Product Reviews Rated 3.99 out of 5 stars
549 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review my favorite mascara Okay so I read a lot of the reviews in here and I am just convinced that the people who hate this mascara have no idea how to 1.apply mascara and 2.remove WATERPROOF mascara. I have tried every drug store and high end mascara out there and this is one of my top 5. I have long and thick lashes. It separates perfectly, coats my lashes without clumping, doesn't flake off, barely smudges and it stays on all day. I remove it with coconut oil because it is gentle on your lashes and waterproof mascara will rip your lashes out if you do not take care of them and remove mascara properly. That being said, if you think it's clumpy, wipe the brush off before you use it then put it back in the tube and move it around and then use. Sometimes there's too much product on it when you first buy it which will naturally make you hate it from the get go. Secondly, do not use water and soap to remove waterproof mascara, that's brainless. Use an oil based makeup remover, coconut oil or baby oil. Love this mascara a lot and will buy again!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not what I expected... Was sent this mascara and excited to use it! However, on first use the mascara clumped my lashes and separated them making them look dry and unhealthy looking. Small flaky clumps of the mascara began to fall off within minutes and the claim of being waterproof was not experienced. Contact with water causes the mascara to run very bad! Disappointed with this product.
Reviewed by 549 customers One of my favorites! 5
Nikkiaust17 from Vermilion, ohio
I agree that this is a dupe for Rollerblade. The only thing is this formula is much more wet. I love this mascara with a 5 star rating easily, but I honestly love it more after it has been drying for a month or two. The brush is kind of cone shaped and makes it easy to get close to my lid at the end of my eyes. (That's where I usually struggle). This is for people after a little volume but mainly lengthening. I absolutely recommend.
Favorite Mascara !! 5
Ryn from San Francisco, CA
I originally purchased this mascara on vacation after I stumbled across Doja Cat doing her makeup on vogue beauty secrets and I was instantly impressed. My eyelashes are usually really stubborn and fall flat halfway throughout the day, however, this mascara not only adds volume and length to my lashes, but it holds a curl all day with no smudging (and I have pretty oily eyelids). Overall this is a really great product!
I would not buy this again. 2
No nickname from West Virginia
I would not buy this product again, because of the excessive flaking!
Great dupe for the rollerlash mascara from benefit 5
SophiaKim from Atlanta GA
Works perfectly, my second favorite mascara ever.!!!!
My holy grail mascara 5
Jazzyfizzle from Washington
I'm not sure why there are so many terrible reviews on this. I've used this formula since it came out and have stuck with it ever since. It's the only mascara that stands up to the task of maintaining the curl in my lashes after using an eyelash curler. It's waterproof, which is great for my oily lids. Adds so much volume! Maybe this is trickier to apply since the brush makes it so I don't have to apply too many coats, so I'm usually quick and steady about applying it. Once it dries, it doesn't transfer/clump/fade during the day. It's perfect!
Amazing 5
Tiff from Seattle
Not sure why the ratings are so low but this is thee best mascara ever. I've used countless high end mascaras and this one out performs them all. I have oily skin and lids, two coats and my lashes are full, long and stay curled all day. Does not transfer either. Love it!
Dry again 1
Jen from MI
Every time I buy this product at Ulta it's dry! No matter what Ulta I go to
would not ever buy this mascara again. 1
madison from greenwich ct
it made my lashes clump together and after using this mascara my lashes began to fall.
Not that great 3
AP from Chicago
This mascara is VERY flaky and wet. It takes a long time to dry, clumps easily, and flakes off throughout the day. I'm constantly wiping underneath my eyes throughout the day to make sure I don't have this mascara underneath.
nope 3
oof from Memphis, TN
nope.. super CLUMPY and uneven. Sooo hard to get off and when u finally get it off it pulls half ur eyelashes out w/ it...
Would not recommend 2
jayla from ulta
It is VERY wet when you apply and takes forever to dry. It left me looking like a raccoon by the end of the day. It was extremely hard to take off and would never fully come off. It left my eyes dark still. Also it ripped out so many eyelashes and overall just isn't a good mascara. I would not recommend.
Easy shape 5
Nooraish from New Jersey, NJ
It's brush is easy to shape my lashes. I always buy this mascara because it is waterproof and the best thing I've noticed is MY EYELASHES ARE THICKER THAN BEFORE. I am not using anything else than this product for my eyelashes.
Do Yourself a Favor, Buy a Different Mascara 1
Morgan from Columbia, MO
The product is WET and thick. The wand makes the product get everywhere. The worst mascara I have ever tried.
Could kick myself for buying this 1
Jennifer from Florida
The container/applicator design alone should have been my first clue. The handle is not shaped so you can hold on to it easily and you cannot stand either of them up because the bottom is so small. Comb applicator not good because you had to line up the comb with your eyelash and once the product was on the comb would not go through it. Wish I could return it.
Horrible clump disaster 1
Alexalou08 from Massachusetts
Horribly clumpy from the start, brush bristles do not do a "fan effect" they just glob the product on there. Disappointing product.
Horrible clump disaster 1
Lexilou08 from Massachusetts
Horribly clumpy from the start, brush bristles do not do a "fan effect" they just glob the product on there. Disappointing product.
No, not at this store 1
Joy from Menifee CALIFORNIA
I was surprised that the container was empty. I cannot get anything on the brush to put to my eyelashes. Don't know what happened there
Clumpy and hard to remove 1
Sandra M Roe from Los Angeles
I rarely write reviews but this mascara is aweful and a waste of money. Not only is it clumpy as soon as you put it on but it's terribly difficult to properly remove and takes your lashes with it when you do. Skip this one.
Best drugstore mascara! 5
Lina D from Garland TX
This gives me the long and dark lashes I've always
wanted! I've used a lot of more well known brands, but this Lash Sensational cannot be beat! Especially when it comes to price!
Too clunky and flaky 2
Sara from Wooster, Ohio
I used this product for two weeks and it just was too flaky and clumpy. Very hard to take off even with good makeup remover specifically for waterproof mascara
in the garbage 1
triplea186 from Iowa
1st time took the wand out and full of mascara so of course just clumped on my lashes. 2nd time wiped off all that mascara and still clumped up on my lashes. Later in the day I felt like I had dirt on my face on it was the mascara coming off. WHAT A WASTE OF MONEY! In the garbage it went.
Beware, it transfers 4
Liz from Seattle, WA
I like this mascara brush and it makes my lashes look great. The one drawback is it tends to transfer to my lids throughout the day, which I have noticed lately with similar formulations from this same brand.
the best waterproof mascara EVER 5
Emily from Texas
I have always struggled with finding the perfect waterproof mascara that doesn't smudge, stays put, and looks just as good as normal mascara. I found this one after researching different kinds and I decided to buy it. I am so impressed! I usually buy higher-end makeup so I was a bit hesitant to try this out but it is AMAZING. I've worn it through swimming, getting sweaty at band camp, and crying sessions, and it never fails me. I highly recommend this! It gives the perfect curl (even without using an eyelash curler), good volume, separation, and length! Well worth the small price.
I would give zero stars if I could 1
Peg79 from ND
Mascara did nothing but clump and looked dry and flaky. Tried it 3 times and then had to purchase a different mascara. Will never buy this again.
I am buying again.... 5
Liz from Baltimore
One of the best Mabbeline mascaras i've used!