Rated 3.63 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review THE BEST Waterproof Mascara!!
I love how curled my lashes are and it literally lasts all day at the beach. Super black finish.
Most Helpful Critical Review Worst mascara I have ever used
I tried this mascara recently and am extremely disappointed. I love a good waterproof mascara but this one I just couldn't make work. During application it dries almost instantly, so it is impossible to do multiple layers in order to get the volume or length I was looking for. It is also extremely messy, when applying it gets everywhere, and since it is waterproof it is impossible to clean up with a Q tip. I live in Massachusetts where in the summer we get brutal humidity. This mascara did not survive. It kept getting stuck together and looked terrible. At the end of the day when I tried to take it off it wouldn't budge. I use the Bliss Makeup Melt which can usually remove anything. When that didn't work I tried the TooFaced Mascara Melt Off which is meant to remove waterproof mascara. It still wouldn't come off. I tried my best with what I had but my eyelashes began to fall out and now here I am a day later and there is still some reminisce of this mascara. I definitely would not recommend this to anyone.
Reviewed by 112 customers Love this
Cindyh62 from Wichita, KS
My daughter got a sample of this and she doesn't like waterproof mascara so gave it to me. I love it and am now purchasing some. I have bad allergies which make my eyes water a lot and this in the only mascara that will last all day and not come off or smudge, in fact it is very hard to remove ( the only reason I gave 4 stars instead of 5. I also love that it is thick and dark, I have blond eyelashes which are practically invisible which makes it hard to apply mascara, especially my lower lashes. I love that I can apply this to my lower lashes and not end up with a big mess like a lot of mascaras
Hooded eyelids - perfect!
WW from Themyscira
I have hooded eyes and mascara ALWAYS make raccoon eyes on a regular day, not to mention in water. This is the first mascara to lengthens my short eyelashes and keeps the curl and doesn't flake, smear, or end up under my eyes.
Removing it requires patience and something with oil. I use coconut oil and a washcloth and take my time. You can't rush through the removal process. If you have hooded or oily eyelids, do not hesitate! Buy this now.
Love The Squeeze Style Tube
Allison from Alabama
I got this in a makeup trial bag and absolutely fell in love with it. It stays on and coats perfectly. And I love the squeezy tube as opposed to a hard tube. I will be ordering a full size from here very soon...if I had to knock even part of a star it would be because it's not sold in the stores.
Cara from Austin, Texas
I am obsessed with this stuff. People have commented that it is hard to get off - but that's one of the reasons I love it. I can wear it at the beach, the pool, take a shower and it doesn't smudge at ALL. I use the NYX makeup remover and it comes off no problem. I only wear waterproof mascara and this one is the best I have ever used. You don't need a lot and it's not for layering, but if you have short blonde eyelashes like I do and a tendency to cry like whenever/enjoy outdoor activities, it's fantastic. I like that it's so dark too!
Liddy from DMV
I've been looking for this my whole life
Sweet from East Coast
Perfect for watery eyes, and wet weather. Finally a great waterproof mascara that can do exactly what I need it to do!! GREAT JOB EYEKO
Dee from Florida
This mascara does what it's supposed to do... be waterproof for the beach! I have gone to a water park all day and then a pool at night and literally did not run at all! I have been at the beach all day and no clumps, no fade, nothing! Yes, it is a pain to come off but with a good oil based cleanser it comes off. Be careful when removing otherwise you may lose a lash or two.
Ceci from MO
I personally really didn't like this mascara. It went on just as smooth as any other mascara, but it takes literally days to come completely off, and it absolutely wrecks your lashes, especially if you apply a few layers for more volume. I feel like my eyelashes were shorter, duller and dryer than before I put it on.
MOST DEFINITELY I WOULD BUY THIS AGAIN!!!
Sun Mermaid from Sacramento
I use this wen company comes over to swim , wen you want to look ur best in water n out laying around by the pool, reviews mentioned that it's hard to get off, yes if ur using makeup wipes, you need water based makeup remover, comes off no problem, mine was Mary Kay makeup 💄 remover
It's not even shower-proof
Jenn from PA
Lash type: stick straight
I tested this mascara twice in the shower. First attempt, I used little product to create a natural look. My lashes reverted back to being straight & I experienced major flaking. I removed it easily without any effort with my Heimish All Clean Balm.
Second attempt, I packed on the mascara for a bolder look hoping it would hold. It did not. My curl fell & I experienced some flaking. I removed it with a bit more work with the same cleansing balm.
holy grail !
rach from roanoke, va
this is the absolute best waterproof mascara i've ever tried. no other waterproof mascara has seemed to work for me - i've tried abh, benefit, maybelline, milk, and more. NONE have the effects of this mascara! the others would flake and run, but this one stays on in the water and doesn't clump lashes - it keeps them nice and full. it even stays on in the shower and when i rinse my face. however, a few flakes have come off after crying for 3 hours.. but that's expected. it lengthens and volumizes lashes without clumping. as for getting it off, i use the banila co clean it zero balm followed by water based cleansers and toner. use a generous amount of any oil based cleanser - vaseline or coconut/olive oil works too. overall best mascara i've used :)
Extremely Hard To Remove
jay from texas
this mascara look nice and all, but it's so hard to remove, it can be done (sorta). i take a cotton ball and soak my eyelashes in the garner micellar water in the blue bottle, and then i put some of the water on a lash brush and brush through my eye lashes with it, the mascara doesn't come totally off but it comes off enough that my lashes won't break off in my sleep. I don't recommend this at all, much better waterproof mascaras out there.
CAN NOT REMOVE
No eyelashes from Dallas, Tx
Impossible to remove. Took off so many of my eyelashes! I would rather have mascara running down my face than use this. It went straight to the trash bin!
Finally found what I've been searching for!
Polly from RC, SD
I've been trying many different waterproof mascaras, even my everyday Tarte in waterproof formula, and nothing comes close to this one. LOVE it!! Lifts, separates, and stays put-no raccoon eyes. I didn't have any problems taking it off. I used Clinique's Take The Day Off with a cotton pad, no scrubbing needed. So happy I tried this gem. Hope it's available for a long time to come.
Best Mascara Ever!
Jay from San Diego
I have stubborn eyelashes that fall straight no matter what mascara I use or how I curl my lashes. I received this product as a sample and I absolutely love it! It keeps my lashes curled, spaced and gives them length that almost give me a false lash look. The downside is that it DOES NOT come off. I have found that taking a little bit of olive oil and rubbing it on my lashes for a minute or two has helped to take this mascara off instantly. After, I wash my face and rise everything off. I hope it helps some of you who rate this low due to how stubborn it is.
The best waterproof mascara I have ever used!!!
Lori from Inland Empire, CA
Bold,intense coverage without having to apply multiple coats
Kat from Mississippi
I love this stuff because it gives great lashes and super waterproof
Maddie from Pensacola Florida
This is the most waterproof mascara you will ever use. I wore it to the beach and cried for hours wearing it and it didn't move at all lol it was so hard to get off I ripped out so many of my eyelashes
How do I get this off!
Smurffy from Virginia
If I could give this. Lower rating I would. I cannot get this junk off. I applied it FIVE days ago. I have tried everything possible to get it off my eyelashes. Make up wipes, Vaseline, Soap and Water, Baby Shampoo, Baby Oil, ANYTHING OIL BASED. I have let it soak. I am literally losing eyelashes at this point. This is the WORST THING I HAVE EVER USED.
I WILL never buy again
Heathwr from New Hampshire
I would never recommend this mascara to anyone! I wore it for 4 hours and once I tried to take it off it, it ripped lots of my eyelashes off. It takes forever to take off. If you don't want any eyelashes after taking this mascara off then this is for you!
BUY THIS MASCARA
Kayla from Massachusetts
This mascara is great for anywhere you go! I saw a lot of comments saying it's impossible to remove but i use GARNIER SKIN ACTIVE MICELLAR CLEANING WATER GET THE BLUE BOTTLE IT REMOVES WATERPROOF MASCARA!!!!! And then i just use cotton rounds or a wash cloth.
I used multiple makeup removers...
Abbey from Michigan
Overall, I love how this mascara functions and looks! It gives a beautiful, full look, but after trying it a few times I found that was the only pro for me. Personally, my biggest pet peeve is waterproof mascaras that are hard to get off. I first tried a drug store makeup remover which usually works for my other waterproofs, but it didn't even soften the hardness of the mascara on my lashes. Rubbing it off gently that time took a few of my eyelashes off! I then tried a Mac makeup remover (I believe) and after letting the cotton pads soaked in it lay on my eyes, it finally started to budge. The next day however, there was still mascara in my lashes and it made putting mascara over that very clumpy. I was real disappointed because I only wear one layer or mascara... I would ONLY use this if I went to the beach, water park, funeral, ect...
Perfect for Asian eyes & lashes
AB from Los Angeles, CA
Best mascara! Holds a curl super well, gives crazy volume and length. Only con is that it dries super quickly, so towards the end of the tube it gets pretty hard to use. It's also hard to remove with regular makeup remover, but coconut oil will do the trick!!
Favorite Mascara EVER
TheCrossfitter from San Antonio
Extends and lifts lashes giving full appearance. Stays on though toughest workouts and weather. Love this mascara.
Looove it!! It stays on amazingly!
no more under eye fallout from minnesota
I got a sample size, and fell in love after one use!! I am that girl that....no matter what, my mascara always paints my under eyes dark...throughout the day constantly checking the mirror for fall out...this stuff is incredible!