Tab through the images or use the previous or next buttons to navigate each product image
Yay! You are earning rewards points on this purchase.
Highlights
Summary
Available in 12 shades to flatter every hair color, anyone can be an expert with this super easy brow-filling and shaping eyebrow pencil! Benefit's Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil features a custom goof-proof tip that instantly shapes, defines & fills in brows.
Benefits
- Retractable, non-sharpen tip
- 95% said it was easy to fill & shape brows***
- 94% said it gives beautiful brows on the first try***
- ***Consumer panel survey of 109 women after 1 week
Features
- 12-hour* waterproof** color
- *Instrumental test on 20 panelists
- **Instrumental test on 22 panelists
Item 2542687
Use the wide part of the custom teardrop tip to shape and fill brows using a couple of strokes from the start to your arch to build color. Use the pointed edge of the tip to define the outer end (the tail) of your brows. Blend with spoolie brush for full and natural-looking brows.
Beauty Tip: Brow boost! Layer Benefit's cult-favorite Gimme Brow+ (sold separately) over Goof Proof Brow Pencil to add instant volume & natural-looking fullness.
Shade 3.75: Synthetic Fluorphlogopite, Stearic Acid, Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Synthetic Japan Wax, Ethylhexyl Palmitate, Cera Alba (Beeswax), Sorbitan Sesquiisostearate, Aluminum Hydroxide, Tocopherol. May Contain: CI 19140 (Yellow 5, Yellow 5 Lake), CI 42090 (Blue 1 Lake), CI 77007 (Ultramarines), CI 77163 (Bismuth Oxychloride), CI 77288 (Chromium Oxide Greens), CI 77289 (Chromium Hydroxide Green), CI 77491, CI 77492, CI 77499 (Iron Oxides), CI 77510 (Ferric Ferrocyanide, Ferric Ammonium Ferrocyanide), CI 77742 (Manganese Violet), CI 77891 (Titanium Dioxide).
Product ingredient listings are updated periodically. Before using a Benefit Product, please read the ingredient list on the packaging of your product to be sure that the ingredients are appropriate for your personal use.
This brand is excluded from most Ulta Beauty coupons.
We think you'll like
12 items
Use previous and next buttons to navigate the slides of the We think you'll like Product Carousel
Urban Decay Cosmetics
All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray
Charlotte Tilbury
Travel Size Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray
MILK MAKEUP
Hydro Grip 12-Hour Hydrating Gel Skin Tint
Similar items for you
12 items
Use previous and next buttons to navigate the slides of the Similar items for you Product Carousel
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Brow Wiz Precision Eyebrow Pencil
Benefit Cosmetics
Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer
Benefit Cosmetics
24-HR Brow Setter Clear Brow Gel with Lamination Effect
Benefit Cosmetics
Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil
Sponsored products
12 items
Use previous and next buttons to navigate the slides of the Sponsored products Product Carousel
Grande Cosmetics
GrandeBROW Brow Enhancing Serum
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Brow Wiz Precision Eyebrow Pencil
Anastasia Beverly Hills
DIPBROW Waterproof, Smudge Proof Brow Pomade
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Clear Brow Gel Flexible Medium-Hold Eyebrow Setter
Waterproof with 12-Hour* Longwear!
Available in 12 Shades!
Non-Sharpen, Goof-Proof Tip!
Find Your Shade of Goof Proof Brow Pencil!
Shade 1 - Cool Light Blonde
Shade 2 - Warm Golden Blonde
Shade 2.5 - Neutral Blonde
Shade 2.75 - Warm Auburn
Shade 3 - Warm Light Brown
Shade 3.5 - Neutral Medium Brown
Shade 3.75 - Warm Medium Brown
Shade 4 - Warm Deep Brown
Shade 4.5 - Neutral Deep Brown
Shade 5 - Warm Black Brown
Shade 6 - Cool Soft Black
Shade Cool Grey
Pair with Another Benefit Brow Fave!
Explore More Benefit Favorites!
Questions
Q&A
Showing 20 out of 49 Questions
- Q
If I use Soft Brunette in the Hourglass eyebrow pencil, what color would you recommend in this? And is this really waterproof and sweatproof?
- Asked by GiGi
- Official Answer By Benefit Cosmetics en_USHi Gorgeous! I would recommend either 3.5 (neutral medium brown) or 3.75 (warm medium brown) in our Goof Proof depending on your undertone. Goof Proof is waterproof up to 12 hours!Was this answer helpful to you
- Q
Does this product containe fragrance?
- Asked by Trice
- Official Answer By Benefit Cosmetics en_USHi Gorgeous! Our Goof Proof pencil does not contain fragrance! xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
Hi this is my first time using this brow pencil. I usually use a pomade. My question is if the tip dulls or breaks how do I sharpen it?( since the pencil is plastic)
- Asked by Tiara
- Official Answer By Benefit Cosmetics en_USHi Gorgeous! Our Goof Proof does not require a pencil sharpener! Just twist for more product to come out! xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
I have dark brown hair with yellow undertone (Asian). What color should I considered using?
- Asked by Nin
- Official Answer By Benefit Cosmetics en_USHi Gorgeous! I would suggest our Goof Proof in shade 4. However it's always best to get shade matched in-store for the best possible results. xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
I have dirty blonde hair. Dishwater blonde to be a bit more descriptive. I use ABH Blonde. What color should I use with this product?
- Asked by Kirsten
- Official Answer By Benefit Cosmetics en_USHi Gorgeous! We would recommend shade #2 in our Goof Proof pencil. Of course, we can shade match you in-store (which will give you the closest match). xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
How waterproof is this product? If I were to go swimming in the ocean or a pool, would it stay on or fade once I'm underwater?
- Asked by Ny girl
- Official Answer By Benefit Cosmetics en_USHi Gorgeous! Our Goof Proof eyebrow pencil is waterproof. Budge-proof your Goof Proof with 24-hour Brow Setter! xoxo B https://www.ulta.com/24-hr-brow-setter-shaping-setting-gel?productId=xlsImpprod14191031&sku=2509015&_requestid=4442094Was this answer helpful to you
- Q
I currently use anastasia products and i use the color chocolate. What color is that equivalent to in the benefit line?
- Asked by ang
- Official Answer By Benefit Cosmetics en_USHi Gorgeous! You would be a shade #4 in our Goof Proof pencil. For the best results we can shade match you in-store (which will give you the closest match). xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
Hi! I normally use the Anastasia dip brow pomade in the shade taupe, and Its a the perfect shade, but pomades aren't for me. What shade do you recommend to me? I need a shade that does not have a red undertone like most do. Thank you!
- Asked by Cassidy
- Official Answer By Benefit Cosmetics en_USHi Gorgeous! We would recommend our Goof Proof pencil in shade 2 or 3. Of course, we can shade match you in-store (which will give you the closest match). xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
What if my eyebrow hairs are sort of grayish brown. They seem closest to the last shade, but shade 5 is way to dark. Is there a shade you would recommend?
- Asked by Emy
- Official Answer By Benefit Cosmetics en_USHi Gorgeous! We recommend shade 6 if your hair color is cool dark brown to cool black (with salt 'n' pepper! xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
What color are they using on the model in the Goof Proof Brow Pencil Tutorial?
- Asked by Sammysweetheart
- Verified Reply - Staff ExpertWe apologize for our delayed response. Please contact gethelp@ulta.com for assistance. Thanks!Was this answer helpful to you
- Q
I have dark brown hair with some Carmel highlights, which benefit eye brow color would be the best? I don't know if the 4 or 5 would be the best. I have tried the milani product which is a dark brow color. Just have a hard time putting it on without it looking to much. I have sparseness eyebrows and am looking something quick to use without messing it up.
- Asked by Cin123
- Verified Reply - Brand ExpertHi gorgeous! I would recommend the Goof Proof pencil in shade 4 if your hair color is medium to dark brown. Of course you can always go in-store to be shade matched to the closest color. xoxo B http://images.ulta.com/is/image/Ulta/benefit_brow6shade_shadefinder?scl=1Was this answer helpful to you
- Q
My eyebrows are transparent with no color whatsoever and i'm NOT the traditional redhead i have strawberry blonde hair with natural blonde streaks and using the shade 3 might be too red/ dark, should i use shade 1 or 2?
- Asked by Olivia
- Verified Reply - Brand ExpertHello gorgeous! In our Goof Proof Brow Pencil I would recommend shade 3 (medium). Of course you can go in-store to be shade matched to the closest shade. xoxo B http://images.ulta.com/is/image/Ulta/benefit_brow6shade_shadefinder?scl=1Was this answer helpful to you
- Q
hi i have natural red hair and very pale skin with pink undertones, do you think that the lightest shade you have will work with my strawberry red brows?
- Asked by Redhead beauty
- Verified Reply - Brand ExpertHello gorgeous! In our Goof Proof Brow Pencil I would recommend shade 3 (medium). Please see our shade finder for assistance. xoxo B http://images.ulta.com/is/image/Ulta/benefit_brow6shade_shadefinder?scl=1Was this answer helpful to you
- Q
I bought this brow pencil almost a year ago and I can never get pigment without tugging, is there any way to fix this or a better way to use it without baring down?
- Asked by morrigan90
- Verified Reply - Staff ExpertPlease contact us at gethelp@ulta.com. Thanks!Was this answer helpful to you
- Q
I have medium to light brown ish mixture with blonde hair and dark brows? What color would you recommend for the goof proof brow pencil?
- Asked by Lucy
- Verified Reply - Brand ExpertHi Gorgeous! I would recommend our Goof Proof pencil in shade 02 or 03, of course we can shade match you in-store (which will give you the closest match)! xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
Hello, I have black hair with some brown highlights which are fading at the bottom and not even noticeable anymore. Which brow shade should I use? Stuck between 5 and 6, how can I differentiate?
- Asked by Lo
- Verified Reply - Brand ExpertHi gorgeous! If your undertone is warm I would recommend shade 5, if your undertone is cool would recommend shade 6. Of course, we can shade match you in-store (which will give you the closest match). xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
Will this pencil tame flyaway brow hairs? Does it have a waxy consistency?
- Asked by All about the brows
- Verified Reply - Brand ExpertHi gorgeous! Our Goof Proof pencil fills and shapes your brows and does contain wax. I would recommend our 24-HR Brow Setter (Item #: 2509015) for shaping and taming your brows! xoxo B http://www.ulta.com/24-hr-brow-setter?productId=xlsImpprod14191031Was this answer helpful to you
- Q
My hair is ash blonde or yellow white, have brown eyes, olive skin. Which goof proof eyebrow pencil color do I use?
- Asked by Sun Honey
- Verified Reply - Brand ExpertHi gorgeous! I would recommend our Goof Proof in shade 02 as the closest match. Of course we can shade match you in-store (which will give you the closest match)! xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
I hv permanent eyebrows. I still hv hair in the main part of brow but the end of the brow the hair is gone leaving the tail of the brow with a light discoloration of the original color tattooed. I would be using it to complete the end of the brow on just skin alone and trying to cover the discoloration. is this product for me? Thanks!
- Asked by MImi
- Verified Reply - Brand ExpertHi gorgeous! Our Goof Proof fills and shapes your brows. Use the wide part of the custom goof-proof tip to fill & shape brows. Build color with a couple of strokes. Use the pointed edge to define the "tail" of your brow. xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
- Q
If my hair is light to medium brown but my eyebrows are a very light blonde what shade would I be. Ps. when I was little my hair used to be blonde but it turned brown but my eyebrows are still blonde.
- Asked by Lindsay
- Verified Reply - Brand ExpertHi gorgeous! In our Goof Proof brow pencil I would recommend shade 01 (Light) as a close match. Of course, we can shade match you in-store (which will give you the closest match). xoxo BWas this answer helpful to you
Reviews
Review Snapshot
by PowerReviews
Ratings Distribution
Best Uses
Describe Yourself
Most Helpful Positive Review
HOLY GRAIL
All I have to say is that if there is one thing I know - it's eyebrows. I've been obsessed with brows for like over ten years. This product is hands down, the absolute BEST eyebrow product I have ever used. The formula is light years ahead of the ABH Brow Definer. It is highly pigmented but also bui...
Most Helpful Critical Review
Not what I expected!
Love how the wand makes it easy to apply but I felt the product too creamy which made my eyebrows look very oily by the end of the day.
3760 results
I really like this brow liner
The problem is that it is TOO EXPENSIVE! $28 cost is way too much for an even smaller brow pencil. Something that, as a senior, I use everyday.
I would definitely buy this product again
Benefit brow really easy to use and stays for almost 24 hours. Great buy. Definitely easy to use and enhances your brows.
Waste of money
This was my favorite eyebrow pencil and I had purchased many times, but last time I bought this it broke every time I used it. Not sure if they changed the formula, but won't buy again.
great product
I have been using this eyebrow pencil for a long time. I hope they don't discontinue it. It applies smoothly and precisely.
Broken lead
The lead broke the first time I used it.