Product Reviews Rated 4.74 out of 5 stars
19 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great for everyday I'm a makeup minimalist and only use mascara and a little powder on a daily basis. Usually eyeliner looks a little too fancy on me for everyday.
But this eyeliner gifted by Eyeko is lovely for weekdays. Softer than black but still adds a little drama to the look. It doesn't imprint on my hooded lids, but if your eyes water the "wing" part of the cat eye could deteriorate a bit.
I love the applicator - very easy to use and achieve precise lines. Great product overall.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great rich brown, but fatally flawed The black Black Magic Liner is one of my favorites, I was excited to try this one. It is a rich warm brown with a slight glossy finish - very pretty! It's such a unique shade of brown - I don't have anything else quite like it in my collection (and there are a lot of them!). The same brush tip as the black one applies a crisp thin or thick line, even on my aged 47 year old lash line, with lots of fine lines and loose skin. Unfortunately, it starts to flake almost as soon as it dries down. Forget using a lash curler after application, it messes it up so much I need to reapply. Even if I don't curl, it's flaked noticeably within an hour. I've never experienced this with comparable liners (Stila, KVD, Clinique, etc.). Could be a dud - I bought it online, not in the store - but it's too expensive to try a second time, especially when there are so many other great brown liners - even if this one is an especially pretty brown.
Reviewed by 19 customers My go to every day liner! 5
Kayla from new york
I love the tip of the eyeliner, always helps me create the perfect wing. Never smudges off through my long work day. My holy grail product!!
Great rich brown, but fatally flawed 2
Mu from WV
The black Black Magic Liner is one of my favorites, I was excited to try this one. It is a rich warm brown with a slight glossy finish - very pretty! It's such a unique shade of brown - I don't have anything else quite like it in my collection (and there are a lot of them!). The same brush tip as the black one applies a crisp thin or thick line, even on my aged 47 year old lash line, with lots of fine lines and loose skin. Unfortunately, it starts to flake almost as soon as it dries down. Forget using a lash curler after application, it messes it up so much I need to reapply. Even if I don't curl, it's flaked noticeably within an hour. I've never experienced this with comparable liners (Stila, KVD, Clinique, etc.). Could be a dud - I bought it online, not in the store - but it's too expensive to try a second time, especially when there are so many other great brown liners - even if this one is an especially pretty brown.
Great product 5
Iryna from Chicago Illinois
Super eyeliner. Very bright color. Lasts well all day. It is applied to the eyes from the first time. Not imprinted. To summarize all the qualities of this eyeliner, it is a great product and gifted by Eyeko. I recommend and buy it as a gift to all my friends
My New Favorite Liner 5
Haylsudz from Houston, TX
Loving this eyeliner so far! I also adore the Cocoa color. The liner is super easy to apply and also is long wearing which I'm a huge fan of. I'm really happy I gave this one a try because it is my go-to liner now.
*gifted by Eyeko
Great 5
Ashliz01 from Auburn
Wonderful eyeliner!
Love This Edit 5
jnbpdt from Eclectic, AL
I received this product complimentary from Eyeko in exchange for my personal opinion. This liquid eyeliner is great! It goes on so smoothly. The line itself isn't too thick or too thin. It's just right. You can adjust your lines thanks to the calligraphy inspired tip. That makes it super easy to make all kinds of eyeliner styles with just one liner. It stays on all day and doesn't smudge from where you've applied it. I like that the look isn't as harsh as black eyeliner. This is a great way to accentuate your eyes with minimal effort.
Love quality 5
Maya from Charlotte, NC
I got this product complimentary from Eyeko in exchange for my honest opinion. This eyeliner's brush is so easy to use. I struggle to draw precision lines, but this brush makes it easier to apply makeup. I like the color. It is warm brown but looks dark brown. The eye liner aren't black but dark enough to be seen well. And the package it came in was just awesome. It is easy to apply, stays all day long, and easy to wash off.
Great for everyday 5
Lucy J from Omaha NE
I'm a makeup minimalist and only use mascara and a little powder on a daily basis. Usually eyeliner looks a little too fancy on me for everyday.
But this eyeliner gifted by Eyeko is lovely for weekdays. Softer than black but still adds a little drama to the look. It doesn't imprint on my hooded lids, but if your eyes water the "wing" part of the cat eye could deteriorate a bit.
I love the applicator - very easy to use and achieve precise lines. Great product overall.
I would buy this eyeliner again! 5
Carol lee from FL
This was complimentary from eyeko its the absolute best eyeliner out there. It glides amazingly on my eyes and it leaves such a nice finish, it doesn't look cheap and it stays on all day, my usual eyeliner would already wear off.
Great lightness of color 5
EyelinerMua from Los Angeles, CA
Eyeko gifted me this eye liner complementary for review purposes. I love the subtleness of the brown cocoa hot chocolate color this liner has. It is perfect for creating a lighter soft look rather than using black like I usually do. I will definitely be restocking on this eyeliner. I love the way it glides on my skin without pulling on it.
I will buy it again 5
Brikenda from New Jersey
Eyeko London brand looks so good and very unique! Never tried it before but since I tried felt in love with it! Black magic cocoa edit liquid liner js so good! Makes my eyes look very beautiful! Highly recommended it!
Perfect Eyeliner 5
lulurico from California
I got this complimentary from Eyeko London, the Black Magic Cocoa Edit Liquid Eyeliner ;The Eyeliner has a precise point giving to my eyes a nice shape and open my eyes beautifully. The eyeliner last all day ;easy to remove ;doesn't make any mess it leave a soft texture behind ;I am very happy with this high quality Eyeliner .
Wow! 5
Moe213 from Glendale, AZ
This liquid eyeliner is a must have for days where you want to have a natural yet glam makeup look. The eyeliner glides onto your lids with east & stays put all day. I was gifted by Eyeko. I wear this eyeliner paired with the Eyeko brown mascara for my naturally glam makeup days.
Perfect 5
Daiki from Va
This product received complementary Eyeko london. I try this Black Magic product for the first time: Cocoa Edit Mascara and I love it, my eyelashes make it very beautiful and it gives it a unique shape that is waterproof. recommended.
Got the look 5
Love2u from Grand Prairie, Texas
I wanted an eyeliner that will give me that defined look, and the Eyeko did just that, I love my stroke thick, it gave a good pigmentation with the help of the applicator tip , it was easy to apply and create the shape desired. It is long lasting and water proof, I received this product complimentary from Eyeko.
Brown Eyeliner Anyone? 3
LisaAnto from MI
I am a huge fan of brown eyeliner. Smudge proof and fade proof as it lasts all day. Defines my lash line exactly as I expect. Liquid liner is not the easiest to apply, but those that have experience, then this will be easy for you. Gifted by Eyeko.
Amazing eyeliner 5
Nikki H. from Worcester, MA
II received this product complimentary from Eyeko for free in exchange for my honest opinion. This is a nice liquid liner that goes on very smooth. The application is precise and leaves no spaces in between the line. It is a perfect dark chocolate brown color, and does not smudge at all! And it comes off easily with makeup remover. I would definitely recommend it!
Love it 5
Cecijj from NY
it is gifted by Eyeko. I have used couple days, and this eyeliner impress me. It wear it for 8 hours outside, and when I come home, it still shows exactly like morning, No fading, and still shows the color it is. So I love it so much!
Awesome product 5
Qi from NY
Gifted by Eyeko. It is Perfect for anyone who wants a slightly more subtle definition to their eyes. The Liquid Eyeliner glides onto the lids to create the perfect cat eye. It is
Smudge-proof and fade-proof, Long-lasting for up to 8 hours, Quick & easy to apply.
