Rated 3.99 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review BEST.. MASCARA.. EVER!!!!!!!
I feel like this is my DREAM mascara! I cant believe how well it works! I saw other reviews, with terrible things to say, but for me I feel like its the complete opposite.
Personally, I like very long lashes, separated, sweeping to touch my eyebrows. Naturally my eyelashes are straight, fine, and average length. But a simple curl with a lash curler, and 2 coats of this mascara, I have superstar lashes.
I didn't have any issues with clumping, or drying. My only tiny issue, and this is with every mascara I use, is smudging, I have very oily eyelids & Houston humidity, so when my eyelashes touch my upper lid you see some smudges. HOWEVER, some urban decay shadow primer = no smudges. I urge people to try this mascara for themselves!
The mascara brush is my favorite design, its slender, tapered, and rubber wand and tips are the best design. It combs through from root to tip leaving your entire lash covered and separated.
This mascara is either a love it or hate it. I definitely LOVEEEE it!
Please see the pictures I uploaded just so you have an idea of what the mascara looks like on by itself.
Most Helpful Critical Review Ridiculous
Bought this a couple weeks ago when they were advertising it at the front of the store. Seemed pretty good when I first applied it, definitely lengthened and defined my very thin lashes. But it did smudge a lot by lunch and when I went to remove it that night, nightmare! Would not come off! Flakes everywhere including in my eyes. Gave it a couple more tries, wish I hadn't. Third day I wore it and removed it I ended up at the opthomologist with a scratched eye from the flakes! Never use again! Be warned!
Reviewed by 4624 customers LOVE IT!
JJR< 3 from Albertville, AL
First time trying it and I am not disappointed! Makes my eyelashes 100000x longer !!!!! Does not smudge throughout the day (and I have normal to oily skin) this one and they're real magnet are my top 1 !!
Dkhb from Independence kansas
This mascara really makes my lashes look longer abs"and fuller.
The one I always come back to.
SleepyGirl from PEKIN, IL
I really love this mascara, and the fact that it comes in the small size is the icing on the cake.
mimi33 from Spokane, WA
I really love this mascara. The wand is dense, not fluffy, which I prefer. It really helps separate the lashes so no clumps! Makes for a perfect application every time. When removing, it does seem to flake off which is annoying, but I'm sure that is because it is water resistant. Wish it came in water proof! I really like the applicator.
Hands down best mascara I have ever used!
Jewelgirl2 from Marietta, GA
My absolute fav mascara and I have tried so many different brands.
Smudges Under Eyes Within a Couple Hours of Wear!
vnb from MT
I am a big fan of the Benefit cosmetic line, nearly every product I have tried has been amazing. I had very high hopes for this, and had come from using the Roller Lash which held up decently throughout the day. After about two hours of wearing this mascara I had big black circles under my eyes from it smudging. I have to remind myself to wipe underneath my eyes all day.
Ok, but at a premium
Ash from SoCal
I like the wand and the volume, but the outcome was only a slightly cleaner looking than my local drugstore volumizing mascara. Not worth the price difference to me.
one of my favorite 2 mascaras - love the mini size
Jen from Delaware
I have fine, light, occasionally sparse, fairly straight lashes. They need all the help they can get. Even still, I like a less is more lash look. My makeup is on the natural side. I like the brush style, doesn't get too clumpy in my opinion. The tip is good for taking the brush perpendicular and getting individual baby lashes if needed. If you're light handed you can get a softer look, if you go heaver it's plenty dramatic. Coats good to the tip of the lash. Love the baby size, I think it stays fresher longer. I always flip flop between this and Clinique Lash Power
favorite high end mascara hands down
charity 138 from Louisville KY
so far I've tried a ton of high end mascaras. urban decay,lancome,Tarte, Clinique and I've gotta say without a doubt this is the BEST!!! it's not harsh not very messy easy to apply and the results are AMAZING!! looks like perfect size falsies.
Not for long lashes
Rachel from Philadelphia, Pa
I have naturally long lashes and like a few other reviews it just clumped mine together or made them really thin and weird looking. I still make it work by going over it with a clean more bristled mascara brush, overall the formula is great I just need to use a different applicator for my lashes
CSmith from 83544
I love the wand shape on this mascara! It's so smooth, but if you wait too long or not long enough in between coats, it will become clumpy. Other than that the application is so silky!
Linda from Florida
Wonderful brush makes lashes look great
ChrissyL from Cleveland, oh
Enhances my lashes BIG time.
One of the best out there right now
WorkFromHomeDogMom from Tennessee
This is the best mascara I have found in a while. I wasn't sure I would like the brush because I normally like brushes that are more bristly, but I gave it a try because I have been a fan of previous Benefit mascaras. I was also bummed at first that they had changed the Bad Gal mascara, but I ended up liking this even more than the original and the They're Real mascara. An appropriate amount comes out of the tube with the brush, it's not clumpy, and the small brush actually allows much more control in covering all your lashes. It's easy to apply if it's just for every day wear, but build-able if you want more oomph. It's definitely lengthening; you have to build it to get a lot of volume. It looks natural, has no scent and I actually like the tube itself - it's easy to grip instead of being slick and slippery. Another really nice product by Benefit.
bayyybee Audi from Buckner Illinois
this is the Gucci of Mascaras
Love this mascara! Makes my lashes so long and pretty.
Linda the Nana from Machesney Park Il
Don't need a lot of coats and lasts all day
Best mascara ever#
CJagmom from Ohio
I love this mascara! Gives good coverage and lift! Makes my eyes pop!
Ette from Baltimore, MD
It's a great mascara ! No negative issues!!
Didn't notice anything special
Cash from Hattiesburg
I didn't notice a difference between this mascara or a cheap brand. It did the same. I need a fat applicator to show a difference.
Best for Attention
Polished Nurse from Knoxville, TN
I use this mascara as my final layer to complete my look, usually focusing on the tips of my lashes to give them added volume & length. It literally gives them a "bang" and I love it. I will never stop using this mascara. Highly recommend.
boopsy from coral springs, Florida
I really wanted to love this mascara so much... the first mascara I bought went on beautiful separated the lashes they were full day almost looked like they were false lashes that's how good this mascara Works no issues.... I went back for another mascara , loose lips sink ships in less than a month because it doesn't last all that long... I also purchased along with it the tinted Brown lash primer... now I have noticed that the mascara smudges underneath my eyes halfway through the day.. I will take into consideration that could be the cause of the Lash primer so I will just continue using the primer and just the mascara. I really wanted to give it 5 stars but I think it needs some work don't like the idea of it smudging under my eyes.
Mascara- new to me
Renee from White Plains, NY
I was looking for a mascara to thicken my lashes. They are long but not thick. It does the job but I think I can find something better .
It's a keeper!
Jen from WA
This is my new go-to mascara! I love everything about it - it thickens and lengthens my lashes and doesn't flake off into my eyes like cheaper brands. This formula is worth springing for the extra $$.
I will buy this again
Mindy from Decatur, Illinois
This is my mascara!!!!
Who knows from AL - Alabama
The way it says I should.