Product Reviews Rated 3.11 out of 5 stars
76 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Love this mascara I have been using another Essence mascara for years and when I saw this one, I decided to try it out...and boy, am I glad I did. The texture gave an odd sensation going on. It felt like it was going to be thick and waxy but in reality, it gave me beautifully defined lashes. I hate clumps and I didn't get any with this! I would not say it's the most lengthening mascara but it did a decent job there. I was easily able to build up the volume with two coats. In the end, I would say my lashes had a very "whispies" effect to them.
Most Helpful Critical Review So disappointed I saw great reviews about this new mascara and wanted to love it. I liked the volume it gave my lashes (which is why I gave it 2 stars) but I couldn't remove it at night. I tried my regular make up remover (Neutrogena), Micellar water (Garnier), and a waterproof remover that I use only for stubborn make up residue. However, not one of these products could remove the remaining mascara and I ended up loosing some lashes in the process..very upsetting!
Reviewed by 76 customers I love this Mascara! 5
Polly from Ocala, FL
Works great! Gives perfect definition, volume, and length (@ least for me)
And the price is unbeatable, too!!!
Would re-buy For sure! 5
Lilliland from Erie, PA
I meant to buy Lash Princess and instead grabbed What the Fake. I like it!! It was a great bargain at BOGO. Doesn't smudge and is deep black.
Surprisingly great mascara for the price 5
Nadine from Clay, NY
I have used it for week now and consider buying another one asap
It's ok! 3
Jenn from Morehead City, NC
I gave this mascara try seeing it was by the checkout. It was affordable and does the job if you don't wanna spend too much.
Flakes and irritates eyes 1
Michelle from Texas
While I love their Princess mascara, this one was a complete fail. It flaked immediately and got into my eye. I threw it away on first day.
I like it 4
Liz❤️ from Arizona
I like it cause it an everyday used eyemascara and it work good
Definitely worth the hype! 5
Izzy from Texas
I had seen this mascara with rave reviews. It is an awesome buy! Very inexpensive but great results. Coats every lash and Curls them. I have to say it works best on lashes that have some lift to them.
No volume or length in this mascara 2
Yo from Tx
This product has a great price but only good to darken whatever lashes you have. Does not live us to it's name. Other products in this brand are fab though!
Wonderful mascara 5
Shelle from NV - Nevada
It is wonderful and gives great extension to the lashes!!!
Hhhmmm 2
Alicia from Alabama
It leaves marks on my upper lids....it wears off easily
I love this!! 5
Leslieniqole from Alamogordo, NM
This combined with their mango butter lash primer is AMAZING!!! My lashes look so much better and get the best length ever!!
Won't buy again 1
Yas from TX
The mascara was dry and clumpy
I will not buy this product again 1
Tpic from Syracuse, ny
I do not like this product. I does not help my very small eyelashes.
Great 5
Micki3 from Sacramento CA
I buy lots of mascaras, I'm happy this one. It does build longer lashes, but wait between coats. Great price!
waste 3
Jangee from Texas
not good. no length or volume. sad that I wasted money
Disappointed 2
Snoopy from Tx
Mascara was dried out, returned it
I wouldn't purchase again. 1
Aislimn from Pittsburgh
The product was on sale and cheap so I purchased. Product is very dry and clumpy. Won't buy again.
Disappointing 1
Taelow from Milwaukee
I was underwhelmed by this product. For something that advertises itself as mimicking the "fake lash" look, this barely makes any changes to lashes. It adds some color, but no change in length or volume. Im glad I didn't spend a lot on it!
Terrible 1
Chan from Ohio
Clumps and adds no volume
Hmmm 4
Rory from Warren oh
I like the way it lengthens my lashes but I don't like the clumps
No volume 2
TYO from CA
Didn't volumize. Flaked off & burned my eyes.
Doesn't use a lot of product for the perfect look 5
Abby yeah from Canada
I love this stuff would definitely Recommend it. It's so easy to use and you get the perfect length and only like four strokes.
I normally love this brand but this one burns my eyes idky 1
Gabby from Woodville tx
Would recommend the brand but just not this mascara it burns my eyes
LOVE It!!! 5
Nadia from Dallas, Tx
I really have little lashes and this really was one of the first mascaras that worked for me.
Never Again 1
Let Down from Bowling Green KY
Very poor quality of mascara. Did not go on well and about 2 hours into wearing it my eyes began itching like I was allergic to it. It did not plump or volumize my lashes. Cheap!
