Rated 3.96 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Long lasting and fun colors!
I was really excited to try this product out because I LOVE colorful eyeliner. It adds such a fun pop to an otherwise normal or "boring" makeup look. I was excited to see I received a really pretty blue shade that would definitely serve as a color pop on my blue eyes. When they say that this stuff lasts it LASTS. I applied this at 6am before work and didn't use any sort of primer on my oily eyelids to see what the true lasting power of this liner was- when I got home at 6pm it was still perfectly intact with no flaking or smudging of any kind. The downside to that though is that it was still on my eyes after I hopped out of the shower and it needed a bit of tough love with some eye makeup remover to get it all off. If you have sensitive eyes and need this to come off after you've had your fun with it this might not be the product for you so keep that in mind. I liked the packaging and the tiny brush applicator was easy to use and create wings with. I can see this being an incredible product for people who preform on stage or for a bride who needs her makeup to stay in place all day. The bright colored ones could also be great for concerts or raves where makeup tends to be sweated off! Overall I recommend this product if you're looking for something long wearing that comes in a unique variety of colors!
Most Helpful Critical Review New eyeliner for product testing
I received this eyeliner to test from #influenster. Upon receiving the item, the packaging was fair. It did get me excited to open the product after seeing the images on the box. Removing the product from the box you see a black tube. Noticeably, the majority of the tube is a handle and a small portion has product in which the handle dips into. Removing the handle from the product pot and pulling it out, I immediately noticed it was a fine tip liner brush with a LOT of clumpy product on it. To be able to give a fair review, I wiped off the excess product and dipped the handle in once again to see how the product would come out a second time. Once again, when removing the brush, it was clumpy. I wiped off the excess in the pot this time and noticed the bristles are quite long and soft. This can be good, depending on your preference when applying eyeliner. I prefer a more sturdy brush that I have more control over. This, in my opinion, allows for more mistakes. But if you have a steady and experienced hand, I'm sure you will enjoy this. After applying the product, this leaves little room for mistake. It DOES NOT wipe off easily. Again, this is good and bad. My eyes are sensitive so using a lot of pressure on the lid to remove a product is not enjoyable. This is an ok liner. Workable, but really nothing special. It has long lasting stay power if that is what you're looking for. It was too clumpy and soft for me to really enjoy applying, the softness of the brush made me nervous not to mess up as I had a difficult time removing it. When lining my eyes I like a thin line, not but dramatic raccoon eyes or cat eye wings. So honestly if you're into a more dramatic look it may very well work better for you.
Reviewed by 537 customers great eyeliner
Patrice from Santee
Love the blue color
Winner for Bartender
audnine from NC
I'm very picky about eyeliner. I like consistency of this one. The brush is very fine so you can get really thin and precise. Best part is that it actually stays on all day. Bottle lasts a long time too
Erica from Hemet, CA
Very patchy and not pigmented at all.
Not buy this, very hard to remove it even with remover
Liner from Panama City
I've tried to use this product but it's very hard to line and very hard to remove it even with the make up remover.
They really mean EPIC wear
Hkc from Colorado
I have hooded lids and oily skin. This liner seriously holds up against both. I use this as a base and then use the stila microtip for the sharpest points and thinnest lines. This product outlasts stila!
I would not buy this again
Debbie from Oak Ridge Tn.
I bought brown and stone grey and you can't tell any difference in the two colors while wearing. Not happy with my purchase
stays all day!
Potato-Chan from Wisconsin
I literally adore this eyeliner. I just got it a few days ago and I feel like it's the eyeliner I've always been looking for. It stays in place all day which and I've always had a problem with other eyeliners flaking off in some spots. I even put it on the waterline in the corner of my eye (which I never do because no eyeliner stays on there) AND IT STAYED. Super happy!
Stays on strong & is very pigmented
Korina from Arizona
This thing is waterproof! Not even rain or getting splashed in the face with water would cause this run or flake off. This is my first time using this eyeliner (did not see this was waterproof) and when I tried double cleansing with an oil cleanser and a gel one, it would barely budge. I did find out that micellar water does remove it so that's good cause I thought I was gonna be stuck with it on my eyes.
It's very pigmented and black which I like. And it does dry up fast, it dries to a matte finish but it does not feel dry or flakey at all.
Great eye liner
Estherqueen from Texas
First time si used it and very pleased with product. I have allergies and didn't experience any problems. I wish it would be in a bigger tube, there's not enough product. The setback is the how the brush tends to separate, so you have to adjust the bristles together. Can get messy.
Great liner but...
Kc from Denver
It was amazing liner, but I did end up having an allergic reaction to it. My eyes got really puffy and were stinging. It was also extremely difficult to remove.
Chris from los angeles
Gloopy, transfers, and takes forever to dry. Body only wear is recommended. Definitely not for the eyes
Longest lasting liquid liner
Shewolf from NJ
The best liquid liner I have used for the price. Didn't smudge or flake off. Needed makeup remover to remove.
Teri from Texas
Doesn't skip, very smooth liner! My best friend loves it!
Looooooove it! 💛💛💛
Lex•Luther from Northridge, CA
Yo! I've been on the hunt for a liquid yellow FOREVER and they're always sold out. So, I had low expectations when I saw that a lot of this one wasn't snatched up. I was wrong. It's great. Got lots of compliments and it made my green eyes pop OFFFF! 💛💛💛💯 it's just hard to take off.
SAPPHIRE SHADE IS SO GOOD
Michelle from TX
So far I've only tried the blue shade and I absolutely love it. It is so easy to make a wing! Just because of this eyeliner I will be grabbing the black and brown liners. So easy and painless, does the job!!!
NICKY from HENRIETTA,NY
HAVE USED THIS BRAND FOR MANY YEARS
Thick, Glue-Like Consistency
SabSixx from Montreal, QC
I had high hopes for this eyeliner because I generally feel like NYX makes good quality products, but this eyeliner is such a disappointment. I bought the black and yellow shades, and although the black is quite pigmented, the yellow is extremely patchy. The formula is also extremely thick and goopy -- think of craft glue -- so I couldn't layer the yellow to make it more opaque because it would create a visibly elevated line along my eyelid. The disadvantaged of formula were compounded by a disappointing brush. The brush is not user-friendly or tapered, and combined with the thick formula, the product would goop / clump in my eyelashes and I couldn't create a sharp edge or a nice wing. The eyeliner definitely has staying power if you apply it successfully, but in my case, this was a disadvantage because I could not get it out of my eyelashes.
definitely the best
glowupbeautybyolaya from amarillo tx
i use this product all the time its the best
nad from Bloomington, IN
nice red color and nice applicator
Good glide, but hard to get off
Lee Riich from Elkridge, MD
I love love my Neutrogena wipes! They take off everything. I wear long lasting eye liner, liquid and crayon all the time and my wipes will take it right off. With this NYX liner, I used the wipes, baby oil, witch hazel and water and soap, it did not come off! I literally had to use Vaseline to scrape off my eye. It's a good product but I do not want to go through all that to take make up off
Great eyeliner ! Be careful because kind of runny!
Miya from Ms
This is a liquid eyeliner and it is really liquid! The tip is easy to use !
Truly waterproof and long lasting
Elle from NY
I am so impressed with this liner. It seriously does not budge; I've never found such a long lasting liner. Love the colors too! If you want a liner to wear swimming or to last a really long work day or night out, this is it
Formula is terrible
Shoshi from South Carolina
I usually love nyx liquid liners, but I hated these. I got the white and the lilac, and the formula is so gooey and impossible to apply. It stuck to my eyelashes and wouldn't make a clean, opaque line because of the consistency. I'm returning both
Me from Colorado Springs, CO
It was really difficult to use, the applicator is awful, and it was almost too thick to control. It stays well though
Good for everything eyes except eyes
Em Kay from New york
I used this as an eyeliner. Although it last awhile, it has a sticky residue which wouldn't come off my lids.