Rated 4.45 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Goes on smooth!
I love this product! I usually use Anastasia dipbrow which dries up after a while..but after trying this out this will be my go to! Great product for half the price I'd usually pay
Most Helpful Critical Review Perfect Color, Breaks Easily
I love the way my eyebrows look when I use this eyebrow pencil. I've always used deep brown colors on my eyebrows but it never looked right. Turns out that my perfect color is NYX's "black", which by the way is a soft smokey black-grey, but can be buildable to straight black.
I like retractable products because I hate to carry a sharpener, but omg this thing breaks like crazy! I never roll the product out more than maybe a millimeter, but the "lead" part always breaks and falls out. If I'm lucky and the broken piece is big enough, I can put it back in and continue to use it. But then every time I open the lid, the broken piece falls back out.
This product does not have the staying power of NYX's eyebrow gel (the one you apply with an angled brush - that stuff is almost completely waterproof), but as long as you don't rub your eyebrows accidentally, this product will last all day.
Despite the fact that this product breaks a lot. I've still repurchased because the color is just so perfect. I hope they can improve the product in the future so that the breaking doesn't happen as much.
Reviewed by 1356 customers Fill in pencil
Sue from Wisconsin
I use the Ulta fine line to draw the shape of my brow and this pencil to fill in. It's a perfect combination for my needs.
Gigi from Austin, Texas
Works so well and is great quality. However, there isn't too much product in the tube so it actually runs out fast.
I like it!
Lena from Memphis, Tn
I usually purchase the Anastasia Beverly Hills brand for my eyebrows but this is not bad at all. Can't really see a difference.....other than the price. I may have to continue to purchase this one!
Trish from St. Cloud, MN
This is my go-to brow product. It is very hard to find them in stores and when you do they are always out, so I buy 2 or 3 at a time! These are way better then the higher-end brands. I hope these are never discontinued.
Great while it lasted but that wasn't for long.
SDarling from Dallas, TX
I used this for my eyebrow edges and arch area. It was great while it lasted (around 2 months) but I didn't even use it on my whole brow. I also didn't use it every day. If I used it daily and on my entire brow, it would last for a good month or so. I don't know if the color stick was having issues coming out or what but I raised it when necessary until I could raise it no more.
Africangal from Boston
I loveeeee the flat tip on this pencil and how easy it is to draw precise and stroke-like hairs on your brows. It deposits a soft shade too!!!! Not too harsh. I'm obsessed and will be purchasing more.
I would totally buy this again and WILL.
Chelsea from Ohio
I really like this pencil. I've only used it once but I'm very impressed from the first use. I've used several of the nyx brow pencils, my favorite for a while was the fill and fluff one but I found the pencil to be thick and hard to get small details. This is almost like the same thing, but with a spoolie instead of a brush, and the pencil is angled but it's thinner which is what I really love. I like natural brows on myself and I have had trouble getting my arch to look good without too much product on it and this is the perfect size to do that! I bought the shade espresso and use the espresso brow gel by nyx to go over it to tame any loose brow hairs.
Spdt19 from GA
Loriann from Indiana
Holy Moly... I have finally found the brow pencil that I will use for the rest of my life....
Love these pencils
KCali from California
These are so great for filling in brows. I love the soft colors and they don't fade out and turn to a weird reddish hue as they oxidize on skin during the day. Best pencils I have found at this price point. Love the NYX pencils.
Luciana from Houston, Tx
I love this pencil it is amazing and stays put
My go to brow pencil
Belinda from Idaho
This has been my eye brow pencil of choice for the last several years. It goes on smoothly and blends well. It does rub off fairly easily, but I don't touch that area much. I also wish it came one shade lighter, but to get such a color, I have to spend three times as much for a premium brand. This is a very acceptable compromise.
Kim from Newport News VA
I wish I would've found it sooner!!
Love the color and coverage
BeccaDee from Houston, Texas
I absolutely love the color and tilted head design. The draw back is that it breaks and crumbles when trying to use. The breakage leads to waste and not getting ones full use and money's worth.
Dee from Tucson AZ
Was complemented by brow artist on my natural brows!
tamberjune from california
I use this every day I want to look like I have eyebrows. which had been a lot of lockdown, if I leave the house for anything where I care what I look like. but I find this is the best eyebrow pencil I used to use the smashbox $30 version for years after the old revlon stopped working so well for me. I has very blonde, sparse brows. I'm using castor oil and it helps but thai is my HG for brows. also compared to ABH- no comparison the ABH pencil breaks off so quickly. I'd go for elf if I can't find this they're both great for natural looks!
I would buy this product again.
Lucy from Michigan
This product was the color I wanted which is hard to fine. Either a Taupe or Ash Brown color.
It was easy to apply and stayed on all day. However it did not last as long as I thought it would.
Defective - second time
dawnsharks from Livermore, CA
This is the second NYX mechanical eye pencil I have bought from two different stores that arrived defective. This one wouldn't rise out of the tube even after turning the bottom I think 100 times. the other one I bought elsewhere the liner literally fell out of the body of the pencil. there are other brands where the product is more reliable so personally I will not be purchasing any NYX pencils in the future.
Autmidd from Granbury, TX
This is a great product. Is goes on smooth. I will highly recommend it
Great for "Bronde" hair!
Jojo from California
Check my pros and cons.
My 1 of 3 things I will always repurchase!
sav from Harrisburg PA
I have dirty blonde hair and use the taupe color, which is very difficult to match. I use this product literally every day, I'm a creature of habit so I'll probably never try anything else. Looks natural, no one even knows I fill my brows
Favorite brow liner
Greystreak rogue from Melbourne
I've been using this for about 5 years n it's the best one out there!
I would buy this product again.
Lucy from Michigan
I use two pencil when I do my brow. One a brown color and one a gray color.
The color I am finished with is perfect and it stays on all day.
Bri from Virginia
I really like this product I did break it off a little in the first use but I blame myself because it may have been out too far. This is very nice and precise when doing brows.
As good as high end pencils
SueBee from Alabama
The sales person told me about this pencil and she was right. It is excellent and does a great job for sparse brows. I have used all brands from high to low end, and this pencil is my favorite. I like this pencil so much I purchased four of them.