Rated 4.07 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Please please please NEVER discontinue this!!
I just recently bought this brow pencil in the shade Rich Brown. I bought it after hearing Raw Beauty Kristi raving about it on YouTube. It is seriously SO GOOD! I detest doing my brows- this pencil makes the job super quick and easy with a fantastic result! Covergirl- please make this forever!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Great formula, mixed up packaging
I love the formula of this pencil. It fills in my brows perfectly without too much product, and lasts all day. However, mine was packaged completely wrong. I noticed when I purchased that the shade on the lid was quite deep, but I figured it was supposed to look like that. I even checked online to make sure "soft brown" was the lightest shade. It was the only one my store had in stock so I went ahead and purchased. Low and behold I get it home and it's the darkest shade but labeled as the lightest. Like I said the actual product is excellent but I'm pretty sure the one I got was packaged wrong so be careful.
Reviewed by 75 customers I use it every day
Kim from Wayne, NJ
I use this product every day. I originally used Maybelline's but wanted to use cruelty-free brands and this one is great! I have pretty light eyebrows and this does a great job at filling and controlling the amount of product.
Rachel from Pennsylvania
I have been re-purchasing this product for the last year and it has completely taken over my high end eyebrow products. It is easy to use and fills my brows just as well as my Brow Wiz pencil. The only issue is that it can break off easily so I try not to expose too much product at a time.
Great Pencil - but
Tulsa Girl from Tulsa, OK
I have been using the brow pencel for a month now. I purchased a second one since it was so great. The first time I used the second pencil, as I twisted the pencil to make it longer, the crayon shot straight out of the cylinder and I couldn't make it work without it continuing to do the same thing each time. I will be returning it to the store for another and will try it again. Hopefully they will refund my money. I would only recommend if this is corrected.
Color was off
MT from NAPA, CA
Soft brown is more like black/brown
Emma from St. Paul, MN
I love this product. I saw it recommended by Rawbeautykristi on YouTube so I thought I'd try it. Awesome quality, does a really good job. I feel like I run through the product quicker than other brow pencils, but that's okay. I always love how my brows look after using this.
Good but not great
Adriana23 from Oregon
I bought this a few weeks ago and I loved the texture and the fines of the tip but the color was too dark even though I got the tone: soft brown
Easy and Simple
Rae from Va
Super simple product, works wonderfully :)
Was not happy
Katiekakes from South Haven, MI
Was not happy with product. I find that it doesnt apply smoothly, kind of clumps up in areas. I got one use out of it and then the whole thing was broke up inside. I kept twisting it to come up and pieces just kept falling out. Had one brow done this morning and couldn't even complete the other one because it was broke in pieces and the last piece in fell on the ground. :(
Char 36 from Tn
I am dark brown in Anastasia Beverly hills brow pencil. What shade matches that ?
Great for Cancer Patients
lgreenwell from Louisville, KY
I lost my eyebrows during chemo and only 50% came back. These pencils work great. Lots of compliments. People are amazed I penciled by eyebrows on.
Very natural color
Over fifty make up lover from New Jersey
The color isent to rich. Its a very natural color brown.
Nita from Texas
It's great! I'm actually really impressed that it's by covergirl. No need to spend so much money this one is really good! Good shade and it lasts all day.
Samanta from Washington
The is amazing. No need to waste you money on any other eyebrow pencil.
AndieA from Dallas, Texas
I wanted to love this, but it just breaks apart! I have very sparse brows and the greys are cropping up, but this pencil is one of the better matches in my stash. Unfortunately, both the pencil end and the brush end are coming right off, after only three uses! This has never happened to me with any other brand.
rvtprincess from Denver, CO
I have used a ton of pencils for my brows. Some were too dry, some were too creamy and didn't last. I got the honey brown color and not only is it my perfect color but it's the perfect consistency and lasts all day even when I'm sweating in summer. Cover Girl is killin it!
LisaD19119 from Philadelphia, PA
I've had this brow pencil for a a week and it was everything I needed. Easy to use, great color and coverage. It's officially my new fav... do yourself a favor and buy one today... you won't be disappointed!!
It's amazing, like no other!!!
PamB from Colombia
I just discovered this and it's superbe!!! You do your brow in one minute, best thing I've ever had for my brows!
BETTER THAN HIGH END!
MaRyJo1023 from Hialeah, FL
When I started using eye makeup I thought the end all and be all was ONLY high end products until I started buying, using and experimenting with drugstore items again because the quality has gotten much better than it used and the moment I found/tried this eyebrow pencil in my perfect shade I've never tried or looked back at high end eyebrow products. This will continue to be my go-to and staple item for eyebrows for as long as it is around because it gets the job done with little to no effort and doesn't break the bank!
The best eyebrow pencil !
Genesis0125 from undisclosed
Very pigment go on so smooth I'm in LOVE with this
Better than NYX, ABH, & Benefit
Mackenzie from Atlanta, GA
I'm 19 now and have been using this product since I was 16! If I could only wear two makeup products for the rest of my life, it would be this and the Glossier stretch concealer. It's easy to use, travels well, has great color payoff, and holds up to walking on campus in the Georgia summer heat. Under the radar holy grail in my opinion.
emmiec from Nashville, TN
I love most of my covergirl products but this one let me down. I barely twist it out and it breaks almost everytime. It's also not very smooth and is very hard to apply.
Tina S. from WI
I have used so many eyebrow pencils, high end and everything in between. I never thought I would love one more than the one from L'Oreal, which I have used for a few years. This one is the best I've ever used, and so easy and effortless to use. I have stocked up like crazy on these. If this brow pencil ever gets discontinued, I will definitely cry like a baby!
DallasFan from San Diego
Great brow pencil. I've tried a lot a this is my favorite by far.
This is it!
TamiG from Florida
I have uses...you name it, I have used it! High end, low end, in between and all around. Love this.
I will never use another eyebrow pencil
Jennifer from Cleveland, Ohio
This product is perfect!! I have sparse eyebrows but love the Instagram brow look. This pencil is so thin you can do anything with it!! It is also so easy to create natural looking brow hairs and fill in your brows seamlessly. The formula in this is also perfect and will last all day long and won't budge. Never mind going to spend my money on Anastacia brow wiz again when I can buy this and achieve EVEN BETTER BROWS