Rated 4.06 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review YES!
This is the mascara of my dreams. I use to use the better than sex mascara but it irritated my eyes, flaked, was hard to remove, and was $24! I've been on the hunt for a mascara that could replace that one and after almost two years, and dozens of failed mascaras I have found it. this one is the best mascara I have ever used. Yeah, I said it. It lengthens, separates, adds volume, doesn't clump, and holds the curl of my natural lashes! The pictures i'm posting are literally ONE COAT! One! I'm in lash paradise! :D
Most Helpful Critical Review Great for full long Lashes; BAD shelf life!
I usually buy Voluminous but it's been transferring under my eyes (even with waterproof) so I decided to try this. The result on my lashes were OUTSTANDING! I get so many compliments. And ZERO mascara under my eyes with non waterproof. I bought black waterproof and 2 tubes of black non waterproof. Why so many? I'll tell you. This mascara has a shelf life like I've NEVER seen before. Maybe a month and a half OR LESS then it's totally dried up! Had I not gone online and read reviews, I may have kept thinking it was somehow me?! I love this mascara but cannot waste anymore money on new product drying up so PLEASE FIX THE DRY OUT PROBLEM. So disappointed.
Reviewed by 5703 customers LOVE this
*Beauty*In*Ga* from Northwest Ga
This mascara is wonderful! It instantly makes your lashes so full! The reason for only 4 stars though is because I feel like it dries out faster than others. I still love it though and will keep buying.
My go to!
Sarah from Utica, ny
This is my go to mascara, it's affordable and is in competition with other high end brands. Some fall out but not a lot and lasts all day !
Best mascara ever
Em from USA
This stuff is amazing!! Makes it look like you put fake eyelashes on and not clumpy at all
lazuli from New York City
My eyelashes are more full when I don't put this on. It's clumpy right from the start and it smudges easily. I keep loosing eyelashes from it & I'm just done at this point. All it does is make your eyelashes black & long if they aren't already… don't buy!!!
My go to mascara!
mmay2001 from Cullman, Al
I love this mascara. Once it dries out/gets empty, it gets clumpy but it's amazing and definitely worth it for the price.
My absolute favorite Mascara! Luxury dupe!
Gentry from Iowa, US
I have been using this Mascara for nearly two years now. I switched from using TF- BTS and I have to say, I am a fan for life! My eyelashes have so much length and volume after just the first application! I like that it doesn't go on super thick and feels light on my eyes. I have never had this mascara break off my lashes and flake into my eye like other brands. Love this stuff! WELL worth the price!
Short shelf-life but results are so worth it
BearyWasHere from SoCal
Beautiful results that look very similar to the preview above and removes so easily with some water and remover to get up the leftovers. It lasts for an 8 hour shift without giving me racoon eyes, and non-dying tubes never cause flakes on me. I will say, the shelf life really is short (maybe a month or two) and the results aren't the same once this mascara starts going gunky. For example, flakiness will start to happen if you try to keep using it once it's dying and it will cause spider lashes at that point. But for the price and the results? I'm fine with just tossing it and opening up a fresh tube. I've tried so many mascaras that are twice or more the price of this, with nowhere near as impressive results and that are so much more difficult to remove. This is my favorite bar-none. I love it so much I have backups at all times, and I will continue to buy this until they change the formula or stop making it (Loreal please never change this).
Also, if you have brown eyes, try the Black Brown shade. I know it sounds boring, but it creates such a lovely natural everyday look. Blackest Black is my go-to, but every time I whip out my brown shade I'm impressed with how pretty my eyes look.
Best Mascara ever
Sun from 95337
Best Mascara Ever
fav mascara ever !!!
lauren from texas
literally have been using this since it came out and it's absolutely my fav and i always go back to it…makes lashes thicker while giving some length
Flakes on first application
Blady from Atlanta
I purchased this on the recommendation of the sales associate, who swore it was the best mascara ever. I specifically mentioned I need something that doesn't flake since I wear contacts. The first day I wore it, it started flaking within the first hour. Horrible!!
x from ulta
this mascara makes my lashes clumpy and look so wet. after 2 coats it's already having clumps. would not buy again
Shelby from SC
I used to exclusively use better than sex but it's just so expensive. I started using this and it's basically the same formula. It starts to flake a little faster but it lasts like 10 hrs.
Worst mascara I've used
Amanda from Pittsburgh, PA
I normally do not hate products, and am especially not critical of mascaras because they're such a basic product, and to be honest there's hardly ever a noticeable difference between different mascaras to me. But this is the worst mascara I've ever tried. It is so clumpy and wet and makes my lashes look horrible. I tried it on 3 different times and still just is not doing it for me. Do not understand the hype for this mascara in the slightest.
i don't like it
era from ndfndjdjdkdkd
this mascara does give volume but it also makes you lashes very clumpy and no length the clumpyness might be because the mascara wand gets so much product on it and it gets so dirty. I thought it was just my bottle but my cousin also said hers what's the same
Holy grail for me
KaylaTheShopaholic from Milwaukee
I have tried so many mascaras over time. This is the one I have found myself coming back to. I tried many others, High end and drugstore. With its primer I do not experience any transfer or flaking. My eyelids tend to get oily throughout the day and this holds up well!
never had a worse mascara
kenz from ohio
i have been using this everyday as my regular mascara. i have long, curly lashes so i just really need pigment rather than lengthening or anything. all this product does though is make my lashes look clumpy and stuck together. hate hate hate.
Affordable and good
Lilz from Las Vegas
This mascara is affordable and it really does volumize your eye lashes. You do have to be careful though because it can get clumpy if you add multiple layers. But for the price not bad.
Sara from KC
This is brilliant for the price. I'm switching from the MAC I always use because this is such a great product for half the price. It takes quite a bit of work to remove.
Leos mom from Home
At first i really enjoyed this mascara after 2 weeks maybe a bit more my tube got all clumpy and gross and the mascara dried supper fast and it wasn't preforming nice anymore for me is a pass !!
LOVE LOVE LOVE IT!
Brooke from .
This has been my favorite mascara for a few years. It gives your lashes a full and long look. holy grail product, i recommend!
Gilly from Indiana
This wasn't really anything special . I have medium length lashes, not really long but not short either. This just coated my lashes, didn't add any length . It does hold the curl of my lashes which some don't. That's important to be because my lashes are very straight . It's fine for everyday, and I would buy again. Just not really my favorite.
great mascara - at least as good as better than sex too face
Crazy Cat lady from Boston
i naturally have long eyelashes - this one enhances really well and darkens! Wand is great, lasts at least a few months without ever getting clumpy or dry (unlike Too faced better than sex IMO). worth a try!
Thick and clumpy
eliza from New Mexico
I've tried this mascara on two separate occasions. The second time only because I forgot about the first. It's thick and clumpy right out of the tube. Leaves globs on lashes and flakes off.
Ehh. It's okay
Tenna from 52405
It's really nothing fancy. It clumps easily and doesn't coat well. I put two coats on and it was clumpy in some areas and others it felt like it was barely there. I have about 12 mascaras right now and this one would be a good one coat natural look.
HMR from Michigan
I keep trying other brands to compare yet always come back to this one! Great application, doesn't clump, stays in place throughout day and quite a value for price. Having tried more expensive brands (Benefit they're real & NARS climax) I'm impressed by quality/performance for price. ❤️