Product Reviews Rated 4.46 out of 5 stars
370 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I thought I couldn't easily wear liquid eyeliner anymore I have a much younger sister and was recently the maid of honor in her wedding. The makeup looks she chose had a winged eyeliner. I gave up wearing liquid eyeliner in my 30s when my eyes became hooded and I started to get creases. I decided to try this one because I liked the idea of it helping lashes grow and I chose Brown because in my thirties I also gave up wearing black liner. I felt like black liner has a bit of a blue undertone and I wanted something that matched the brown in my hair and eyes instead of contrasting it. I really didn't think I would be able to use this product but I was pleasantly surprised. The tip is amazing. I have never used a better applicator for eyeliner, ever even brushes. The brown is a nice, fairly dark color but goes on thinly so if you make a mistake it's not that noticeable. I usually just do one line if I'm in a hurry and I will do three or four coats when I want more intensity. It also feels really good going on the eyes. It is cooling and feels nice to put on and does not tug at all. It doesn't stay perfectly so I recommend putting on an eyeshadow primer underneath. It's also not smudgy. It just sort of disappears a little bit throughout the day without a primer. Anyway I absolutely love it and it's now my everyday eyeliner.
Most Helpful Critical Review Something's changed I think something changed since the last time I bought this eyeliner. It's still easy to put on and gives a great dramatic line but now it makes a mess around my eyes! The old version with the smooth-edged pen would stay on and not budge AT ALL. This new version with the water drop textured pen has made a mess on my face - there's darkness under my eyes from smudging and when I swipe my finger over the line it comes off which it never did before! I still like the line it makes but I miss it's old staying power.
Reviewed by 370 customers This is the best 5
glowyl from undisclosed
This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. The formula is super amazing as it doesn't smear or leak. It is truly black and waterproof I have very watery eyes and it never smudges. The tip makes it really easy to do winged liner. Amazing product that I recommend to beginners who are starting out with eyeliner!! 
Holy grail 5
Madison B from Olympia
The best liquid eyeliner I've ever used. I love this stuff so much.
Not a fan , 3
shamailak1 from undisclosed
Not a fan , the color is a very faint black almost gray looking. I prefer a more bold liquid eyeliner.
Application is very smooth. 4
bailey1720 from undisclosed
Application is very smooth. The black is pretty prominent and is not for a subtle look!
Love this product! It's 5
kyleer19 from undisclosed
Love this product! It's so easy to use. I have a really shaky hand so I love how fine tip it is. I would absolutely recommend this. It stays in place really well.
So Disappointed 1
Anna0996 from Edmonton, Alberta
I wish I could give this negative stars, it's so bad. So, I bought this a few weeks ago and didn't get around to using it until this afternoon. I have an eye that likes to water for no reason, so I'm always looking for a GOOD waterproof eyeliner. This ain't it. 20 minutes after applying I had eyeliner running down my cheeks and friends were asking if I was okay. I wish I could get a refund I'm so upset with this product, it's immediately going in the trash. I'd share a photo but it all smudged away so there's no eyeliner left. First and last Physician's Formula product for me.
I have used this 5
lindsayw71 from undisclosed
I have used this eyeliner for years. The application is smooth and very black! The tip makes a winged line like no other!
This is my favorite 5
leidyo11 from undisclosed
This is my favorite eyeliner. I use it in my daily routine, especially, the brown one because it give a natural look and stays all day long. It is a must have wherever I go
This is my all 5
maryp232 from undisclosed
This is my all time favorite liquid liner! I also love it in dark brown. The brush is perfect, can get such crisp and clean lines. It does NOT fade easily and stays put!
This is my all 5
beths135 from undisclosed
This is my all time favorite eye liner (and I have tried a lot!). It goes on smooth and controlled and lasts all day.
It is by far 4
gypdymundo from undisclosed
It is by far the best eyeliner. It stays on all day, probably could stay longer. And it's so easy to apply. The only problem after few weeks/month it started leaching. I would open it and it would literally drip black ink. I thought maybe it's just bad or broken. I bought it again and the same thing happened. Very sad
Hello I have been 5
hannahd253 from undisclosed
Hello
I have been using this eyeliner for a long time . I absolutely love it so much . It's the best . 1) long lasting 2) you get the perfect wing liner 3) matte black I highly recommend you try this liner . It's so good and it's the only liner I use .
My favorite eyeliner. I'm 5
victoriag270 from undisclosed
My favorite eyeliner. I'm not great with liner and have found this one the easiest to use. I get crisp lines and it is nice and black. I have no problem going over shadow even with glitter. I will continue to repurchase.
Flaky 1
Lisa from Phoenix
I purchased this liner since the reviews looked good but after applying the liner it only looked good for three hours. After three hours it started to crack and flaky off. Never purchasing this one again.
I got this product 2
jennyb72707 from undisclosed
I got this product in the color black and it was showing up more like a grey. I really had to work with it to even get it to show some pigment on my eyelids. I would recommend something better than this
Very easy to apply 5
Marilynrose4 from Palm Springs, CA
This eyeliner is the best I have ever used. it goes on so easy.
As someone with very 5
sugarhooker from undisclosed
As someone with very sensitive eyes eyeliner can be a bit hard for me to find especially a waterproof liquid. This one works so week. It's Hypoallergenic so it's doesn't irritate my eyes and stays online day and night! This is a new fav!!
My Holy Grail Liner 5
Evie from Los Angeles
The best of the best eyeliners. Lasts all day! Non irritating.
My favorite makeup product 5
trinityb45 from undisclosed
My favorite makeup product of all time I love this eyeliner so much it's very pigmented easy to use long lasting I highly recommend this eyeliner I'm always asked what eye liner I use and get tons of compliments I highly recommend this product I'm in love and will totally buy this over and over!
One of my favorite 5
joannah55 from undisclosed
One of my favorite eyeliners ever. The felt tip is perfect. Does not smudge through the day and I like the smell of it too!
i bought this product 5
lifewithjess88 from undisclosed
i bought this product after running out of my favorite high-end liner and it has since become a staple in my routine.
Best eyeliner ever 5
Farzana from New York
It is the best black liquid eyeliner. I tried other eyeliners, high-end and drugstore, but I always come back to this. The pen feels luxurious. I love the brush tip applicator. It's not too long and not too short. I can make the line very thin or thick based on my mood. It gives a nice dark matte black eyeliner. It doesn't feel tight or doesn't peel off if I put another layer on top. Great tear duct lining with the tip. The only issue I did have with this eyeliner is that I did ruin the brush tip with the cap due to my own negligence. Just be careful while closing the cap.
Goes on beautifully and 5
melindag8890 from undisclosed
Goes on beautifully and stays thru tears very easy to do a cat eye or really anything . It's jet black and love the water drops on the packaging. Definitely looks luxurious and super easy to control. Definitely worth the money I paid.
Tip frayed on second use 2
Disappointed in PF from Philadelphia
Wanted to love this liner but the tip frayed on my second use. Tried trimming the strays but it didn't help. Only got one use out of it. Very disappointed!
Excellent! I have the 5
natakrasota from undisclosed
Excellent! I have the black color and I bought the brown color, the tip of the eyeliner is gorgeous and easy to shape and the color is very clear and deep! I highly recommend it.
