Rated 4.63 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Completely infatuated with this! < 3 < 3
I'm in LOVE with this shadow!!! I do my Smokey eye and then add to lower lid above lashes... or as a liner ... I get so many compliments! Really brings out hazel in eyes...I literally smile every time I start putting this on- it's the little things in life! LOL ... shimmer- Smokey- blend... you can do it all ... and the applicator tip is a great added bonus!
I would probably never had bought this if I hadn't gotten it as a sample... now I'm like 'MUST BUY ALL THE COLORS!' I have to stop myself because I don't wear too many colors ... it is costly- but one of the rare things I splurge on for ME... and it will last forever!!
I probably wouldn't but 'Kitten Karma' and 'Smoldering Satin' if I had to limit colors... they are VERY similar in color and not enough drastic difference to warrant both .. but both are beautiful
Most Helpful Critical Review Chunky and Patchy
I had heard so many times that these were such amazing products, so i decided i would give them a try. I bought Ballet Baby for quite a costly price in my opinion. And upon getting it home and trying it, it didn't take long for me to see the flaws of this product. (Now this could be a bad batch, or the colors formula is a bit iffy, i dont know? Just sharing my experience. The initial things i noticed were
-The glitter clumped up in certain areas and it was quite patchy, it was definitely hard to even get the color somewhat even, never-mind opaque!
-The glitter only truly showed pigment and shine at certain angles. I didn't like that only at certain angles could you really see the product, i expected creamy glittery goodness, and was given patchy uneven shimmer.
-Probably my biggest issue; IT WAS SOOOOO CHUNKY!!! In certain places the glitter would chunk up and get uneven, and when i went over it for a second coat it just rubbed the first coat off and i was left with weird bald spots on my lid.
-Super uncomfortable, i dont get how these gurus can say this is comfortable when it feels like someone made an eyeshadow out of sand paper!
That's the bad and ugly but what about good
-I liked the color, it was a cute shade even if not opaque
-Its glitter, and i mean, who doesn't like glitter? (EVEN IF the glitter is chunky and gross looking)
THE VERDICT: Is this product worth the money? ABSOLUTELY NOT! (as of now) I still look forward to trying these supposed metallic formulas ive heard about and maybe give another shade in the glitter collection a shot and maybe i just got a bad batch or something. But as far as my experience goes, it was a terrible and useless product that costed me too much money.
FOR THE RECORD! yes i used primers and bases and concealers and eyeshadow primers and foundations and even tried powder bases just for the heck (because apparently the other word is flagged) of it?? Ive tried everything in my power to make the product work and it just didn't
Reviewed by 1578 customers Love it
Mallory B from Heath, TX
There are a lot of uses for this product. I mainly use it for my eye lids but you could go wild with this if attending a music festival or something like that. Very concentrated which is what you want. I recommend!
Love it! Give me every color
Keshias_World from Indianapolis
I see some people saying it's watery or complaining about fall out.
1. Shake it
2. Don't swipe this on your eye, after you add eye shadow primer tap or dab this on the eye getting it as thick as you want and lightly blend and it's fine!
I didn't experience any fallout when I really took my time, when I used it for a quick rushed day I did but that was my fault- can't blame the product!
I honestly want this in every color!
Yes I would definitely buy it again
I have a lot of nicknames from Illinois
I love love love it
Stila Liquid eyeshadows are the best!
Amanda from Kirksville, Mo
These liquid eyeshadows are beautiful! I had a hard time getting a light enough shade effect on inner eye to mid eyelid after doing the darker blended shades. This works amazing to apply after all other eyeshadows blended then applying this for that color pop! It applies smoothly and last me through my 12 hour work shifts!
Water with glitter in it.
SusieQ from Al
Too runny. Just a small tube of water with glitter it. Would not stay in place for more than two seconds.
Sassy Cassie from Illinois
this is so pretty...thr only draw back is glitter fall out, even in thr middle of the day I'll notice new glitter in my cheek...but the Sparkle is totally worth it!
Great for the Holidays
Bumblebee22 from Raleigh North Carolina
I love this eyeshadow! This is my second time purchasing the same exact one and I never buy the same makeup except foundation. It's great for the holidays and my eyes are very sensitive but this does not bother them.
Courtney from North Carolina
I got this during the 21 days of beauty. I was excited to see that it was included. I've been wanting to purchase it at the recommendation of Kelly Strack. She had uploaded a bridal makeup tutorial where she used it. I recently got engaged so I've had my eye on it for a while. It goes on easily and adds a perfect shimmer to your eyes. I used it as an eyeshadow topper. My eyes are sensitive to a lot of liquid-y products like this but this eyeshadow didn't bother me. It does have quite a bit of glitter in it so be aware of that. It stayed in place all day and didn't crease. I got the shade kitten something. I have the regular kitten eyeshadow from stila as well I love them both! The shades are a shimmery gold.
Mandy from Kathryn, ND
Retro Rose is a flattering universal shade
Not a fan
Metz from Fort Myers, FL
I tried this and was hoping it would last a few hours and it barely lasted 1 hour before it came off my skin. Disappointing.
Titi from Texas
I love these Stila eyeshadows. Easy application and the appropriate level of pigment. Will definitely purchase more
The only glitter I use!
Izzy from Tampa, FL
Love this product! It's very easy to use as no glitter glue is required, and it has zero fall out. Also I have slightly hooded eyes which causes most products to crease, but this glitter stays put all day without creasing! I have a ton of shades of these at this point and will not use any other glitter.
Love glitter?! Buy this!
Becky from IL
I love this stuff so much! I've bought Karma Kitten 4x. I get compliments on it all the time. I use a primer before, and primer spray after, and glitter still gets around my eyes by the end of the day but I love it so much that I don't care. Its very sparkly!
Great, exactly what I was looking for
Pamela T from Pawtucket, RI
I purchased the shade molten midnight with the thought of putting it over eyeliner and it works great. I am sure it will look good over any smoky eye look. I love the shade having a dark base under the silver glitter so it really sparkles.
Not what I thought it would be
Sassy from IA
It goes on really smooth, did not have the color I was expecting
AMO from San Diego, CA
I love this product! It gave my eyes that extra GLAM they needed!!!
Best non-crease eyeshadow
Hailey from Montana
I always wanted to try this product because of the hype around it. So when it was on 21 days of beauty, I figured I would give it a go. The hype is real! Super easy to apply, unlike a lot of other liquid eyeshadows, and it doesn't crease throughout the day, which has always been a huge problem for me. The glitter is even more pronounced when it's on your eyes. Definitely would recommend this product!
I have pictures to show how how pretty this product is but I'm not sure where to attach them.
It's really pretty
Adrianna from Atlanta, GA
I really do like this liquid eyeshadow! It goes on really nice, and it lasts for a long time. The only issue that I had was how quickly it dries. You really have to put it on quick.
The Fancy Dino from Columbus, OH
I love these shadows! I have bought several different colors and they are all amazing. The sparkle actually shows up and stays put. Depending on how you angle the applicator, you can put a thin thin or a thick line of product. I also like to apply the shadow directly on my lid and then layer eyeshadow from one of my palettes over it to really enhance the color and dimensions.
Glitter on glitter!! from Los Angeles
So much glitter!! I loved all the ones I got. Come tones are very similar when applied.
Product ingredients cause me to get stye STAY AWAY
Tori Leon from FL
I tried this product for an event I had. I have never had an allergic reaction or any reaction for that matter to eye products. I was surprised to see at the end of the day my eyelid has bumps on it I have never seen before. Its so unfortunate because I did like the product. I bought shade dolly. It held up full day but due to ingredients for pigment I would not recommend.
Received damaged product
Anjali from Redmond
Received damaged product. Brush is Broken.
A must for your makeup bag
Chs makeup lady from Charleston, SC
I have about 7 of these and I use them mostly as toppers. Pigment is amazing, you need only one coat and it lasts for hours. Definitely use primer to keep the glitter intact and prevent it moving around. I have recommended these to all of my makeup enthusiast friends, I can't say enough about these shadows!
Pretty but dries quickly
Kendall from California
These liquid eyeshadows are all super pretty but there's something in the formula that makes the product dry up very quickly in the tube
I would give it six stars if I could
Wyomom from Wyoming
Fantasy product, I get so many compliments, daily on this product. I use it on my lower lid and blend it with a darker color on top the top
Part of my lid. I love the kitten, but I have many colors in sparkle and matte colors. Great product especially if you have a tendency to rub your eyes. Stays well, lasts all day.