Product Reviews Rated 4.28 out of 5 stars
139 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best Eyeliner For Upper Lash Line My search is finally over. This eyeliner is a deep but not too dark cool shade of brown. Most brown eyeliners look too dark for my fair skin and mature age. It's easy to apply and looks just as good at the end of the day as when I first apply it early in the morning. I apply over eyeshadow and I use Too Faced Shadow Insurance as a primer. I've tried many eyeliners over the years and this is the best one that I have found. The only con is that it applies very lightly on the waterline so I don't recommend it for that. I use Givenchy Khol Couture waterproof eyeliner pencil in Chestnut and that stays on fairly well. A good makeup remover specifically made for waterproof products is required. I've been using Clinique Take The Day Off For Lids, Lashes and Lips for many years and it works well without causing irritation. I use that first and then wash my face as usual. I highly recommend this pencil!
Most Helpful Critical Review Flakes off/ raccoon eyes. Definitely BAD Meh. My search for the replacement to my holy grail SELF SHARPENING (now discontinued) eyeliner continues. This eyeliner was promising but several times I found black flecks on my cheeks. I thought it was my eye shadow at first but then I went skiing and caught a glimpse of myself in my boyfriends sunglasses. I had eye makeup all down my face. Raccoon eyes. This is NOT waterproof. It's majorly disappointing. Why is it so hard to find a decent self sharpening eye liner!!!!!! I hate the ones that need to be sharpened because you end up wasting product and scraping your eye plus you have to drag around a sharpener with you. Save yourself the trouble and don't bother with this one.
Reviewed by 139 customers Best eyeliner I've ever used! 5
Tiff from Indiana
I love this eyeliner! Easy to apply! Waterproof!
Wouldn't buy this again - for liner dispenser - poor design 3
Berge from ID
Beware if you turn the tube to dispense product to see how much is left, you won't be able to get any of it to go back in to the tube! What a stupid design. Would not buy for that reason!
Smears and it doesn't last much. Thumbs down. Expensive too. 2
RIO70 from New Jersey
Junk
I buy it for convenience 2
Julie nurse from Washington
I wear it every day. It wears off and smudges within the first hour.
Easy to Apply, Really good staying power! 5
bettyboo from Arkansas
Sales Lady told me this was the best, I was skeptical but after using, I totally agreed with her opinion!
LOVE 5
Ashlyn from MI
Goes on smooth and lasts all day. Easy to apply for a beginner like myself
Sensitive Eyes Beware!!!! 1
Ali from Spartanburg
If you have sensitive eyes/skin this is not the eyeliner for you. I used this yesterday and my eyes kept getting more red throughout the day. I removed my makeup and washed my face before bed last night. This morning I woke up looking like I have pink eye in both eyes. My eyes are red, swollen, and painful. When I looked up allergic reaction to Benefit eye products I was surprised to see how many other people have had to same reaction.
Best Eyeliner! 5
Jordanzzz from Little Rock AR
I love this eyeliner! It stays in for hours and doesn't smear into your eyeshadow. I have not found a roll on that works any better. The only con is sometimes it shadows below the eye but a very light shadow super easy to remove.
The Best!! 5
Citygirl915 from New York
I have tried so many eyeliners searching for the perfect one and this is it. It glides on, lasts all day, doesn't smudge, is non-irritating, and easy to wash off.
My Favorite Eyeliner 5
DQUINN27 from Florida
This is the best eyeliner I've ever purchased! It glides on so easily, and it's like a cream based gel almost that says put all day. It's easy to clean up if you make a mistake but it's nearly impossible to do so because it is so easy to use! I hope they never discontinue it!
Best I've found 5
Dreamsinred from Medina ohio
I love it, lasts all day without smudging
No way is this 24 hour—24 minutes is more like it. 1
Erojam from New York, ny
Continuing my quest for a true long lasting eyeliner.
I love it! 4
CJ from Kenosha, WI
I bought it for the smudger. I ended up really liking the liner. Comes off easy with makeup remover.
My new forever eyeliner. 5
Mommyof5 from Northridge
I've always found myself going back to MAC engraved and have said my goodbye, this is the best eyeliner that you only need to put on once a day and it stays all day. my blurry vision and no smudge and it lasts forever, I swear. Try it, you'll never go back to the one you're using now.
Not impressed 2
Jessica from Ocala , FL
This product was recommended to me by my benefit brow lady. It does not apply smoothly and smudges i am still on the hunt for a quality eyeliner.
I loved it 5
Jh from Gainesville ga
Stays on does not smear or get under eyes!!
Best eyeliner pencil I've ever owned 5
Judy B from Orlando, FL
Thank goodness the Ulta representative told me about this product. It doesn't smear, doesn't run into my eyes and make them burn as the day goes on (a big problem in a moist climate), just looks great until I wash it off. With the gentle cleanser I use, it comes off easily when I wash my face. Another plus: You don't have to sharpen it as is needed with so many other brands, so there is no mess, and no waste!
Finally 5
Abbey53 from CT
I am pale with pale blue eyes and violet seems to look the most natural on me. This violet is perfect! I have been searching for a replacement for the beveled edge Dior pro liner that they no longer make. Every liner I tried was both hard to apply and either smeared or flaked off leaving me with purple or red streaks under my eyes. The Badgal liner glides on smoothly and stays put pretty well even with wearing a mask and breathing steamy air on it all day! I think once the masks are gone there will be no smearing at all.
Fantastic 5
Kkrenz64 from Covington, wa
Was looking for a gel eyeliner! I have tried so many! This one is worth every penny!!
No I won't buy again this 4
Tina from Greenville SC
I am very unhappy with my order.
I brought my benefit eye liner on May 8/2021 and it's deliver by May 12th and I used hardly 3 times and it's already finished!
I am going to try and return and ask for my money back!
Overpriced and doesn't stay on 1
Kristin from Naperville, IL
The salespeople at my local Ulta said this stuff was "amazing" and would stay on all day. What a joke! When I put it on it smears off or dissolves into my skin within 1 hour or less, no joke. The first day I bought it, I had to re-apply it about 8 times to make it even look like I was wearing eyeliner. Would never buy this again. Total waste of my money.
My Favorite 5
Pinney from Texaa
Love this eyeliner because I have sensitive eyes and thia is the only waterproofi liner that works without itchy eyes
Eye liner 4
Twylight from Oklahoma
Smooth application, good color. It does smudge after a while
I would definitely buy this again! 4
Danjah1 from Texas
I used this on my waterline and was amazed at how long it lasted! I had to go over water line about 3 times to get it as dark as I wanted. On my eyelid it's just glided on and lasted until washed off.
Tried purple 4
Color is your friend from Oregon
Decided to tried color eyeliner for first time. Looked in to color for many years
