Rated 4.38 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review 10/10
I came across this mascara and was kind of hesitant, but I am SO glad I purchased. This mascara does flake off into my eyes or irritate them in anyway & the length and fullness is out of this world. I'm obsessed with this product and tell everyone they need this mascara!
Most Helpful Critical Review Amazing, but transfers like crazy!
I got this as a birthday gift from ulta.
I rarely get excited about mascara as I have such short stubby lashes that it's near impossible to see any effect.
When I applied this the first time I was blown away by how amazing my lashes looked. They were long and voluminous without clumping or being too stiff. I had such high hopes for this.
Sadly, this is not a good mascara for those of you who have hooded eyes and/or are prone to sweating along the browbone area like I am. After less than 4 hours I had major transferring along the upper lid/browbone area, to the extent that I actually looked like I had two sets of eyebrows!
I love this mascara for how it makes your lashes look but I hate it for how much it transfers. If this was available in waterproof then this would be a holy grail for me but alas, it's not in waterproof yet so my search for an amazing mascara continues.
If you don't have hooded eyes or issues with sweating along the brows then this is fantastic, so whilst it didn't work for me I would still definitely recommend it.
Reviewed by 4304 customers I love this mascara! People always ask if my lashes are fake
Love My Lashes in MN from Minnesota
I love this product and use it every day! It really increases both the length AND volume of my lashes. People always say my lashes are beautiful and ask if they are false lashes. What a confidence booster!!
Gretchen from Rochester, MN
Great mascara! Goes on smoothly & even. I've had better luck with the regular vs the waterproof choice of this product.
Brooke from WV
Made my lashes appear fuller and thicker. Just wish the spoolie was a tad smaller so I didn't get it on my eyelids.
Heather from Ohio
I am always up for trying new mascaras especially when they're on sale like this one was during the 21 days of beauty sale. I loved this mascara at first. It made my lashes appear really long and added great volume, but just after a few uses it started to clump badly. I will try cleaning the brush as others suggested. However, I definitely recommend Smashbox superfan mascara over this one.
Leslie y from PA
I love this mascara it is the best ever. paired with the cils primer it makes me look like I have false lashes I love it.
Kind of love it...
Marcy from Florida
This mascara definitely delivers on lash fullness, but it dries out a little faster than other mascaras. Still a great product though.
shelby from madison ms
I did like it and still use it. ingredients seem to last and keep well. only gripe is that it clumps easily and I need to clean the wand off every other time I use it. almost there lancome. you're so close
Best Mascara Ever
Hannah from Ohio
I have tried SOOO many mascaras and I always come back to this one! It gives you the perfect amount of volume and length. Your lashes are left looking full without being clumpy! I have yet to find a mascara that competes with this one
I would by this product again! I like it in brown.
Gabby loves horses from Emerald Isle, NC
It is great, and I have no completes.
So Far, So good!
Femme Fatale from Savannah, GA
I was pretty upset when Benefit stopped making "They're Real" mascara in brown, so I thought I would
give this brand a try. I was pleasantly surprised that it made my lashes look fuller, and was available in brown. It's a bit pricey, but I will stick with it as long as it delivers. I think the wand/brush design is a plus
because it does allow me to get each and every lash. My lashes are not as thick as they used to be, but
I'm not a spring chicken anymore either. The real test will be this summer as the temps and humidity rise.
My new go-to!
Rawcal520 from Tucson, AZ
I thought my lashes were working against me with the last 4 mascaras I tried, until this one! It gives my average lashes the volume and length to stand out.
I would buy again.
Sally from Los Angeles, CA
I love a large round wand, this wand delivered just that.
Best Mascara for Day to Day and Dramatic!
Ashleigh from South Bend, IN
This product is my favorite mascara I have tried! If you want a more natural look, you can add one or two coats. It also builds really well for a more dramatic look if you add more coats! It doesn't flake or clump, stays all day, and comes off easily!
Really wanted to like this
Mariah from West palm beach
I really did like this product at first even though it is kind of a wet formula, but it's hard to get off and when it seems to make my eyelashes fall out even when I use coconut oil to get it all off. For something this pricey I don't want to damage my real lashes. Also Lancôme is not cruelty free
Two stars because it's not the worst
Raquel from North Carolina
The rave reviews convinced me I was missing out but this did not live up to the claims. I do not have issues with mascara smearing, drug store or high end. This mascara always smeared! It's volumizing but I also found it clumpy and my lashes looked wire-like. I like my mascara to make lashes voluminous and the ends of my lashes to taper. An extra star because it was not irritating to my sensitive eyes but I would not recommend
Goldie_indisguise from Cape Coral
I adore this mascara. Travel sizes are the best route to purchase any type of mascaras. I like to have my favorite brands & types in my Arsenal. Thicker & longer lashes with no clumping.
I love this so much
Daney from Tulsa, OK.
I use it on my eyebrows and it looks so good. I love it!
Monsieur Big Flakes
Georgia Mom from Marietta, GA
I always use Lancôme's primer with all my mascaras, so I tried Monsieur Big with it too. Love Lancôme, but sadly not this mascara. It's clumpy, took the natural curl out of my lashes and after a few hours, had flaked everywhere. I looked like I had little black freckles all around my eyes. Not a good look.
Smudges and clumpy
Anna S from Las Vegas, NV
I normally use Lancôme definicils and loooove it. I never experience any smudging with that product and my lashes separate nicely without a lot of extra work. This formula in comparison is very wet and clumpy. It smudges after wearing a couple hours which I don't really ever experience even with drugstore mascaras. I really regret spending so much for this and will have to buy another kind.
would buy again
rita from toledo
First mascara I've used that actually made my lashes look longer.
Love love this mascara
Stephannie from Baytown texas
Have been using this mascara for awhile. Makes my lashes look long and beautiful! Doesn't cake or flake off even after a full day
I keep going back to this one
Walker 37 from Indiana
I have used this for a couple of years now. I've tried other brands and always come back to this one as it's not irritating and it stays on without flaking.
Very good quality mascara
Emma from Sacramento.
This mascara is good for lengthening and natural look. It is very smooth and won't clump. Very easy to remove when washing your face and it will stay on throughout the whole day. If you want the very best look with this mascara when wearing a full set of makeup, I would really recommend getting the primer (it's a white color case) as well. If your an everyday mascara user you would definitely benefit from this because it helps keep your eyelashes healthy and beautiful with the mascara. I am a big mascara user and I have noticed that my eyelashes get really dry which could lead to eyelashes to fall off. But when I bought the primer which the mascara,I noticed my eyelashes were shinier and stronger. I really do recommend this mascara but also the primer. There both really good. Ps. The primer helps with any other mascara, this mascara is really good and didn't damage my eyelashes, I was just giving an example of how MY eyelashes get really dry because I use many mascaras, but with the primer I've seen my lashes more stronger. (:
Only mascara I will use.
Vickie g from Eagan mn
💕💗 this product
I can't believe I don't like this!
Nikki from NYC
I've only heard great things about this mascara since it came out but I didn't jump on it right away cuz I already have my holy grails, TF BTS and Essence Princess. Then these went on sale so I figured I'd get them. I was actually SO sure I would like these that I bought 2 - 1 black, 1 brown. You can't build this mascara up, I thought it might be too wet but I couldn't build it up once I dried it out a bit either. I love my favorite mascaras because I can build and build if I want extra thick lashes. This really gives you a much more natural look and being that it doesn't do much more than darken n lengthen them a little, you can get that from elf for a couple bucks and save your $ Just sayin...