Rated 3.57 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review my favorite mascara
Okay so I read a lot of the reviews in here and I am just convinced that the people who hate this mascara have no idea how to 1.apply mascara and 2.remove WATERPROOF mascara. I have tried every drug store and high end mascara out there and this is one of my top 5. I have long and thick lashes. It separates perfectly, coats my lashes without clumping, doesn't flake off, barely smudges and it stays on all day. I remove it with coconut oil because it is gentle on your lashes and waterproof mascara will rip your lashes out if you do not take care of them and remove mascara properly. That being said, if you think it's clumpy, wipe the brush off before you use it then put it back in the tube and move it around and then use. Sometimes there's too much product on it when you first buy it which will naturally make you hate it from the get go. Secondly, do not use water and soap to remove waterproof mascara, that's brainless. Use an oil based makeup remover, coconut oil or baby oil. Love this mascara a lot and will buy again!
Most Helpful Critical Review We Have a Love, Hate Relationship
I originally was going into Ulta to purchase L'oréal's Lash Paradise because it's been getting a lot of attention lately and I really wanted to try it and see if the hype was real, since I'm a huge mascara junkie. After looking through all of L'oréal's 9 billion mascaras, I couldn't find what I wanted, so, begrudgingly might I add, I went over to Maybelline to find a mascara, since I was completely out. After seeing this, I decided to try it (I normally use a Mally Volumizing Mascara) in waterproof because I have really bad allergies and my eyes run a ton. Let me just say this: it's crazy how big this makes my lashes. I have really large, round eyes (think a baby deer), so mascara is an important part of my makeup routine. This fans out my lashes, it's pretty good giving a cat eye effect (since I almost always wear wings), and makes my lashes so long, I can touch my brow bone when I look up. It's great if you're looking for a false eyelash look without the false lashes. I know that sounds pretty amazing, and you're probably wondering why I'm giving it 3 stars, but here's why: I have sensitive eyes and when mascara flakes and gets dry, my eyes get extremelu irritated. As cool as the brush for the tube is, it's not very good at separating lashes and removing clumps, which in turn results in a ton of fall out into my eyes. Also, this is extremely hard to remove. Even with makeup wipes and a liquid remover, I STILL have mascara under my eyes when I wake up in the morning, which drifts even more fall out into my eyes, worsening my allergies. Bottomline: I love how this mascara looks, hate what it does to my eyes. But beauty is pain, right?
Reviewed by 141 customers would not ever buy this mascara again.
madison from greenwich ct
it made my lashes clump together and after using this mascara my lashes began to fall.
Not that great
AP from Chicago
This mascara is VERY flaky and wet. It takes a long time to dry, clumps easily, and flakes off throughout the day. I'm constantly wiping underneath my eyes throughout the day to make sure I don't have this mascara underneath.
oof from Memphis, TN
nope.. super CLUMPY and uneven. Sooo hard to get off and when u finally get it off it pulls half ur eyelashes out w/ it...
Would not recommend
jayla from ulta
It is VERY wet when you apply and takes forever to dry. It left me looking like a raccoon by the end of the day. It was extremely hard to take off and would never fully come off. It left my eyes dark still. Also it ripped out so many eyelashes and overall just isn't a good mascara. I would not recommend.
Do Yourself a Favor, Buy a Different Mascara
Morgan from Columbia, MO
The product is WET and thick. The wand makes the product get everywhere. The worst mascara I have ever tried.
Could kick myself for buying this
Jennifer from Florida
The container/applicator design alone should have been my first clue. The handle is not shaped so you can hold on to it easily and you cannot stand either of them up because the bottom is so small. Comb applicator not good because you had to line up the comb with your eyelash and once the product was on the comb would not go through it. Wish I could return it.
No, not at this store
Joy from Menifee CALIFORNIA
I was surprised that the container was empty. I cannot get anything on the brush to put to my eyelashes. Don't know what happened there
Best drugstore mascara!
Lina D from Garland TX
This gives me the long and dark lashes I've always
wanted! I've used a lot of more well known brands, but this Lash Sensational cannot be beat! Especially when it comes to price!
Too clunky and flaky
Sara from Wooster, Ohio
I used this product for two weeks and it just was too flaky and clumpy. Very hard to take off even with good makeup remover specifically for waterproof mascara
Beware, it transfers
Liz from Seattle, WA
I like this mascara brush and it makes my lashes look great. The one drawback is it tends to transfer to my lids throughout the day, which I have noticed lately with similar formulations from this same brand.
the best waterproof mascara EVER
Emily from Texas
I have always struggled with finding the perfect waterproof mascara that doesn't smudge, stays put, and looks just as good as normal mascara. I found this one after researching different kinds and I decided to buy it. I am so impressed! I usually buy higher-end makeup so I was a bit hesitant to try this out but it is AMAZING. I've worn it through swimming, getting sweaty at band camp, and crying sessions, and it never fails me. I highly recommend this! It gives the perfect curl (even without using an eyelash curler), good volume, separation, and length! Well worth the small price.
I am buying again....
Liz from Baltimore
One of the best Mabbeline mascaras i've used!
i can't live with out it!
marie from atlanta
my holy grail and the only one i use! i highly recommend this if u have curly lashes. it gives u both length and volume to ur lashes. the only downside is that it dries ur lashes out.
Layla from WA STATE
From the first time I tried this, it became my go to mascara! My lashes fan so beautifully, that they look as good as false eyelashes. I love it, just fantastic!
Dolly from San Diego
If you like clumped lifeless lashes then go for it .
Great for length!
Simple from New Jersey
This is a great mascara to add a dramatic length and some volume. The way the brush is styled I found that it adds a fanned out look to my lashes which I love! I do have to scrape off some excess mascara off the side of the tube to prevent clumping and it is a bit sticky. However I find it is because I just opened it. It can be difficult to get off which is the only real downfall. I use a gentle cleanser to clean my face before bed but I find that I wake up with some mascara left over.
Best Bang For Your Buck
Steph K from Milwaukee WI
Honestly, I have tried EVERY mascara. Personally I find this mascara out performs even expensive luxury mascaras. I have long thin lashes, so volume/thickness and staying power is most important to me. Love this stuff and great price. Just make sure to get a good eye makeup remover and remove every night! I like Lancome Bificils or Aveda.
Love it !!
Laney from Lakeland, fl
Love it! Favorite mascara so far!
Love this Product!!
Emily from PA
I love to have visible volume on my lashes and this product really shows that!
4444 from Illinois
Clumpy and waxy 😖
There were right about it being waterproof
College Kiddo from Tempe
I got very tragic news while wearing this mascara. I cried heavily on and off for five hours. When I was going to take my makeup off, I noticed that the mascara hadn't smudged, smeared, or come off. If you have a mental breakdown, but still want to look good while dying on the inside, I highly suggest this mascara. Also, it lasted through a tinder hookup, so it's very versatile.
Yeah I would!!
Phi Yen from Superior, WI
I love this mascara because it's waterproof and doesn't get under my eye bags when I'll blink or close my eyes to much. And others that I've used have done this to me which I don't like but this mascara doesn't which is what I love about it!
A nice surprise!
Kat from Portland, OR
Wow! Was not expecting how great this would be! Picked it on a whim and it's great! It lengthens and provides great volume. Clumps a little bit can be avoided if you don't get too much on the brush.
NOT A CHANCE
Gem_Queen from Hanahan,SC
I usually love Maybelline products but this particular mascara is NOT for me. It's hard to put on and see results so you end up having to put more on than needed just to get an effect. Plus it clumps at the tips and causes them to stick together and harden. DISGUSTING.
Crystal the Crier from Hot Springs, Arkansas
I live my life vicariously to those in romcoms and when I cried while watching those romantic comedies my mascara stayed put! And I cry a lot