Rated 4.57 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Enhance your brows!!
I love this pencil duo for darkening my brows! Gets the job done! Last awhile and the price isn't too bad!
Most Helpful Critical Review Some things changed, but I still love it!
I've always loved this product, the eyebrow pencil has always been my favorite, but it seems like since they changed the look of the pencil, they changed the formula of the pencil itself as well. It doesn't seem to draw on super sharp and sleek like it used to, kind of seems like it's more crayon like now, the more you try to draw in one area the more it seems to jus come off instead of stay on. And EVERYTIME I try to sharpen, the tip always breaks off and in the same size everytime too, as if the pencil is sectioned off like that inside instead of a full bar. I just want the old pencil back! ..but with the same new look :)
Reviewed by 1549 customers Good but could be better
Helpful shopper from New York
Product is nice but does not have the staying powder as the pomade unfortunately. I would say for anyone who has to draw their brows on maybe stick to the pomade. Using an actual high quality eyebrow brush is key to make the product look good. Again. This wasn't bad. I can see the benefits of using the pencil in terms of ease of use but down side is staying power could be better and it ended up just looking messy. Any oil on skin will make the product move around a bit. So your eye brows may look less defined. If you have thick eyebrows then I could see how you would like this though. It almost has the effect of making eye brows look thicker.
Crumbles upon application but does an okay job once blended
H33 from Georgia, USA
I bought this after realizing tarte stopped selling their brow mousse in taupe. I like this pencil and the brush on the end, but the product crumbles once applied. Like you lightly fill in the brows and then use the brush to blend, and the product comes off in crumbles. It's super weird but once blended fully, it looks decent enough. I won't be buying this again though.
Great brow pencil.
Abbes5 from Long Island, NY
I have been using this eyebrow pencil for years. It never disappoints. Goes on very smoothly.
Parker from Alabama
I have using it for a few years!
Mari from Chicago
This is only pencil that works for me, I wish cruelty-free.
Sulu from Erie, PA
On my lack of lack of eyebrows on most of my brows.
Just get it!!
Tay from Denver, CO
This is my favorite brow pencil ever! I use medium brown. I struggled to find a brown that matches my hair color and doesn't have any kind of red tone until I found this one! It lasts a long time and the tip doesn't break/crumble easily
Coco from Myrtle beach
It smears very badly and does not go on well
This is the eyebrow pencil that I ever purchased
TreeHaa from Flint mi
I've been looking for a natural color pencil, this is natural and not wet.
Love this brow pencil
Lena from San Jose
I love using brow pencils and was happy to have found this non waxy pencil that gives me a full bold brow.
Perfect for me
Carole from PA
LOVE this product. I DO wish it was slightly lighter in color
Love this product!!!!
Miz from Bryan, Tx
One of the most natural brow products I have used!
My go-to brow pencil
Spirit_Chick from Raleigh, NC
Like I said, my go-to brow pencil. I've been using this product since 2016. My main brow product is the Anastasia brow pomade (in Taupe), but THIS pencil is perfect for filling in the sparse spots, or to use alone without the pomade. The ONLY problem I have is I go through it VERY fast, every time it gets sharpened the pencil gets shorter and shorter and before ya know it you're sharpening with the spoolie almost in the sharpener
The shade was perfect
Kiaa from Baltimore
The blonde shade matched perfect and gave me the look I was going for
I buy this product again and again
No nickname from La Jolla, CA
It's easy to fill in the areas that need covering.
I use this daily!
Leila M from Orlando FL
Love this product! My makeup routine is simple and (only eyes / eyebrows)... this one i won't go outside without!!!
Not as expected
Celine from Cleveland
I have hardly any eyebrows left
I like using the pomade but sometimes it gets too harsh and messy so I decided to try this soft pencil but I guess I'll stick with the brow whiz
Looking for another brand
Re from Ocean City New Jersey
Good color match but flakes and doesn't last long
More Bang For Your Buck!
Nina35 from Canton, MI.
This works great like the brow wiz, except it will last much longer...... due to the fact that you have to sharpen it, rather then a mechanical pencil. The hair strokes also look really natural.
I do like this brow pencil
JBelle from Redmond, WA
As mentioned above, the frustrating thing, but I've found this with other brow "pencils" is that the "lead" part breaks frequently when you sharpen it, as if it were already broken all through the pencil. If not for that, I'd have given five stars. Note: I use the "blonde" pencil, even though I use "taupe" in any others.
Will buy again
TJ from Sioux Falls SD
This is an easy to use product and stays on a long time which is very good.
kitty from WI
Love this Eye Brow Pencil. Easy to apply and covers even my thin brow skin.
Favorite brow pencil
Lindsey from Atlanta
Stays in place! Longtime favorite!
chicken biscuit from michigan
I usually get the jar, but this is less harsh and I get my eyebrows done SO much quicker. I was taking an hour easy with the eyebrow dip. I got mine done in 20 mins and I'm talking about cleaned up and all. I'm a redhead and this actually blended out to my hair color unlike the dip.
Never Makeup Without It
DJ from Tucson Arizona
This is in my holy grail. The pigment is great for women of color, covers gray hair, smooth application and a high end product!