water proof and that was a lie. It smudged horribly upon application and I did multiple coats to still not get the length and volume I needed. Please don't waste your money. I wouldn't even give this to my worst enemy.
Best Mascara ever, hands down!
Mrs. Smith from NV
I have tried them all, and this one delivers well. Love the brush, gets every lash and defines them well.
Very natural looking, but smudges!
Buyer from America
I love the way it looks on me since I'm a natural blonde and a lot of mascaras look too bold/crazy for me, but this is so subtle and natural so that's great.
The only thing is that throughout the day you'll see it smudging under the eyes, so if that's something you can't be fixing constantly over the course of the day maybe this isn't for you.
Also it's not too water proof, so be careful regardless.
You get what you pay for
Bre from North Carolina, USA
This product gives you a great natural look, but I like my eyelashes to be enhanced by mascara and this just didn't do it. I bought it in store because the Lash Paradise was sold out and thought I'd give it a try. I'll use the mascara, but won't buy it again.
J from NY
I've been looking for a good waterproof mascara and settled on this one. Today I put it to the test with a full day out in the heat lugging around a wheelbarrow. Sweaty, but lashes fully intact! I'm a person whose mascara ends up all over my under eyes within a couple hours, so the fact that this lasted all day outside is enough to tell me I've found a keeper.
This is not waterproof
Chels from Mi
This mascara does nothing but smear. It adds no volume. If anything it added some length. It is NOT waterproof. It smudges on me just through the day. Horrible.
Great waterproof mascara
marie from Bluffton, SC
I like a brown-black mascara which is difficult to find. This waterproof formula works the best of any I found in that it stays on all day and doesn't make my under eyes look dark.
Not My Favorite
Dani from CO
I had bought this mascara because I knew a lot of celebrities loved it. But not me. I liked it at first because the thin formula is buildable and makes them look really pretty, but it smudges so much. I got home after an 8 hr shift and realized I had black smudges under my eyes. I'm a brown girl so it looked like I had the worse eye bags ever. I'm okay wearing it for short amount of times but not that long anymore. I think I'll try the lash paradise next time. So overall, good formula, bad wear for long periods of time, good wear for short periods of time, and wouldn't buy again!
gardenjoy3 from FL
I'm always looking for great, lash building, smudgeproof, waterproof mascara. Well I still haven't found it yet. This goes on your lashes nicely, looks really good but did smudge after a few hours.
I don't like it
hi-ban from San Francisco, CA
I don't like this mascara. The product is very chunky and my lashes look like a mess, the brown is just black.
Give us a curved brush please
Taylor T. from Tennessee
I love this mascara but really prefer the curved brush. I have looked many places to try to find this color brown in a waterproof formula with a curved brush. I have only found the straight brush. Does it exist?
Ms Ann from Greenville NC
I use it once in while but go back to my favorite
My Everyday Mascara
GracieMae from Ct
Great everyday mascara.