Rated 4.14 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product
I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review I used to love it
I used to love this mascara, it was lengthening and waterproof but the last one I bought smudged all over and it was super clumply, I do t know if they changed the formula but is totally messy now, will be looking for another one
Reviewed by 12446 customers This mascara is not waterproof
Jamie from Brownsville Texas
So I Have small eyelashes so I use mascara every day but I can never find one that's all the way waterproof. And this mascara is awesome it lengthens and volumizes my small lashes. But it's not waterproof at all, not through exercising not through water, not through even being intimate with somebody it's smears all over Your under eye area. I never write reviews but this is not waterproof
Big Mama D from Danbury CT
Loved the length and fullness! Lush
I love this mascara.
Sunshine from CA
Stays put, no flaking! Hard to remove. If you have a cold room, make sure to warm it up before use, it goes on way better.
Kate from Murfreesboro, TN
Stays on great for the most part, but too thick and clumps. I have to run a different applicator through my lashes every time I use this mascara.
Again and again
Chris from Tarpon Springs, FL
My granddaughter recommended this product. Good job baby!
Everything is Great But the Brush
Kalistra from Ohio
After i curl my lashes i always go to this mascara. the only two bad things about it is it dries very quickly and the brush is kind of awkward. sometimes it will make one side of my lashes clumpy and the other side won't be. but other then that it is a great mascara.
I would not buy this again
Destiny from Peoria
It does live up to making pages fuller and longer, but I look like a raccoon before I'm even off of work so it is not water proof. I've had better from maybeline and Clinique.
Kinda overpriced tbh
Lizzy from Michigan
L'Oréal's luminous lash paradise is comparable to this item for MUCH cheaper I have the primer and the mascara itself. Not saying it's a bad product but... essence also has some better products for like 5 bucks:)
Abby from Connecticut
For the price and how much this product gets hyped up, I guess I just really hoped this would 'wow' me, which it didn't. It's fine, no clumping or smudging, but once it runs out I'll probably be looking for a different mascara.
Is good but....
Ana from Chicago
I like it a lot !! My eyelashes are very small but this mascara makes miracles is awesome but not for everyday because is hard to remove and I feel it will damage my eyelashes because is waterproof. I like the regular for everyday.
I will continue to buy this product forever !
Boo from Canton Mich
I buy this product every time mine gets low and I try always to have a back up. It works amazing after I curl my bone straight eyelashes. I have tried many and this is one of two that actually works.
Clumpy and awkward wand
Long-time makeup user from Minnesota
I don't love how the wand is shaped or that the product clumps at both ends. Lower lashes end up clumpy and you can't wipe the product off the bottom part of the wand. The product itself seems to be waterproof and I don't end up with raccoon eyes by the end of the day but it's not easy to apply.
I ONLY buy this masacara! Its wonderful!!
chrisitne from nashua nh
LOVE LOVE IT!! I get compliments all the time!!
Angel from Cincinnati Oh
I've used this mascara for years and I love it. I haven't used any others and i don't plan on it!! It last for hours and keeps my lashes curled and intact even in the pool!
Stays on great but the don't like the brush
Tricia from Alabama
I was so excited to get this mascara. I had gotten a sample of the non-waterproof version and loved it. I cannot get it to apply evenly though. It wears great - stays on all day with no flaking - but the design of the brush makes for very difficult application and leaves VERY clumpy lashes.
Builds lashes, however ends up on your lids!!
LetyM from Fort Worth, TX
After years of lash extensions, I've finally broken up with them. Left my lashes short and stubby. This mascara does build your lashes, however dissapointed because it smears onto my lower lids.
It apples easy and it does last long.
Griselle from Youngstown, OH
It stays on long and it doesn't flake while you are wearing it.
Best Mascara Ever!
PJ from Apple Valley, CA
My eyelashes absolutely love this mascara. It does not clump, it is 24 hr wear and my lashes look thicker.
Pats from Topeka, KS
This mascara doesn't weigh down the lashes. Your leashes will still lift and curl after application. Staying power was a bonus.
I love it! Definitely waterproof
Monica from Shade, OH
As a dental professional, I need a mascara that is waterproof. I have kind of skimpy eyelashes, this mascara definitely makes my eyelashes look amazing!
I will not buy again as it flakes off. Too expensive for thi
D from Michigan
Flakes off, definitely not worth it, too expensive
Q from Q, ca
Did nothing for my lashes. Doesn't keep a curl, looks like no product is applied, flakes every where and leaves you with racoon eyes. Dont know how this is highly rated.
Bold BUT also ADHESIVE!
Aimz from online
I was very excited by the packaging. Every time I open it now, a giant chunk of messy black gunk gets everywhere! All over my hands and eyes... I wipe it off but the giant glob of mascara that I have to wipe off the brush has to go in the garbage every time I apply it because it doesn't go back in the bottle. It's super duper chunky on the eyes and don't dare to blink while it's drying or else you will get a glob of this waterproof paint all over your finished makeup and it's a giant hassle to clean up. I have to wipe it off my eye lids which hurts to do after needing to everyday. I like the product but I will never ever buy it again and I'll probably look into getting refunded because it's false advertising.
Suzi Q from Los Angeles
This mascara surprised me with quick application and superior results!
Sarah from Northeast
I love the regular version of this mascara so I wanted to try out the waterproof version for my wedding. This is very clumpy and does not build volume as well as the original formula