Rated 3.99 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review BEST.. MASCARA.. EVER!!!!!!!
I feel like this is my DREAM mascara! I cant believe how well it works! I saw other reviews, with terrible things to say, but for me I feel like its the complete opposite.
Personally, I like very long lashes, separated, sweeping to touch my eyebrows. Naturally my eyelashes are straight, fine, and average length. But a simple curl with a lash curler, and 2 coats of this mascara, I have superstar lashes.
I didn't have any issues with clumping, or drying. My only tiny issue, and this is with every mascara I use, is smudging, I have very oily eyelids & Houston humidity, so when my eyelashes touch my upper lid you see some smudges. HOWEVER, some urban decay shadow primer = no smudges. I urge people to try this mascara for themselves!
The mascara brush is my favorite design, its slender, tapered, and rubber wand and tips are the best design. It combs through from root to tip leaving your entire lash covered and separated.
This mascara is either a love it or hate it. I definitely LOVEEEE it!
Please see the pictures I uploaded just so you have an idea of what the mascara looks like on by itself.
Most Helpful Critical Review Ridiculous
Bought this a couple weeks ago when they were advertising it at the front of the store. Seemed pretty good when I first applied it, definitely lengthened and defined my very thin lashes. But it did smudge a lot by lunch and when I went to remove it that night, nightmare! Would not come off! Flakes everywhere including in my eyes. Gave it a couple more tries, wish I hadn't. Third day I wore it and removed it I ended up at the opthomologist with a scratched eye from the flakes! Never use again! Be warned!
Reviewed by 4657 customers Brush too flimsy.
Kazia True Review from Beaverton, Oregon
The brush is too flexible to put a thin layer on lashes. Plus it smears after a couple hours if I touch my eye. I wasn't impressed.
Lashes look great!
Crystal0429 from Vidalia, LA
I love this mascara! It makes my lashes look full and long!
Lashes look great!
Crystal0429 from Vidalia, La
I love this mascara! It makes my lashes look full and long!
i love this product
me from austin, texas
it went on very smooth and i love how it made my lashes look
The only mascara I'll ever use
Madison from NY
One of the biggest things I look for in a mascara is whether or not it flakes a few hours after wear. This one does NOT! The formula is very lightweight and builds me which is what I move. Definitely recommend for those who want something light!
I would buy this product again and again!!
Chas from Illinois
I love how long and full my eyelashes look!
Ashley from Houston
I absolutely love this mascara! It's by far my favorite one, honestly this is the only one I use when I don't wear falsies. I'm literally obsessed with it right now.
Sarah2679 from Greenville, South Carolina
I bought this off the many recommendations I have gotten about how amazing this product was and an I live the type of brush they have however I hate the actual mascara it's terrible! I tried it for two weeks and it clumped every time on my lashes and look horrible.
Buy if you'd like to spend 20 minutes fixing
Jamie from Colorado Springs
I bought this in a set after a worker said this is a popular mascara right now. I put my good ol trusty back for this hot mess. The concept of this wand is great, but the final result was a flop. Do not recommend. Perversion by Urban Decay LOVE!!
Mandy marieee from St pete FL
Prob the best mascara ever. Makes my lashes look like I'm wearing falsies! Will never use another!
E from Michigan
For volume and length it's pretty good. But it clumps and breaks apart throughout the day. It's KNOWN for flaking onto your face. Yikes.
omg its amazing
ryan from atlanta, georgia
okay before getting this mascara, i didnt really think there was much of a difference in mascaras but after buying this...there is. this mascara never smudges under my eye, gives me perfect volume and seperation. its absolutely stunning. 10/10
One of the best
Harleyn21 from 204 Washington st
I love how it makes my lashes look!
Truly one of the best on the market!
Allison C. from Elgin, Illinois
I went from L'Oréal's Lash Paradise, to Maybelline's Colossal, to Too Faced's Better Than Sex Waterproof, all the way to this. I'm officially never going back to any other black mascara ever again. This is the perfect mascara for someone who's looking for all 3 of the main benefits that come with mascaras. It volumizes, lengthens and curls! Total game-changer!
Whiskey Angel from Illinois
This mascara is good for about an hour. Initially my lashes look fantastic, then it's a flaky mess! By the end of the day most of it has flaked off. Not worth the price!
I love it! 💘
Lucy from Brownsville tx
I love this mascara.
TikTok made me buy it
C from Fargo
I bought this because I saw a girl on tiktok say it was her number one mascara of all time. I would have to agree, I love what it does to my lashes and it really makes my eyes pop. I love and will probably buy again. Holy grail!
I have used this product for a year now
mmae from NY
Have used MANY different mascaras over the years. This is by far one of my favorites. Goes on easily and quickly. Lasts a long time, non-smudge nor does it come off when eyes water. Comes off with soap and water, mostly.
Not My Favorite
Ava from NM
I would say I have had this mascara for a month and it's already dried out. I used the Benefit Cosmetic They're Real! Lengthening Mascara before this and I loved it. I also love Benefits Gimmie Brow Gel. If you are looking for a mascara this one has an amazing formula, you would unfortunately have to purchase it frequently.
Best/Fav Mascara of all time
Wand is KEY from Maryland
I LOVE the wand..I struggle with mascara in general. I usually rotate between samples that I like just enough. Honestly, my lashes look the best they are gonna look with this product. The wand is straight and just slightly wider at the bottom and this allows me to get every lash.
CooleyK from NC
It'll give you volume but it is also terribly hard to get off! When I tried it took off some of my natural lashes! Be careful if you are sensitive.
Hay from Conway
This mascara is the best I have tried. I keep trying other mascara because I'm always on the hunt for the next best thing. But I always come back to this one.
I LOVE THIS MASCARA! ❤️💯👏🏻🏆🔥
Dana from Newport Beach, California
I have to say, IMO, Benefit does a GREAT mascara. I have tried them all but this one really does give may fine straight lashes a BANG! Yes, there are a million mascaras out there, and I've probably tried them all, but this one is something special. It's a really dark black, does NOT clump, separates the lashes well, and keeps the curl in my fine straight lashes. The one thing that I seriously appreciate about this mascara is the wand shape. It's so easy to coat all the lashes with a normal wand like this instead of the big, bulky, hour-glass shaped wands that are extremely popular in every mascara out there right now. It took me a while, but I finally found the perfect mascara that my lashes love. ❤️💕🏆✔️💯🤩
BEST $ SPENT
lil from Oregon
I have spent so much money on mascara over the years and never loved one as much as Bad gal bang. Every time I find a mascara I like the formula eventually changes and it irritates my eyes horribly or they get rid of it all together. I've been using this since it came out and it's absolutely amazing! Definitely recommend and currently stocking up on all Xmas goodies from benefit with Bad gal bang in them.
Not a fan.
Christine from St. Louis
Love Benefit, always used Roller Lash & love it. Saw a lady raving about this one on Tiktok so I thought I'd give it a go. It's great at first but went flaky and I kept seeing it bleed off my lower lashes. Going back to Roller lash.