Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review This product has a...
This product has a twist up mechanism to reveal the pencil and a built in spoolie brush at the opposite end. As advertised, the pencils small size allows for precise application, which is particularly helpful if you want your strokes to mimic natural brow hairs. The spoolie is pretty standard, though it is not scratchy at all. The color pay off is good, depositing enough color to make a difference in a stroke or two without being so pigmented that your get an overly dramatic look on the first swipe. I found it held up well throughout a standard work day without smudging or fading. PROS : Slim design makes it easy to draw hair-like strokes on brows. Spoolie brush isn't scratchy. Color is not overly bold or too light. Wears well throughout the day.
Most Helpful Critical Review Bring back the old pencil!
I have been using this product for years and have loved how easy it is to make your brows look precise and filled in. Within the last couple months there has been a noticeable change in the quality. It is much lighter than it used to be and takes me 3 times longer just to get it somewhat shaded in. It never fully has the completely filled in look that I go for and the color is much more ashy. I am so sad that this product changed and that I will have to do some searching for a new pencil that will give me the old formula's results.
Reviewed by 564 customers Great soft micro pencil
Lclynch from North Carolina
I really love a very skinny but soft/pigmented mechanical brow pencil and this one fits the bill!
Bebe from 816
This is the only brow pencil I use, and have used consistently for a couple few years now. The color soft brown is perfect for me. Love that it's retractable. The spoolie is a very nice touch, I use it to blend the inner most 1/3 of my brows. FYI though, you can buy it elsewhere for a little bit cheaper. The ingredients list isn't completely clean or 100% natural but it does omit alot of toxic ingredients. Combined with how well this product works for me personally, that doesn't warrant switching brands
Great Eyebrow Pencils!
Betsy Boop from Scottsdale Az
Perfect design for these pencils. Colors available good for everyone
Applicator not working!
AmandaLR231079 from Sydney
I'm so disappointed as I actually like the product and it's the only one I've found that gives me the finish I'm after, however after three uses, I was unable to twist it up any further.
Not recommended for beginners
kellyc from AZ
This is a very soft brow pencil so it's a little hard to work with. You need to be precise and use a light hand to get a good result. Once applied and blended out though it lasts all day for me. It's a good shade match as well.
Cat from somewhere over the rainbow
Skip the Overpriced Stuff
Liz from Chicago
This is a holy grail product. Does the same for a lot less. If you're going for a more natural looking brow then this is for you.
natural look eyebrows
Carol from PR
I love how natural this pencil looks on your eyebrows, same as Anastasia eyebrow pencil.
It 's a very short term temporary solution
Victoria from Plano Texas
Size of pencil is minimal ladra a few days color disappears in a few minutes
Favorite everyday pencil
Lpared from Makeup
I really love this product! It works really well. Not waxy and lasts all day for me. This is one of the best color matches I've found and I'm very happy with this product.
New everyday go to
Elle from Arizona
Used it everyday and I am happy with how long the product lasted before empty. My eyebrows usually stay on all day. Not really creating hair like strokes but I'm not looking for that.
My favorite brow pencil(but more shades please!)
Mika from Mission Texas
i love this brow pencil especially the amount of product in it for the price. It's very creamy and pigmented product. Nice and precise for those hair like strokes. Just wish there was more shades in this pencil since blonde is a little light for me and soft brown is too dark so i use the blonde for filling in and shaping and the soft brown for some hair strokes
I love this!!!
Emily from Greenville
One of the best drugstore brow pencils!
Can't twist up after visible product is used!
CJ304 from CA
What a waste of money! I loved the color & application - but when week one was done and I tried to twist it for more, there was no way to do that. It appears no one from Maybelline actually wears this product or they would realize this immediately. Quality of the product was awesome - worst dispenser ever. I want my money back!
Please Bring Back Define A Brow
HiBrows from Florida
I tried this Brow Ultra Pencil in Soft Brown for my full thick brows. I did not like this formula because it was not smooth, creamy easy glide on skin. Define A Brow in soft brown was perfect. It was creamy, smooth. No smudging or clumping dots and it dispensed reliably until the last of the pencil, lasting a long time. It was a bright green pencil with brown cap. I miss it. I wouldn't mind paying $10 for a better product like Define A Brow.
really really like this
Linzee from .
I have a very weird eyebrow color lol not really, they're brown, but I have searched and tried all kinds of brow powder, pencil, whatever, and nothinggg matched. it was either way too light, or wayy too dark. but this matches my brows perfectly :) I have pretty nice eyebrows and I don't need to fill them in everyday, but the times that I do, you can't even tell a difference. it's sometimes difficult to use because I have a big scar in the middle of my left brow, but I've learned to work around it
Why from Puerto Rico
I like to give products a chance but this is overpriced for a very small product, I could barely get anything out :/ kinda let down
Sk from Iowa
This pencil works so well. It fills in my brows nicely and doesn't move all day.
Good substitute for Anastasia Beverly Hills
Allison from Charleston WV
The pencil is much finer than Anastasia. I kind of prefer a softer pencil for blending but this one is great for detail work while Anastasia is not. The brush is small and stiff and the Anastasia one is a bit fuller and softer. Overall, color is great, texture is great, price is well worth it.
Favorite Brow Pencil
rroofe from Batesville, AR
This is my favorite brow pencil. I've tried others and come back to this so I've just decided to stick with it. I used this with a combo of the Milani brow flick style pen for a great combo.
Very natural looking
FFHGRAMMY from Miami
Very natural look to fill in and define brows
Hands Down Fav!
Jakki from Houston-Ish, Texas
I will purchase this product over and over again. The color deep brown is a perfect shade for me. It's not warm toned like most brown pencils.
Great eye product
Chris from San Antonio
Used this to fill in my brows and it is ultra slim that it makes it easy to fill.
GOLDEN BLONDE NOT ASH
Taylor from Federal way WA
I used to use the green define a brow by maybelline in dark blonde. Sadly it was discontinued. Switched to Anastasia not the biggest fan (unpopular opinion). Tried this out in blonde in hopes it would be a reincarnated version of the brow pencil I used to use. The application and quality is similar but the color is so off. I recommend this for golden blondes only not anyone who's ash or taupe it will not work trust me.
My new fave
Beezzy Bee from CA
I'm always on the hunt for the right/best brow product and this brow pencil is my latest find and I'm so happy with it! I love the slim lead of the pencil so I can fill in the parts where my brows are a bit sparse. I also love the shades of color offered in this pencil...I picked medium and deep brown and with these two, I can match pretty much any shades of hair color I have at any given moment. Recommend!!!!!