Rated 4.22 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review It's good, not perfect, but good!
I wasn't going to buy this since I have so many palettes already, but when I was in the store I saw it in person and fell in love. I love neutrals and these are beautiful! I love the way the palette is laid out with different looks beginning with light shades for brow bone and base, then a light nude sections, a pink/mauve section, a bronze section, and a deeper brown section. I've used the palette the last two days since I received it and find that the mattes blend seamlessly and they are very pigmented! I've already created looks I've loved. The shimmers are stunning, but best applied with fingers, as they don't pack much pigment with a brush. I do think this palette leans more on the warm side, but it's still neutral enough that anyone can wear it. This is going to be my go-to travel palette! One thing I don't love is the cardboard packaging, especially at the price point that it is, but on the plus side, it is thin and lightweight so perfect for storing away without taking up too much room or throwing in your purse for on the go. I say that if you love neutrals, you'll love the convenience of having them all together in one cohesive and aesthetically pleasing palette.
Most Helpful Critical Review Shimmers are tough to work with, gorgeous colors tho
The colors are simply beautiful, and I like how they arranged the palette - complementing shades are together, to make creating eye looks easy. The shades are very pretty and work super well with my warm/light skin. The mattes blend nicely and I love the colors. *However, the shimmer shades are a massive letdown.* They're gorgeous in the pan, but come out far more chunky/sparkly than shimmery, and they don't give you much pigment payoff or coverage. Lots of fallout as well which was super annoying. My black shirt was covered in sparkle chunks. I got the shimmers to work out, but it took some trial and error. Best application method for me is to to wet a flat brush with setting spray, dip into the shimmer pan, TAP EXCESS OFF, and PRESS onto the eyelid. Start with a little and build, as it's easy to either have too little or too much. Wetting the brush also helped the sparkly shades look more shimmery and less 90's chunky. I tried pressing them in with my bare finger but that didn't work either, as that didn't give me nearly enough pigment/payoff and it was just too hard to be precise on my lid. If you do buy this, TEST IT OUT before you go out in public. It's going to take a little bit of trial and error to figure out how to work with it.
I love the colors, but I'm on the fence about keeping it since I'm not sure the shimmer shades are right for me. I already lived through the 90's - no more chunky sparkle. Plus, I agree with those who said the packaging is cheap. This was not a win, but not a huge fail.
Reviewed by 333 customers This is my favorite!
Rachel81 from Oregon
I bought this awhile back and I am buying another just to make sure I always have it! I get compliments all the time. I feel sexy when using it. If you notice it's hard to get the glitter colors with a brush, use your finger and bam!! Beautiful! I recommend this even over some of the more popular more expensive palettes. Most have!!!
Neutral colors nice
Kyla from New York
Colors are very beautiful, neutral tone with nature look or night time smoky look. Good pigmentations and easy to blend. Very tiny kickback powder but still workable
Wanted it to be as pretty as it looks...but no
Lisa from Waco ,TX
I so wanted to love this pallet! I have the peach pallet that's my favorite , but this one just couldn't make it with me . The colors looked so good but once applied the mats look dull and the sparkle is hard to apply.. I'm returning. 😞
Katie from Lapeer, MI
Very beautiful colors. I have never been disappointed with Too Faced pallettes.
Best go to eyeshadow!!
Chrissa Lovett from Katy, Tx
Love this palette!! You can use it for everyday or glam! Love the shimmer shades and all blends beautifully!!
On the fence
Girlygirl from Wisconsin
I want to love it...Unfortunately the colors just don't compliment my cooler tone skin as much as I would like. Even though the colors look beautiful in the pallet, they all look very similar on me - a very warm, copper tone. I can make a couple of looks with it but they aren't as diverse as I was hoping for so I'm on the fence on keeping this palette. I do really love the shimmer/glitter colors and can make them work well with other eye shadow palette's I have. I don't know if I can make enough different looks with this to justify keeping. I will say that the colors are very pigmented and last all day when I prime with UD eyeshadow primer.
Ollie's mom from Chicago
From the pictures I thought this palette would be more brown based but there are a nice mix of browns, pinks and plums. The mattes are superb. They glide onto my hooded eyes and blend smoothly. I find the shimmer shades a little too chunky to apply fully on my lids so I use them as toppers. I pat down the matte shades of my choosing onto the mobile lid and build to the opacity I want. Then I rub my finger into the shimmer shade and gently pat it onto the lid. I start lightly and build up. This gives me control over how dramatic I want the look to be. If the shimmers weren't so chunky I would give this palette five stars.
Dana from PA
I didn't expect to love this product as much as I do. I have gotten so many compliments! There are so many different looks you can make from it, too. Wow.
The pigmented eyeshadows are pretty but not transferring
Rara from Sydney Australia
I love all the matte shadows in this pallet, but the pigmented shadows are not transferring from the brush to the eyelid??
I have tried every brush used my finger and the pigmented eyeshadows in this pallet just will not transfer smooth/nicely to the eyelid!
I have a certificate 2 in makeup artistry so I'm not a novest, I primed the lids done everything correctly i even tried a damp eyeshadow brush nothing i struggled big time with the pigmented shadows. Considering how much I paid im extremely unhappy, I feel like I maybe got a lemon pallet to be honest :( Sadness from Sydney Australia!
This palette is just okay to me
Abby from Columbia City, IN
I was really excited to get this palette, but I feel like the shadow doesn't has a rich, full overage from palette to brush to eye. I also like more light brown hues, and this is more in the pink family.
Hail from Grand Rapids, Mi
All of the colors match well with my skin & stay on all day without creasing. Definitely recommend and buy again.
my new go to!
Kayla from Missouri
I've been wanting this palette for so long and I finally just bought it. So glad I did! The mattes blend very well and are smooth, the glitters apply decently when you use your finger. I've used this palette everyday I've worn eye makeup since buying it
Hey it's whoever I am from The USA
This is a natural glam palette the glitters are very very pigmented if you use your finger. Mattes are pretty!
I don't use this everyday tho.
eyesee from Orange county CA
LOVE LOVE LOVE IT!!
I have ND, CT, many other eyeshadow palettes, but this one is truly amazing one. Love every single shade in this palettes, so beautiful on my eyes.Good quality.
Lacey Sue from Kennewick, WA
Love every shade! Perfect combination of mattes, shimmer, and glitter. Blends together well for a gorgeous finished product.
Stylist from Indiana
Love the colors
Very disappointed by colors
AKateA from North Carolina
I had my eye on this palette for months before I broke down and bought it. I couldn't be more disappointed... the shadows have very little color payoff, and a lot of the mattes look very different from the color in the pan once applied. All of the mattes have a slightly pink/orange tinge to them, when I thought they would be cool or warm browns. Honestly I've used it twice and will probably give it away.
Such great pigments !!!!
Amarilys from Waterbury , CT.
I love this palette
BriBri from Lexington, Ky
Love all the nudes that help me create a natural look!
katie from new york, ny
I'd been wanting to get this palette since it came out and I don't know why I held out! I find that I reach for it everyday. The shades are all flattering and you can get natural to dramatic looks easily. The shadows are buttery and easy to blend. The simmers are sophisticated, really sparkly but not chunky.
Tam from wv
a little disappointed
RachelC86 from Cape Cod
I have over 40 eyeshadow palettes. This is the one I constantly reach for. This seems to be a much more sophisticated and grown up release from Too Faced and I am here for it. This palette puts TF back on the map. This palette makes it so incredibly easy to put together gorgeous looks, from natural relaxed looks to more smokey, shimmery looks. I adore this palette. The shimmers and mattes both perform beautifully. The shades make it almost impossible to not make a look gorgeous. This would be great for beginners but also very well loved by pros and long time makeup lovers. I actually prefer this packaging to the other TF palettes. I have the foundation and the concealer from this range and I have been so impressed with these products. They're much more luxury feeling than a lot of TF releases. This has been the best palette investment for me in the last year or so. I adore it.
Gorgeous Colors for My Brown Eyes
Kay from GA
As a more mature woman, I can easily wear these colors as there are mattes and shimmers in a beautiful selection of more natural colors. If I want to glam up my eyes, I can use the shimmers on my lids. I like the texture of the mattes; no fallout. I love this palette!
Excited to finally get pallet
Makeup Ninja from Louisiana
I love Too Faced eyeshadow pallets and was really looking forward to getting this one. I've only had a chance to use it a couple of times, but so far so good. The colors were as I was hoping for, and it applied/blended as I expected, with the color staying true (with the help of eyeshadow primer). You are able to get any kind of look you could possibly ask for. Ranging from neutral natural to smoky dramatic. The possibilities are only limited to your imagination. ❤️
Great mattes, disappointed in shimmer
SJMA12 from Dallas
Great blend able matte shades and I always love how TF gives you more Matte product intuitively. I almost kept it for that alone. I tried a few shimmers, I especially like my shimmers to be lighter colored and those ones in this palette were very chunky and actually showed up on my lid with texture. I understand texture with say a true presses glitter or topper but I like less grit. Looks weird. I love the colors and very badly wanted this to be what it had potential to be. I would actually encourage TF to do a "remastered" version, even if price point was higher.