Product Reviews Rated 3.47 out of 5 stars
985 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review The only mascara that matters anymore This is by far the best mascara on the market and I've tried them all. I honestly can understand how anyone has had a problem with this product because I've rn blown away. I have naturally long and full lashes so Iv been searching for a mascara that will be volumizing but not clumpy or too thick. This mascara was able to wrap every lash in a perfect coat of mascara giving me the full dark lashes i've been searching for. I had no issue with the wand wing too big, the wand never even hit my eyelid or anything. On top of that I went to the beach later on in the day it was 93 degrees out and it didn't budge from sweat even a little. When I went in the ocean I was knocked down and completely submerged by waves multiple times and somehow the mascara stayed 100% in place, no smudging or racoon eyes or anything, just perfect lashes. By the end of that day the mascara was still in place and my lashes looked exactly how they did when Iapplied this. I never write reviews but this product deserves recognition. If your looking for dramatic eyes and want a mascara that is SERIOUSLY water proof this one is easily the best choice. My new absolute favorite product!
Most Helpful Critical Review Was excited for this product but it's a complete fail Super disappointed. I was really excited for the release of this but it let me down in so many ways.
First, as many have pointed out, the brush is HUGE. I have medium-sized eyes with hooded lids. I was able to apply it without getting it everywhere, but it was not easy.
Second, the packaging itself is larger than it needs to be, and as a result I was unable to fit it in my usual makeup bag (which has always been able to hold my mascara). It also wasn't particular comfortable in the hand.
Third, while the product itself performed decently (the first couple of uses), I saw no improvement over other, less-expensive mascaras. Honestly, there really doesn't seem to be a point to having such a huge brush... it didn't do anything.
But this is where it really started to go downhill.
After just a few uses, the "hourglass" design of the brush showed its poor engineering. The product began to collect in the middle of the brush (in the "skinny" part of the "hourglass") where the tube couldn't pull it off. The brush quickly began to degrade from there; the bristles are soft, so they began clumping together and being sort of flattened, until it got to the point where you pretty much just got a huge dollop of mascara when you pulled the brush out of the bottle.
So after about a week, it became all but useless. I gave it a few more tries before throwing it out. I'm very glad I used points to get this, and didn't pay actual money, or I would've been pretty upset because this is one of the more expensive mascaras out there.
Would not buy again, and would not recommend.
Reviewed by 985 customers Too clumpy and burns 1
BB from Richmond VA
Writing this with an eyes full of tears because the wand deposits a lot of mascara into the eyes with every use. My lashes look fuller I guess but I've gotten much better results with different products without the eye irritation.
Negative comments 5
Cidemil from Chicago
I don't understand the negative comments at all. This mascara is beautiful I had zero issues zero clumps. It gives at full volume affect the comb as beautiful as well.One of the best mascaras out there. Maybe some people need to learn how to put mascara on or have a defective mascara because I did not experience any of these issues
Definitely Not 24 Hour 1
sjh03 from WI
This mascara is terrible. I've gotten multiple samples and I've really tried to like it and give it a chance, but it is not good. Smudges everywhere. Wand is so thick, it takes forever to get anything off of it and onto your lashes. It also seems to dry out really fast so the packaging must not be full proof? Would not recommend.
I would not buy this product again 1
MrsB from San Antonio
Mascara became clumpy immediately. I got one good use out of it. By day two it looked like it was a month old product and it weighed my lashes down
I hate everything about this 1
Tasha from Michigan
Just awful. When I first pulled the wand out of the tube the product was such a thick globby mess I couldn't even see the bristles on the wand. I felt like I had to clean so much of it off the wand before I could even use it. The wand itself is also huge but really flimsy. All of that combined makes it difficult to use without making a mess of your whole eye. Overall, it didn't do much for my lashes, maybe a little bit of volume but nothing that wowed me. Plus, it began to flake off after just a couple of hours.
lots of volume! 5
Hannah from Pennsylvania
This is my favorite mascara. Makes me look like i have false eyelashes on
The only mascara I will use 5
Jen from Indiana
Before this one, I used Too Face better than sex mascara. When this came out it changed everything. I prefer mascaras that add a lot of volume and length. This one is perfect for that. Please never stop making this stuff its the only mascara I will ever use!
Fullness without flakes! 5
Eyes from MSP
Gives great fullness and separation, but not spider leg style. Also no flakes that other mascara leaves under eye throughout the day.
Only mascara I buy! 5
Nichole from Michigan
I get compliments often on my eyelashes. They ask what mascara I use! I don't have naturally dark or thick eyelashes either!! I have to apply a few coats but I do with all mascara, but I only use this mascara! The wand does come out kinda clumpy sometimes but never clumps my lashes, not sure how that works?
This mascara is a train wreck 1
GG from Spokane
Waste of money.
I would buy this product AGAIN, IF 3
Law 2022 from Southern Maryland, USA
I've wear make-up everyday, I have for years! This mascara's formula is great, however, the wand within is way too big and thick! I feel a thinner want would do WONDERS for this mascara. I would definitely buy it again IF this change were made.
'
Used to Love it, but... 3
Mezzogirl from Savannah, GA
This used to a be a 'go-to' mascara for me, but the last one I bought smelled terrible and was definitely not the same formula as before. I do love the fat brush, but couldn't get over the smell.
Clumpy 2
Esther96 from Wyoming
Idk if I got a bad one but it was so clumpy and the formula makes the wand look like it's caked on and dry. But it does make your eyelashes longer and thicker, starts flaking after a couple of hours.
Too thick 2
essyla from MI
It works
I would buy again 4
CM from Tampa Fl
My lashes look fuller and longer
Not for me. 1
DM from NM
The product comes out super chunky and I had to use a different wand because the one it came with was too packed with product.
Disappointing 1
Mel from Texas
I bought this because it was on sale a while back and it's bad. It's clumpy and does nothing to make your lashes look good. The essence lash princess easily destroys this for less than half the price.
Worst mascara I've used 1
P_Whaley from Hinesville,GA
My ultra was out of the better than sex mascara so I figured I'd try this one. The mascara barely comes off my brush onto my eyelids and it definitely doesn't lift of add any volume my lashes look like spider legs
I love it 5
Lace from USA
My absolute favorite mascara!! I got it as a sample over 2 years ago and have never found anything better! BUY IT
Terrible 1
Alina from VA
I would give it a 0, but instead it gets a one. The wand was COVERED in mascara and the amount of product you had to scrape off for first time use was so wasteful and the bristles weren't there. It wasnt applicable the the wand wasn't even visible.
I would not buy again 1
G from Ohio
it is so bad waste of money. Clumps are the worst
No! Your eyes will burn 1
Ani Ick from Oklahoma
Was ok for about an hour then my eyes started burning and itching. I've never wanted a makeup remover wipe so bad in my life. I had to take my contacts out immediately.
PERFECT! 5
Sher from Florida
Anyone who says they hate this mascara, is probably a basic makeup wearer and has no idea how to use a high quality product like this. They should go get a basic mascara. If you want volume, length, thickness, and tons of product on the applicator to work with, THIS IS FOR YOU! Your lashes will reach the heavens, yall!
Not what I expected 1
SuzyQ34 from Charlotte, NC
It was so clumpy and just a mess. I never throw out mascara, but I did this. I tried cleaning the wand twice but every time it was just a mess. Very disappointing.
Clumpy 3
Gypsie from Dallas, Texas
I am really picky about my mascara. I'm always trying new ones to find the perfect one. This one is not it! It is one of the worst mascaras that I have yet tried. The wand is so big and heavy. The brush is too big to effectively apply the mascara without it getting on your eyelids. It simply just clumps. I can't use it. I do not recommend this product.
