Product Reviews Rated 3.88 out of 5 stars
51 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Love! I'm gonna start at this mascara smells so good! And I love that! The wand and applicator puts the mascara on so good and very even. This is definitely my favorite and go to mascara and I would definitely recommend this is anyone!
Most Helpful Critical Review Smells Good...Goes on clumpy I used the Butter Blowout Mascara several times and I'm still on the fence of whether or not I like it. First impression...the bottle is beautiful and the product smells like the beach - coconut and islandy. I wish it went on smoother. My very first application was very clumpy. It reminded me of when I am using mascara and realize it's time for a new bottle...where it's dry and clumpy...except this was on my FIRST application. After I comb through the clumps, it looks nice...but I shouldn't have to do that right away like that. I probably won't buy this again.
Reviewed by 51 customers Good but not the best 4
Woodsy Girl from Indiana
I like this mascara but it's not the best I have ever tried. There are others I like just as well and are less e pensive.
Not what I expected 1
Lenna from Las Vegas, NV
I got this initially to try it after my favorite mascaras were discontinued. The first thing that hit me upon opening it was the strong scent. It went on smoothly, though a tad clumpy, but as I fanned it out, it kept clumping up and the scent kept burning my eyes. I decided to ignore that and just finish up my make up and go about the rest of my day. Bad idea. Throughout the day my eyes kept burning, this mascara kept flaking off until I had raccoon eyes, and weighed down my lashes so bad! I finally had to take it off as best as possible while at work because my eyes kept burning from it. I've tried it a few times after and each time it gave the same results. Ultimately it was a fail and has now been tossed. Lesson learned. Never use a mascara that has scent because it'll most likely irritate my eyes.
dry, clumpy, makes 0 difference 1
ac116 from Georgia
Avoid this mascara if you have the chance. I thought it would be great based off of its ingredients but it was wayyy too dry and left clumps on my eyelashes and even my face while I was putting it on
Love everything but the scent 4
Lentils from Toronto
I bought this a few months ago. I initially loved it. It has the perfect balance of not looking too overdone, but it's not too little either. The lashes are full and soft looking. Love it!
I even wore it while camping, and swam in it everyday. Even tho it's not waterproof, it wouldn't run and make a mess on my face. Some product would come off, but I didn't look crazy person after swimming in it! Super impressed! And then it washes off super easily with a regular face wash at the end of the day.
The downside: I'm not fond of fragrance in any of my makeup, and eye products in particular! Over time, my eyes became sensitized to this product They became unbearably itchy every time I wore it. I had to throw it out. :( If this came in a fragrance-free formulation ever, I would be super excited!
Would not recommend 2
Haleyrae from undisclosed
You have to keep putting on layers to even see a difference. It's kind of clumpy
Maybe It Was Expired 1
Michelle C. from LOUISIANA
The mascara had dried out. It was completely unsuable. I threw it away, I just did not feel like going through the motion of returning it.
Great mascara-terrible smell 3
Bonbon from Seattle
Smells so strong gave me a headache and doesn't dissipate, I don't recommend to anyone who is sensitive to smell. No exaggeration, people could smell my mascara as I walked by them... lashes looked flipping gorgeous tho so I kept trying to make it work but in the end it wasn't meant to be, other pros: easy to take off with warm water, no flakes, lightweight, buildable
Omg its amazing 5
Cosmic from .
It smells good and looks great. Not too natural and not too dramatic.
My new favorite mascara 5
Veri from San Diego, California
I wear a natural look. This mascara is buildable. Which is awesome for all looks.
Smells so good!!!!!! 4
Scary from Sac
Kinda clumpy and wet, big thick brush. Application doesn't clump too bad and finish is natural. THE SMELL THOUGH!!! smells like coconut cream idk so good!
Okay Product 3
JeniJenJen from undisclosed
I love the wand length, the color is good and the brush is perfect. The product itself however leaves something to be desired. It clumped up almost right away so that's a big no for me and my routine. It also doesn't disperse very well so the brush ends up with more on one side than another and I've tried using the tube to even it out but it doesn't work very well.
This is probably a good product for teens.
Smells nice 4
Hobsy from Austin, TX
Russ mascara isn't the best I've used but it isn't bad. I prefer a maximum effect without clumps. But this mascara can get clumpy. I plan to use it until it dries out; clumps can be worked out with a little effort. Smells good.
Smells great 3
Seasonc from undisclosed
This mascara smells great. I never thought I would say that about a mascara. A little clumpy and wet. The wand could be better. I used another wand from another mascara and had better results. It would be almost perfect if it had a different wand and smoother formula.
Love it! 5
Jen from MI
I am a lash paradise fan, But this formula works very well for me. Im unsure which I will buy next. I like that's this one doesn't weigh down my lashes, but it is a more wet application. So I tend to get it on my eyelid and stuff when applying. It not horrible but my lash paradise doesn't do me dirty like that. It also takes a couple of coats to get my desired look, but that doesn't bother me. Right now I'm torn between favorites
I had high hopes 3
Ana418 from PA
I recently bought this and while it smells good, the brush applicator isn't the greatest. It is hard to get all of my lashes since it is so thick and clumps my lashes together. If I could get my money back I would.
Scent and performance 5
rlmne2000 from Michigan
Smells like coconut! Thickens and lengthens and lasts...
Works well not to mention smells so good! 5
sixashleys from AL
This mascara is absolutely amazing, i love it! It goes on smoothly. It smells great like coconuts and came in a nice full size container! A few coats and my lashes are longer and softer than other mascaras. Good product!
Nope!👎🏼 1
Sonya from Wyoming
Mine came broken! The wand was broken, it was very oily, and had a very strong smell.
There are better lash hair mascara 1
Hana from California
I don't have sensitive eyes or skin, I don't really ever have to think about what eye products I use, but this makes my eyes burn. Not anything crazy, more like if you have a pollen allergy and you can feel it in your eyes. When you pull the wand out for use there is a huge glop of product at the tip of the wand, like a pea size of toothpaste. It doesn't hold a curl and my lashes didn't look any longer than usual... it doesn't clump but it transfers and feels like it never really dries down. The new elf mascara is a better mascara than this, and that one isn't that great wither.
Not for me 2
Loves makeup from NY
This was very clumpy and hard to comb the clumps out. Did not add length. Volume was decent but too clumpy.
Great features! 4
dlej1972 from New Jersey
This mascara is good quality and smells nice. It is a nice color and adds length to your lashes. The only problem with it is that it is easy to over do. It is not waterproof but it does last for a while.
Nope 1
ML from MA
Clumps going on. I have to use 3-4 coats, my usual mascara only requires 2 coats to get the look I want. It flakes off terribly. By the end of the day, the area around my eyes is covered in black specks.
Super natural and gentle 5
Koko25 from Boulder, CO
Overall really great product. Doesn't cake like most mascaras and overall comes off easily without have to scrub too hard. You can tell it's a more natural product and as a result it looks more natural going on. Definitely a new favorite.
Makeup ! 5
Mulaa from Detroit
Ladies ladies ladies!! This mascara is absolutely amazing i love it & normally i am the one to wear lashes but the volume of lashes that this mascara gives us absolutely amazing and now when i can't wear lashes this is my go to product
Looks great! 5
Jo4444 from Thompsonville MI
This Butter Blowout Mascara looks great on my eyelashes. It is not clumpy. It goes on smoothly. It smells great like coconuts and came in a cute full size container. It definitely extends my lashes and seperates my top and lower lashes. The black stayed on nicely throughout the day without getting all over my face. At the end of my day it rinses off easy enough with soap and water. I have recommended to a few of my friends.