Rated 4.23 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review It's good, not perfect, but good!
I wasn't going to buy this since I have so many palettes already, but when I was in the store I saw it in person and fell in love. I love neutrals and these are beautiful! I love the way the palette is laid out with different looks beginning with light shades for brow bone and base, then a light nude sections, a pink/mauve section, a bronze section, and a deeper brown section. I've used the palette the last two days since I received it and find that the mattes blend seamlessly and they are very pigmented! I've already created looks I've loved. The shimmers are stunning, but best applied with fingers, as they don't pack much pigment with a brush. I do think this palette leans more on the warm side, but it's still neutral enough that anyone can wear it. This is going to be my go-to travel palette! One thing I don't love is the cardboard packaging, especially at the price point that it is, but on the plus side, it is thin and lightweight so perfect for storing away without taking up too much room or throwing in your purse for on the go. I say that if you love neutrals, you'll love the convenience of having them all together in one cohesive and aesthetically pleasing palette.
Most Helpful Critical Review Shimmers are tough to work with, gorgeous colors tho
The colors are simply beautiful, and I like how they arranged the palette - complementing shades are together, to make creating eye looks easy. The shades are very pretty and work super well with my warm/light skin. The mattes blend nicely and I love the colors. *However, the shimmer shades are a massive letdown.* They're gorgeous in the pan, but come out far more chunky/sparkly than shimmery, and they don't give you much pigment payoff or coverage. Lots of fallout as well which was super annoying. My black shirt was covered in sparkle chunks. I got the shimmers to work out, but it took some trial and error. Best application method for me is to to wet a flat brush with setting spray, dip into the shimmer pan, TAP EXCESS OFF, and PRESS onto the eyelid. Start with a little and build, as it's easy to either have too little or too much. Wetting the brush also helped the sparkly shades look more shimmery and less 90's chunky. I tried pressing them in with my bare finger but that didn't work either, as that didn't give me nearly enough pigment/payoff and it was just too hard to be precise on my lid. If you do buy this, TEST IT OUT before you go out in public. It's going to take a little bit of trial and error to figure out how to work with it.
I love the colors, but I'm on the fence about keeping it since I'm not sure the shimmer shades are right for me. I already lived through the 90's - no more chunky sparkle. Plus, I agree with those who said the packaging is cheap. This was not a win, but not a huge fail.
Reviewed by 299 customers Meh
Bonnie from Atlanta, GA
I really wanted to love this palette and fell in love the second I saw it online. I really wanted it for the rose gold color but also love a nude look. Unfortunately the palette is nothing great. I'm very fair skinned and the colors change a lot when applied. I used the palette a few times but honestly never reach for it.
My everyday go to palette
archjane from Chicago
This quickly became my go to palette since the colors are universally flattering. I first saw several YouTubers wearing it and it looked great on them in the videos. With this palette I can do an everyday look, or go a little glam, or do a dramatic evening look. Well done Born This Way!
mtodd from Lakewood, CA
These are all great colors that you can use for both an everyday look or something a little more.
Best eyeshadow I've ever used!
Melindy from Mustang, Ok
I wear this palette every day. It's great for the office, or date night. Shadows blend well without getting muddled. I would highly recommend!
Holly from Cedar Rapids, Iowa
The mattes are great, the shimmers are easy to build.
Love the colors!
PJ from Arizona
Very happy with this purchase. i would buy again! Love, love, love the colors!
I love this palette!!
Mamaof392 from San Diego
Saw someone on Instagram (I think she was a Too Faced ambassador or something) using this shadow palette and I loved the color story so I gave it a chance. I have other too faced products and I love those so I thought I'd try this out. So so so pleased with it! I can create a quick and easy beautiful look for work and look professional. The mattes and shimmers are so beautiful and easy to use. Highly recommend. I love the shimmer glitters I want to wear them all at once!
These colors are beautiful
Hilary D from Raleigh, nC
I like how you can create a neutral daytime look with the colors or more of a vibrant eye for night. It's so pretty
Sam from Stratford ct
I purchased this item for my girlfriend she used it for the first time yesterday and received many compliments I love your nude colors on her but when I saw your collaboration with glitter included in the nude colors I knew it would be a home run she says it's great and has always loved the quality of your product so thank you the continuous supply of outstanding customer service along with a phenomenal product.
Not for me
Gigi from Los Angeles, CA
The colors pulled orange on me. The glitters were messy and got into my eyes. They applied better with my fingers but that's not my preferred application. The palette looks so pretty but I was definitely disappointed. I will return it.
Mattes are OK, glitters are messy
Sue from USA
I fell for the hype, and while the matte shades are very pretty and wearable, the glitter ones are chunky and poorly pigmented with a lot of fallout. I'll keep the palette and wear the mattes but would not repurchase or recommend. There are better palettes out there with similar neutrals, for a better price.
Matches with all my lipsticks
Katie from NY
This palette is just perfect. I see how the colors would look good on anyone. The best part about it?? I don't have to play around with my lipsticks to see what will look good with it. Literally all of my lipsticks look amazing with it. It is such a natural nude palette. I love it. All of the colors compliment each other and there is no guess work like there is with other palettes. Highly recommend. The shades are highly pigmented and blend like butter without getting muddy
Marilyn from CA
I hesitated a bit to order this because I already have another eye palette in brown/nude tones, but I am so glad I did! The mattes blend really smoothly and the shimmers look so pretty! I love the versatility in looks this shade range makes possible, from a natural nude look for daytime to smokey eyes in brown for night time. The colors really suit my complexion and eye color, and I love the fact that the nudes don't look ashy. I like this palette better than my other palette, and that one was more expensive. I also don't agree with other reviews that say this palette is small. It is huge in my opinion! In total, you get 12g of product, which is a lot for an eye palette. In my other palette, you get only 8g of eye shadow. And it was more expensive! I am very happy with this product and I will reach for it often for sure. It just makes my eyes look so pretty!
Scratchy, irritating glitter.
Vanessa from California
The colors are really beautiful, the mattes are pigmented and vibrant.
But I can actually feel the chunky glitter scratching my eyelids. Every time I blink I can feel the irritation on my eyelids. And within a few hours I start to feel like I have sand on my eyeballs.
I am so confused by the idea that anyone is not bothered by this.
Even if these glitter shades were not the texture of glitter glue mixed with sand, there is nothing "natural" looking about chunky glitter.
I thought about keeping it for the lovely matte shades, but looking in the mirror at the cherry red color of my eyeballs due to the irritation caused by this product has inspired me to send this faulty product back.
Not wort the hype
olga from Florida
1. colors do not blend well
2. metallic colors are not pigmented
3. expensive for what it offers
1. it could be a really nice nude pallete
I personally do not like too faced pallets. I don't really understand how people can like it. I would suggest any pallets from Huda Beauty or Anastasia Beverly Hills
Lo from Texas
I was on the fence for a while about purchasing this palette because of some of the negative reviews. I love Too Faced products so ended up deciding to give it a shot. I'm so glad I did! It blends so smoothly, and the glitter shades are fantastic (works best when applying with finger)! Great for both everyday work looks, and glam!
Love the Colors!!
Teresa C. from San Antonio
This products is everything you need for day and night. The colors are beautiful, and they blend very well!! Love it!!
Love This Palette!!
Lyndsay from P. I. Michigan
LOVE IT! quick, easy, & multiple looks for everyday work and a day out shopping having fun
All my favorite shades
Emelmads from Buffalo, NY
All my favorite color combos in one! Usually i only use 2 or 3 shadows out of each palette but this one i can finally use ALL of them.
doesn't blend well
rker22 from WA
Love the colors in the pallet. I noticed this one doesn't have the same nice scents as their other ones, but not a deal breaker. I found the colors hard to blend. I would put it on, but then couldn't blend it down. I tried 2 different eye shadow primers and realized it must be the formula of the eye shadow. Because of this, I decided to take it back.
Perfect neutral palette for me!
Marisa from Pulaski, TN
I've been looking for a neutral palette that suits me for forever and the tones in this one looked like what I've been waiting for. I was nervous because I don't normally like glitter or shimmer eye shadows . . . but these look INCREDIBLE and most importantly, are perfect for my coloring. I'm white with olive tint to my skin and warm undertones. Most natural palettes skew a little blue and so they can look really grey and chalky on me. These colors are just right, they add life and definition to my eyes and I even love the glitter shades! If you're looking for a warm-neutral palette I highly recommend this one!
Not what it seems.
Sara from NY
Looks beautiful in palette but color pay off more similar to Just Peachy Mattes. Really wanted to like the shade petal but comes off so orange. Tried to blend nude and warm rose into the crease but got a muddy orange tic tac colored mess. Also the formula for these chunky glitters are so unnecessary. What's wrong with a buttery shimmery formula instead of a chunky gluey glitter?
Best neutral palette
Fancypants from Ohio
Beautiful colors for all skin tones, easy to blend,, pigmentation is great. This is a great everyday palette
Stands out as a nude everyday pallet!
Dana from Boca Raton
I have most of Too Faced Pallets. (I know I have some problems). When I saw this, I wondered, do I reallllly need another pallet? Well, I took the plunge and SO happy I did. If I had only this pallet (and my matte viseart) for rest of my life, I'd be okay. It has EVERY color and texture you need. From matte to foiled. The ONLY change I would make, is to add a few more Light/creme colored mattes at the front. This is a color i use the most over the whole Lid. So I would highly recommend this pallet. Even if you have many already, you WILL use this daily!
MsDeeBenn87 from Cowen, WV
This palette is stunning. The colors are pigmented and blend very well. I prefer to apply the shimmer shades with my finger tip and having a good shadow base/primer helps a ton! I didn't have fallout when using a base. I just wasn't completely wowed by this palette. It's a lot smaller than I expected as well! I love the color scheme though and would use these colors everyday if I could!