Product Reviews Rated 4.36 out of 5 stars
1486 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I've been waiting for this! I've never found any brow product that just 'clicks' as the Fill&Fluff. It's effortless yet is incredibly natural! My brows don't look shiny, overdone, and they take about 30secs each- yes please!
As a glasses wearer, sculpting my brows (or doing any eye makeup really) is hard, because I have to remove my glasses to get close (and therefore can't well or create clean lines). But this is so easy to use I don't need to overthink it. Most of all I LOVE that it enhances what i naturally have. I'm jumping ship from the micro brow pencil to the Fill & Fluff!
Most Helpful Critical Review Great texture and shades, overall poor pencil There is hardly any product in this, put this formula in an old fashioned wood pencil and it would be an excellent product. Why does everyone waste their money on these chinsey pencils that dont last. This has a great formula and texture and great shades, however the application is way too difficult. You have to be so careful to not break it, not press to hard and to stay in the lines. I know I know, NYx has a wooden pencil but the powder is so messy.
Reviewed by 1486 customers Perfect Auburn Brows That Are Defined But Soft 5
The Queen of Mean from Omaha, Nebraska
I love this brow pencil because it complements my auburn hair perfectly. It's difficult to find auburn eye pencils that aren't too red, too orange, too purple, or too dark. This one is the most natural-looking one I've found. Also the formula combined with the fluffy brush give me a defined brow without harshness, which I find especially important now that I'm 60. This pencil also remains in place all day without running, smudging, melting, or fading. And finally, even though I'm not very arty, this pencil is idiot-proof and allows me to effortlessly fill in and shape perfect brows.
HATE. 1
Grouch-Brows from Kansas
Messy, unbelievable appearance - looks like I used printer ink. PASS.
Great for price 5
AndreaN from Detroit MI
I have purchased many brown pencils in the last year and this is the easiest to use. The little brush on the end is perfect for fluffing and the pencil itself is very creamy and glides on smoothly.
Great product 5
kathy from phoenix
Love It
Good eyebrow pencil 4
Ivygirl2 from Covington, LA
Good eyebrow pencil. Glides on easily and has a small brush on the other end that is different than most and I really like it. They also have several colors to choose from which helps you find the perfect shade.
LOVELOVELOVE 5
Amy B from Portland, Oregon
Literally love this eye brow pen. Makes my brows look bomb and you have so much control over your brows.
Love the pomade 4
Carly from Denver, Co
I chose the color "taupe" because I owned the NYX pomade eyebrow + highlight in "Taupe." I wish they were the same and carried across the brand, but this color has light red tones.
works great for brows 5
AJG from NY
great coverage for brows but I wish there was more product!
It's the best! 5
Kim from Washington
I love how easy this goes on, and how great it looks! It's easy to use to shape my brows. It's better than other products I've tried, and I've tried alot lol.
Works great 5
Tori from Pensacola
My favorite brow pencil so far
Bit of a learning curve 4
Chelsea from CA
The pencil side is softer than anticipated, not a bad thing, just not quite the consistency I was expecting. Thought this would be more waxy, but it's definitely more of a soft pencil. The brush side is easy to use for blending. Will take a bit of practice to get the brow look I'm going for-- may still need a clear coat over top to set them.
Eyebrow pencil 5
Deedee from Washington DC
Love this pencil
Does a good job
I threw out my Anastasia pen after using this 5
AL from CO
This surpassed my expectations. It's highly pigmented and creamy while being very easy to apply. The brush is very soft and diffuses the color evenly. This still looks great at the end of the day. I definitely recommend this for those who like dark and bold eyebrows, but works easily for a natural soft look as well. I have black/dark brown hair and like the color Espresso the most.
Favorite eyebrow product 5
Anjy from Chicago, IL
I'm a beginner when it comes to brows and this is so easy to use and I love the brush on the other end that helps tone and balance the color. I got brunette which seems a little dark so gonna try chocolate next.
Best eyebrow product 5
Em from USA
This eyebrow product is both affordable and works great!
So easy to use! 5
Cpatsy from Jacksonville, FL
I would not consider myself a professional by any means when it comes to makeup - especially brows. I have thin blonde eyebrows and I love the NYX pencil but it takes me FOREVER to fill them in with that. I bought the pomade hoping it would be more efficient for workday mornings and I love it! I outline the bottom of my brows with the pencil and then fill them in with this and I honestly think I like the look of the pomade better. It attaches to the hairs and make them appear darker and thicker so I think this makes them look way more natural! Would definitely recommend
Nice! 5
Step78 from Chicago
This product is easy to use and gets the job done, fills my brows in quick and does what I need.
It's the "ARCH" for Me 5
aQueen2adore from New Jersey
I found my favorite eyebrow pencil….NYX always delivers that good good
Forgot I had it. 5
MUAcosmo from Wichita
I purchased this a year ago and used it once and didn't use it again. I went through all of my eyebrow products and found it. I decided to try it again. I have thin eyebrows and I want them to be fluffy and full. They are also blonde even though my head hair is brown. Unlike a pencil this coats the hairs. It's not as messy as pomade in a pot. I love the brush because it smooths it out and fluffs my eyebrows. They look thicker than they have before. I'm so glad I found this.
I would buy this product in the future again 5
Kirry from Illinois
Excellent
My favorite eyebrow pencil 5
alexarose from wilm, nc
I have repurchased this many, many times and has been my go-to pencil for over a year. I like that the pencil is retractable and at an angle so it makes it easy to fill in the tail of your brows. It has an actual brush rather than a spoolie which I also like. I think it helps me smooth my eyebrow hairs better.
Love this eyebrow pencil 5
Anne from Birmingham, AL
This eyebrow pencil goes on so easy, and it looks very natural. I have some areas where there's not much brow, and this product fills in perfectly. Doesn't look like I am overly made up. And the pencil lasts a long time.
creamy & smooth 5
k saelee from California
it's like a pomade in a pencil form. love the consistency & the eaze of filling in brows quickly. the brush combs through brows & fills sparse areas easily as well. will def be my go to from here on out.
Good and economical 5
SicilianPrincessa from NC
Love this. Stays put and the shape of the product is perfect to get the desired shape brows.
Love the brush, meh on the color Espresso 4
essdubz from Chicago
Dark brunette here with almost-black brow hair. I like an ashy-cool dark brown, and Espresso was warmer than I'd hoped. Maybe the Black would be better, but it looks pitch black in the product swatch, hmm. The paddle brush is great, though — really helps give that soft fluffy brow look. Will use the brush with my beloved Elf Instant Lift Brow Pencil ($3!) in Deep Brown — the perfect cool, buildable dark brown.
