Rated 4.55 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing staying power
I adore these caviar sticks! I have all but quit using powder eye shadow, and I adore Laura's eye shadow, too. Anything that I can do with a powder eye shadow, I can do with these caviar sticks. BUT, the best part of all is they stay on my lids FOREVER with no creasing at all. You've got to work fast during application and before they fully "set" because they aren't going anywhere after that. I highly recommend this product! And PLEASE, PLEASE, Laura, add some matte shades. :)
Most Helpful Critical Review Too glittery
I was a huge fan of the metallic eye creme eye shadows. Especially the rose gold. Since they have been discontinued, I have persevered with these but they don't work for me. The sparkles are too big so the look is not as sophisticated. Too glittery. They also dry in the tube and dry my eyelids too much, making them look creased and cakey. One, is way too creamy and just has an almost permanent melted feel to it, which smudges when I apply it. The rose gold in the stick is totally different to what the metallic creme used to be like. I really wish LM would bring back the metallic creme tubes. These sticks are overpriced, don't work well and not the reliable quality I expect from LM.
Reviewed by 2025 customers Disappointed
KAS from Ohio
It crumbles as you put it on. It also dries in clumps in the creases of your eyelids.
angixn from Racine, WI
I've been wanting to try these eyeshadow sticks for a long time. I just received yesterday. great color saturation, easy application and no creases which typically happens to me if I don't wear a base. I will buy more.
Not rose gold
DebbieB from Chicago, IL
While the caviar stick shadows are over all good, especially for a one and done look. The Rosegold color is decidedly not rose gold. It is a champagne color. Which is fine, just not what I had wanted.
I would buy this again.
Cathy from Michigan
Loved it and bought another
Tammy from SC
Goes on nice and smooth. Blends easily. Color is great. A bit of shimmer, and the colors are nicely neutral. I'm over 50 and this didn't accentuate fine lines around my eyes and was so smooth to apply, it doesn't tug at the delicate skin around the eyes. I liked it so well that I went back and purchased it in another color.
I will be buying more of this
Tam from Michigan
It stays on without creasing. love the colors
It's ok but not great
Kgirl from Charlotte
Personally would use Always On by smashbox over this product. I was excited that this was in pencil format. It applied nice but didn't blend well, not even with a brush. I tried several times- so either my dry skin prevented it from blending well, it dries too fast or it's not creamy long enough to work with it. Idk. I returned it & will wait for the new smashbox Always On colors to arrive!
Great Colors and Staying Power
CB24 from IN
So many lovely subtle colors. Goes on smooth and creamy, blends easily and stays on (no smudges or rubbing off) all day long. Best shadow option out there.
Silky and wonderful
Liz from Chicago, IL
The formula feels very nice and silky. It does have an *ever so slight* stickiness/weight to it on the eyelid, even after drying, but I think that is to be expected with a cream-based eyeshadow. This is a pretty nit-picky observation, however. Other than that, it's great. No creasing, good stay power, and shimmery (but not over the top). I gave it 4 stars because I bought the stick in the "moonlight" color and it's much lighter than I expected from the pictures. It's more of a very light sparkly champagne than a taupe-y, light smoky color (if that makes sense). I'm fair skinned.
Not for older women
TMAC from Hickory, NC
I used it for an all-over base on my eyelids. Apparently, cream eyeshadows just slide into lines and wrinkles on my eyelids.
A cream shadow that stays put!
Emily from Virgina
This eyeshadow stick is great! Perfect for a quick application. Once I get it on my eyelid its creamy enough to move around with my fingertip and blend. Give it about 10 minutes to dry and this stuff doesn't move all day! It never creases or gets greasy or oily. I only wish they had more with some sheen to it for a bit of a satin look. I use the taupe and it's a great every day color. Perfect for quick effortless look!
Easy on, stays on all day
FloridaGirl from undisclosed
Gave it to my daughter for her birthday and she loves it. She says it stays on all day, glides on easily and the color is lovely. She is a blue eyed blonde, a young looking 50.
Caviar Eye Stick Color Lasts All Day
Mamacakes65 from Atlanta
Caviar Stick Eye Color glides on and stays all day! The Amethyst color looks great on any skin tone. It's sophisticated, understated, and works with various outfit color schemes.
Perfect as Eyeliner
AJ from NM
I have struggled my entire adult life with eyeliner. My eyes are oily and every single eyeliner I've tried causes me to look racoonish within a few hours. By mid-day, it's completely gone. I saw a YouTube video with someone using it as a liner and decided to try it since I'd tried everything else. Oh my gosh. It's AMAZING! It goes on so easy-no back-and-forth, just one sweep and you're done. It has a thick tip so you have to use the right angle and be careful how much pressure you use. There are only a few colors that are dark enough but the plum is awesome. Highly recommend!
Yes it's awesome!
Iteachkiddos from San Diego
What a great product worthy of the price. I apply a tiny amount on the outer corner of my eye and start blending over the lid. It blends so easily no need to keep applying more like powder shadows.
Perfect Cream Eye Shadow
LSandman from Atlanta, GA
The color is beautiful! This product is so simple to apply and stays on all day.
MichelleGrady51 from Rochester, Ny
It's nice, but goes on quite dark. The plum is almost black when applied. You have to smear it with tissue
Goes on fast and easy love the color
Jodi from Ks
Love the color so easy
Caviar Stick Eye Color
amc716 from undisclosed
Love it...Especially how it goes on and stays on. The color is perfect as well.
Ease of application
Jenny W from IN
Goes on very smoothly and easy to smudge with my fingertips!
Shadow stick from Raleigh, NC
Beautiful color. Radiant. Makes blue eyes bluer. Creamy.
. from Columbus ohio
Do not make requirements for someone giving a positive review. Won't bother next time.
Very Beautiful. EASY and Looks GREAT! STAYS ON!
Ava Boo from San Diego
I learned about this watching the Lisa Rinna Vogue makeup tutorial. I copied down the name rapidly as she was demonstrating and then ordered two. I REALLY like them!! Super easy to create an eye look and these sticks have staying power. Lisa - LOVE you, Girl! And I love your eye makeup too! Thanks for this tip!
Eye caviar stick
HGlueck from Kansas City
Very easy to apply and love the color. Stays on for long period with no creasing.
Definitely worth it!!!!
Francine2015 from Dallas Tx
Tried other stick eyeshadows, this product by far is best! Goes on very smooth, no dragging, easy to use