Product Reviews Rated 4.18 out of 5 stars
638 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Five Stars I tried this mascara after my usual was discontinued. It was the second I tried following the discontinuation. Normally, I have an AWFUL time finding replacement products--especially mascara and foundation. So many mascaras have flaked into my eyes, worn off after a very short time, etc. Not Buxom Lash Mascara, though. It is the perfect combination of volume and length, withstands the nine hours per day I generally wear it, withstood a nap, and is all around awesome. I did touch it up after taking a nap even though it didn't really need to be, and it didn't turn into a flaky, dry mess even the way my discontinued one that I loved did with touch ups (its only flaw). My lashes look naturally long and voluminous with this mascara. Buxom, PLEASE don't discontinue or change this mascara at all! I will stop my search with this one and use it as long as it's on the market.
Most Helpful Critical Review Good for separating, but not much else I am always on the hunt for the next mascara. I am an Urban Decay Perversion user but am always willing to try new brands and types. This was recommended by an Ulta consultant so I picked it up. The brush is nice. I don't typically go for plastic bristle brushes but the bristles are super soft. This mascara does separate your lashes really well. Unfortunately there's not enough product on the brush and the formula is somewhat dry and thin. The coverage is just not there for volume or length. Ultimately I use it to separate my lashes for the next application of a better mascara. I will keep the brush, other than that it's not really worth the money.
Reviewed by 638 customers My favorite mascara 5
Britt23 from Texas
I love this mascara! Only full size mascara I've ever paid for (normally just get the minis in gwp). This mascara isn't going to give you false lashes, however, it's is extremely buildable without clumping. (Also great for fixing another brand of mascara that did clump) It wears amazingly! Texas heat &humidity no problem, laughing so hard you cry no problem! Want just a little mascara on for work, yup! Want to turn your look into glam for going out, yup works for that too! It also builds very nicely with other mascaras! I always put this one on last if I know it's going to be humid, never have no runny mascara with this one! And it's not waterproof so you aren't pulling eyelashes out trying to take it off.
Best mascara ever 5
Brie from Tulsa
I recently tried the waterproof and didn't like it but this one is amazing
Best I've ever tried
New formula sucks. Super dry. 1
Jennifer from Austin, Texas
This used to be my favorite mascara but the last three I have bought succkckkedddd. Super dry and gives you tarantula eyes. Won't be using this anymore.
Best Mascara If You Hate Clumping 5
beautyvariant from usa
I have naturally long eyelashes so I have tried many types of mascara, including using primers. Most mascaras are not made for people with long eyelashes, so they will overclump. My bottom lashes tend to have fall out flakes and leave marks under my eyes throughout the day, which is very annoying. Not with this mascara!
This is the first mascara I've found that gives me a natural long look, separates my eyelashes, and doesn't flake off. It's definately buildable if you want a more glammed look. The end of the wand works great for the outer corners of my eyes giving a more cat eye mascara, if that's what I want to do. If you like those super clump fiber mascaras, I don't think this will be for you, but if you like a more natural mascara look or have long lashes, go for this one. 10/10 obsessed with.
One of the best mascaras I can find. 4
NatLee from Melbourne
I've tried many mascaras and am stuck on this one. Creates a natural look but still luscious lashes. If yours is lumpy I suggest returning because it is likely old and should have been pulled from the shelf. Has only happened once or twice in the many years I've been purchasing this product.
Booooooo 2
MeganB from Ohio
What a disappointment. It has zero volumizing power. It barely even lengthens. It essentially does nothing and I don't even have super short or thin lashes. I hardly noticed a difference in length and noticed NO volume whatsoever. The only thing this is good for, and why it didn't get one star, is for separating lashes. I basically use it as a primer for my other mascara to strangle and straighten out my lashes but I definitely wouldn't wear it on its own
highly disappointed 1
Diotima from New Jersey
Nothing great about it. I returned it.
Too Thick 3
laina9 from MD
product too thick just like cement. never again
Too Thick 3
laina9 from MD
product too thick just like cement. never again
Empty bottle! 3
Elizabeth from Ca
received an empty container so I had to return
The best mascara I've ever used! 5
Annie from Arizona
I originally got a sample of this product and I loved the result! I've tried various high and low end mascaras and nothing was comparable to this one! Made my lashes so long, without being too clumpy or heavy.
My Fave! 5
Leila from Dublin
I have been using this mascara for years now, and it's truly my favorite. As new mascaras are coming onto the market as "the best", I sometimes try them out and go straight back to this one. No flakes, no smudging, separates and fluffs. It's awesome!
Made my eyelashes fall out 2
Ky from New York
I really wanted to like this mascara. My sister uses it and it works wonders for her lashes. I started using it about a week ago and my lashes are falling out like never before. My eyelids are practically bald. My eyes are pretty sensitive and I haven't read any other reviews where this happened so it may just be me…but I thought I'd warn any prospective buyers with sensitive eyes.
Repeat buy! 5
Kym8m8 from Georgetown Ky
The application brush is the secret ! I've bought this 3 or 4 times
I love this mascara!!! 5
Krystal from Greenville, SC
Love this mascara! No clumping! Looks like I have on lash extensions.
Yes 5
Grandma from IL
I was told to purchase this product on Black Friday because my granddaughter said she loved the product. So I did and I do like this mascara. Better then drug store items.
no 1
Duchess from Florida
Nothing good to say about this item
Love it! 5
Sophie from Scottsdale, AZ
My favorite mascara ever! I always get compliments on my eyelashes when wearing this mascara. It does a great job of adding volume and lengthening lashes.
I've Tried SOO Many 5
PeachyKween from Macomb michigan
I absolutely adore this mascara, it makes my eyes look so doey and I always get compliments when I wear it
The best Mascara on the market. 5
Esther from FL
I've used this for years. I've tried many others and nothing competes with Buxom. I especially like the wand size and the fact it doesn't ever flake or make my eyes irritated.
Horrible 1
H from Dc
This mascara is terrible. It flakes off all over my face and smudges my eyes throughout the day so I look like a raccoon. Do not buy
Great product 5
kja from Plano TX
Have been using this product for years tried others always go back to buxom
My Favorite Mascara 5
Sunkissed from San Diego
Luv this. After trying multiple brands always come back to buxom. Easy application with best results.
This mascara is AMAZING!! 5
JanP from Tennessee
This mascara is truly amazing! I definitely feel that this mascara is not talked about enough! I compared this mascara to a few of my other mascaras that cost a little more and some on the more affordable side and the Buxom one definitely out performed them. I curled my lashes and applied this mascara and my lashes looked so pretty for so many hours. It makes my lashes look so nice, long, separated and it doesn't get clumpy. I definitely recommend other people to try this product out!
Ok 2
Jenna Mae from Chicago
I got this mascara half off for Ultas 21 days of beauty awhile back...
It doesn't seem to do much for my lashes, but it's ok. My biggest issue is I cannot wear it on my lower lashes without looking like a raccoon 2 hours later. 😕