Product Reviews Rated 4.08 out of 5 stars
1635 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I will ALWAYS rebuy this item I have ALWAYS struggled trying to find an eyeliner that would NOT end up on all in my eyeshadow and that would create all kinds of black under my eyes! I have a different way of wearing my make-up as I like my eyeliner very black and very bold! I also do a fairly thicker cat eye! I'm absolutely IN LOVE with this eyeliner and won't know what to do if they ever do away with it!!! I do use an eyeshadow primer before I apply my eyeliner (normally just nyx- nothing over pricy) and BAM I'm ready for a LONG day of perfectly looking eyeliner!
Most Helpful Critical Review Nothing Special I bought this in brown and was a little disappointed by the shade. I was hoping for something dark, but this is more of a lighter reddish brown.
As for the formula, it's nothing to write home about. It goes on fairly nicely, but it can also get streaky if you aren't careful. I have fairly oily skin and this smudges on me throughout the day, unfortunately. I end up getting a tad bit of a raccoon eye around the outer edges. UHG. This is something I'll only wear if I'm going into work(I work in an office) or staying indoors. It's too hot here to wear it outside much, especially with the coastal humidity and my already annoying skin type.
For the price, it's not bad. If you have normal/dryer skin or just live in a dryer climate, you might love this. I would say that if you have oily skin, stay away. This will just smudge and drive you crazy. Also, if you're looking for a dark brown gel liner, look elsewhere. :( I would describe this brown as sort of a bourbon shade.
Reviewed by 1635 customers I will definitely buy again! 5
Lilliland from Erie, PA
Someone recommended this product and it's great - very black, glides on, no smudging. Narrow point so application is a dream. Great value too.
Good product for oily skin person. 5
Irene914 from Peachtree Corners, Georgia
I am a oily skin person, usually the eyeliner will disappeared 1 hour after, I saw the reviews said it works great so I give a try, very good for me, it stayed almost 7 hours on my oily face. I would recommend it.
I would buy this again. 5
myrn53 from Prairie Grove, Arkansas
Best eyeliner I have ever found.
No pigmentation 2
K from Atlanta
I really like the black liner but in my every day wear i prefer dark brown as my eyeliner so I bought this one. I've used the black one before and liked how it applies but this brown color leaves a lot to be desired for. The color payoff is not there. It goes on creamy like the black one but you get no pigmentation unless you set with an eye shadow and I'm not interested in going through all of that. Returning it since I won't be using it.
Wouldn't buy again 1
Tammy from Fort Worth Texas
I tried using it to do my winged eyeliner
One of my must-haves! 5
Bee from Salt Lake City
One of the best gel eyeliners that I have used. Stays on all day, can make it precise or smudged. Using it for 2 years now. Wish it came in more shades! I bought some sharp and angled brushes from ELF specially to use with this liner and it works great!
Really good for beginners 5
Niki from Texas
I just started wearing gel eyeliners and this has been one of the best ones yet and it lasts longer than the pencil ones for sure!
Excellent eyeliner 4
SharonS from Tulsa, OK
It applies smoothly, is more opaque than any liquid liner I've used (I've mostly used Senegence, Loreal, or Rimmel). It is comparable to the Stila gel liner pens, in my experience, and more waterproof and smudgeproof than other drugstore waterproof eyeliners. It does smudge slightly if rubbed, like if your eyes are itchy. The other potential con is that the brush it comes with is EXTREMELY precise, like a needle, so it makes a sharp wing but is difficult to get a good line above the lashes. That is only a small complaint though. I highly recommend this!
the product is very smooth 4
Des from Atlanta , GA
You can smudge the product for a smokey look , or let it dry for a nice sharp liner that won't move.
I wouldn't buy this again 1
Garcia91 from Dallas Tx
I didn't like that I kept going back and forth trying to color my waterline black. I don't
Think I'd buy this again even if it was my last resort. At the end it didn't give my waterline any color
My fav 4
Desa from Anaheim
Like the aplication but smears
Great dupe for expensive gel eyeliner 4
MrsA from Seattle, WA
Love this! Have it in brown for a natural look and just got the black as I find gel easily to do a cateye than a liquid eyeliner
Pretty good, would recommend for first timers 4
Lexi from Michigan
Lasts all day, and goes on smooth. Would recommend if you're new to gel liner
Pretty good, would recommend for first timers 4
Lexi from Michigan
Lasts all day, and goes on smooth. Would recommend if you're new to gel liner
Amazing for first timers! 5
Maggie from Hawthorne
I've always wanted to try to attempt to do a wing liner and I tried different things I tried so much and I bought this thinking not much of it so when I got it I tried it and it was so easy to apply the brush is amazing it does the job it's just great I'm super satisfied
Bad quality 1
Bluejay from United state
Don't like it,super dry.
Good eyeliner 4
Rachel from Illinois
Its a good eyeliner, its not patchy or dry, and has a very defined color. It looks beautiful but the brush it comes with kinda sucks. Its really sharp and not that easy to use. The formula of the product is great but its worth using a different eyeliner brush
Go to liner. 4
Shawnice from Wyoming
My go to liner. BLACK. lasts forever and a day.
It's ok. 3
SD from San Jose, Ca
Glides on smooth. It fades and comes off corner of inner eyes. It stayed on well in the top and bottom rim of eyes.
One of my tops eyeliners 5
Lizz from Schuyler Ne
Love this eyeliner doesn't simmer very bold only have to apply once and your ready to go. Can't live with out it
Easy to apply 4
Babz56 from Pasadena, MD
This goes on easily with my silicone liner brush. Would prefer a warmer brown as this is on the grey side. Price is great compared to competition.
Hard to apply smoothly 1
Robin from Asheville
Maybe it was just a bad lot... this liner was difficult for me to apply smoothly to my mature, loose skin. It kind of dragged and skipped. Bobbi Brown gel liner is still my standard, but the cost is highway robbery.
the best gel I've used so far 5
Tine from Pittsburgh
this eyeliner is GREAT! a very lil goes a very long way! I've had mine for over a yr and i still have so much left! I use this on my lid and on my waterline. it doesnt run... I do have really dry eyes so they tend to water, but this holds up for me! it stays put on my waterline all day.
Like 4
Delia from Anaheim
I love how easy it is to apply , only thing I don't like it smears
Can't live without it!! 5
Crystal from El Paso, Texas
I've been using this for 6 years and I love it. I actually use it for my eyebrows and I don't know what I would do without it! I always get asked what I use and the reaction is funny when they find out it's an eyeliner.
