Rated 4.14 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product
I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review I used to love it
I used to love this mascara, it was lengthening and waterproof but the last one I bought smudged all over and it was super clumply, I do t know if they changed the formula but is totally messy now, will be looking for another one
Reviewed by 22959 customers Expected better
Anna from California
I've tried to use this mascara on and off for years now hoping that it will impress me, but it never lived up to the hype! I expected more from Too Faced but this mascara is so flakey and dry after applied. The brush can be difficult to use at first but overall it's disappointing.
Darth Xana from North Carolina
My absolute favorite mascara. My blonde lashes look fuller, longer, thicker, and of course, blacker in this mascara. I wouldn't dream of using anything else.
Not worth it
Jessica from Charleston SC
Wanted to like this mascara but as soon as I applied it to curled lashes it weighed them down and made them stick straight. It also flaked pretty quickly. Returned it immediately.
Worst mascara ever. Lashes fell out!
BECKY from Chicago
No joke, my lashes fell out immediately after using this mascara. Even being gentle with removing my mascara I would find tons of lashes coming out. If I could give 0 stars I would! I don't get the hype. Worst mascara.
LILY from CANADA
MY LOVELY MASCARA....
Flakes and raccoon eyes
AshAllen from Macon, GA
When I first put it on I was WOWED. My lashes had never looked better, and I thought I was in love. 2 hours later there were black flakes all over my face, I had the worst raccoon eyes I've ever seen. I tried a couple more times using primer and applying in different ways, but this mascara if just awful no matter what you do.
Best mascara ever
Gueraloca from Casa grande, AZ
Use it every day , and it makes my lashes big and beautiful.
Favorite mascara of all time!
Mothern from Melbourne Florida
I have been a makeup artist for over 35 years, this mascara is easy, not clumpy, buildable without getting gloppy, wears very long!
This mascara is not waterproof
Jamie from Brownsville Texas
So I Have small eyelashes so I use mascara every day but I can never find one that's all the way waterproof. And this mascara is awesome it lengthens and volumizes my small lashes. But it's not waterproof at all, not through exercising not through water, not through even being intimate with somebody it's smears all over Your under eye area. I never write reviews but this is not waterproof
Clumpy/Dry/Wand WAY too Big
Kris Tin from Connecticut
I don't understand why people love this mascara so much. For me, it's a total miss. The wand is enormous and fat. You can't get in there and separate your lashes or get the corner lashes without getting product on your skin. It's also super dry/clumpy and SO much product winds up on the brush. I have to use a paper towel to wipe half of it off the brush before trying to apply. So wasteful for what they charge for it.
Big Mama D from Danbury CT
Loved the length and fullness! Lush
I love this mascara.
Sunshine from CA
Stays put, no flaking! Hard to remove. If you have a cold room, make sure to warm it up before use, it goes on way better.
Banana from Livermore ca
I was extremely disappointed in this mascara. For the price and brand I expected a lot more. I have tried it multiple times now with the same results. Within two hours I have mascara raccoon eyes. I spend the day using a q-tip to clean up the smudges and it's really frustrating.
Nora from New York
Truly amazing mascara
Jen from Montana
I have been using this mascara for 3+ years now and it is what I end up going for every single time I am in the store and need to restock. I have tried a few other brands and they are good, but not as good as this baby right here! Does such a great job and not only adding some volume but adding a ton of length for my eyelashes personally. Very black too. 100% will buy again and again
Kate from Murfreesboro, TN
Stays on great for the most part, but too thick and clumps. I have to run a different applicator through my lashes every time I use this mascara.
Again and again
Chris from Tarpon Springs, FL
My granddaughter recommended this product. Good job baby!
Total waste of money.
Tonya from California
Sorry but this is the worst mascara I've ever bought. I literally spent three times as long as I normally do trying to get this mascara on my lashes. It is dry and the brush is way too big so it gets on your skin.
My Go To
Siamese Cat Mom from East Bay, CA
Every day. Does not flake or run. Really wish they would make it in Black/Brown.
Everything is Great But the Brush
Kalistra from Ohio
After i curl my lashes i always go to this mascara. the only two bad things about it is it dries very quickly and the brush is kind of awkward. sometimes it will make one side of my lashes clumpy and the other side won't be. but other then that it is a great mascara.
Hands down the best mascara!
Sda489 from Illinois
I have tried so many different high end and drugstore mascaras, and in my opinion, nothing compares to this for long full beautiful lashes. I use the L'Oréal lash primer before applying this, and my lashes look amazing. I was using the L'Oréal lash paradise mascara for awhile since people say it's a dupe for this, but I can tell you that after going back to this, this one is definitely better. This is my holy grail mascara!
I would not buy this again
Destiny from Peoria
It does live up to making pages fuller and longer, but I look like a raccoon before I'm even off of work so it is not water proof. I've had better from maybeline and Clinique.
DOES NOT LIVE UP TO HYPE
Dr.Daniella from Ohio
I tried out this mascara because it's so heavily advertised that I figured it must be great. Well nope. It is the absolute worst mascara I've ever used. DRY DRY DRY, flaky, smudges after a few hours wear. I do not understand how anyone can like this mascara unless they just haven't ever tried better ones. Going back to my Superhero...
Kinda overpriced tbh
Lizzy from Michigan
L'Oréal's luminous lash paradise is comparable to this item for MUCH cheaper I have the primer and the mascara itself. Not saying it's a bad product but... essence also has some better products for like 5 bucks:)
Libyan from San Antonio
This product would get really chunky and it would fall onto my face every single time I used it.