0.04 oz Item 2503791
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
Cons
Best Uses
Reviewed by 372 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
Goes on fully pigmented in the first velvety swipe and stays in the waterline. You don't have to go over it twice! Will transfer a little until it sets. Smoother and easier to apply than the Marc Jacobs. Better pigmentation than MJ. Finally!
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
I got a sample of this and LOVED it. It was definitely worth spending a little more than I typically do for eyeliner because I was pleased with the product that much (and that's coming from someone who prefers to just use drug store products most of the time).
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
Absolutely love this eyeliner. It goes on smooth, is easy to apply, and stays throughout the day. However, after using it for about a week, I tried to twist to use more of it, and it will budge.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
I especially like this for lining my lower lid; it doesn't smudge throughout the day, and I don't end up with black eyes. I still use a kohl liner for the top because I like to blend the line a bit.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
I was very disappointed with this purchase. I opened my eyeliner gel pencil and was excited to apply the purple liner. Lo and behold, when I opened it and tried to apply, the pencil was dried up. This was a brand new pencil! I will never buy this pencil again.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
Love it! I use it daily. Bought one for me and one for my daughter who also loves the ease of application and long lasting wear.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
This liner is one of my every day essentials. It goes on so smoothly and stays put. It sharpens well. It doesn't smudge and get everywhere.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
The actual product lasts a long time without running or fading, but the pencil tip quickly goes dull after two applications. Sharpening this thing is a nightmare. You burn through a huge amount of pencil just to get the tip sharp and intact. My pencil lasted one week of everyday use because so much had to be sharpened out. It's really a bummer because the gel liner itself is one of the best ones I've used.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
Glides on smoothly. If you need to blend, do it fast because it sets quick. It doesn't smear or fade and looks great until I take it off.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner:
I purchased this eyeliner in Fishnet, which is a jet black color. Smooth and blendable application. No crumbling like some gel or Kohl liners.
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Do you have questions about this product?
Get answers from in-house experts.
Q:
Is this being discontinued? I agree that it is hard to sharpen. But it stays on the best of any eye liner I've tried. My eyes water a lot, and it doesn't run or give me racoon eyes. I only see two colors on line, not the full range.1 answer
A:
Hi There! All shades, except Fishnet, are no longer available at Ulta Beauty. Try our Always Sharp Eyeliners as an alternative.Q:
Does this smudge throughout the day? I've tried so many eyeliners and they all seem to faint away and smudge under my eye.1 answer
A:
Hi There! The Always On Gel Eye Liner is considered smudge proof. It has a 36 hour wearability claim.Q:
I was reading some other reviews, is this liner the full length of the pencil or just the tip?1 answer
A:
Hi There! The pigment in the Always On Gel Eye Liners runs the full length of the pencil. The pigment in the Always Sharp Eye Liners is located in the tip because there is no waste when you sharpen the pencil.Q:
Tried to sharpen the pencil but very difficult to turn in the sharpener. Any suggestions?1 answer
A:
Hi There! It sounds like your pencil sharpener could be dull. A dull pencil sharpener will make it very difficult to sharpen your cosmetic pencils. We suggest using a pencil sharpener made by beauty brand like Ulta. Your pencil should fit snuggly in its sharpener.Q:
Are you able to sharpen this eyeliner with a regular eye pencil sharpener? If so, how? I am have an EXTREMELY difficult time attempting to sharpen it - am I missing something??1 answer
A:
Hi There! We recommend a pencil sharpener made by a cosmetic retailer or company. Our favorite is the cosmetic pencil sharpener by Ulta Brand.Q:
I have tried two different brands of cosmetic pencil sharpener, and cannot get the pencil to sharpen- it appears to be too small for the small pencil hole. Is there a certain brand that works?1 answer
A:
Hi There! We like to use the Cosmetic Pencil Sharpener by Ulta.Q:
Only used a few times and can not figure how to get more eyeliner out of the pencil, it will not advance?1 answer
A:
Hi There! These pencils do not self-sharpen. They need to be sharpened with a cosmetic pencil sharpener.Q:
What sharpener do you recommend with this Eye Liner? The ones I have tried cause the tip to break and I waste a lot of product. I really like it otherwise. Any suggestions?1 answer
A:
Hi There! We recommend a pencil sharpener made by a cosmetics retailer or company.Q:
I have issues with putting eyeliners in my waterline because they get into my contact lenses throughout the day because they wear off. Will this gel liner make my contacts cloudy?1 answer
A:
Hi There! The Always On Gel Eye Liners are waterproof and safe for the waterline of the eye.Q:
hi1 answer
A:
Hi There! We recommend a pencil sharpener made by a cosmetics retailer or company.