Product Reviews Rated 3.88 out of 5 stars
165 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Easy to apply, even application! Def recommend! 😍 I've tried SO MANY cream/gel liners....nothing compares to this! I started using the dip brow by Anastasia about a year ago, decided to give their eyeliner a try, def not disappointed! Love love love this liner!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Didn't work for me. First off, I'm a monolid, so I have difficulties with things like eyeliner rubbing off. I'm a huge fan of Stila Liquid Line and Kat Von D Tattoo Liner, but lately Stila has been flaking off during the day (I think my eyes are carrying more oil these days), so I tried this. I LOVE Anastasia brow products (use brow wiz, but also tried the Dipbrow which is amazing). I like the concept of using a brush to apply a dip pot eyeliner, I have a steady hand and enjoy the process, but after an hour I started noticing this rubbing a bit to my lower lid/undereye, and by the end of the day, there was no product left on my upper lid. This didn't leave as much product on my undereye as some liners I've tried, but there was definitely a noticeable amount. I'm really sad this one didn't work. And it might work epically for a regular eyelid person, but I've tried this twice with the same result of it not staying on, so no good for me.
Reviewed by 165 customers Not satisfied 2
Hope from Denver, Co
I got this because I love Anastasia Beverly Hills brand but this product is nothing it claims to be. It isn't waterproof. it always smudges all over my eye lids. I would never recommend or buy this product again.
Wipes/Smears right off. 1
lctiger08 from Columbia, MO
I was looking for a new gel liner since Ulta does not sell in stores tarte clay pots.
Best eyeliner 5
Meghan wt from Gilbert az
Long lasting and so easy to apply! The best eyeliner I've ever used
Love love love 5
Jackson from Colorado and California
I use the jet and the honey every day. I love how it stays doesn't budge .... needs a few moments to dry dry but once dry.... love. The honey is literally the best eye primer I have ever used on my self and all ages for bridal parties. I'm discouraged cause I can't find the waterproof cremes in honey any more ...... definitely recommend always. If you are not experienced in using a dip pot and a brush don't give up keep trying this product is amazing.
Best eye liner ever! 5
Lupita from Harlingen
Super smooth light weight eye liner! Stays on all day!
MUST HAVE! 5
Sunshine808 from Charlotte NC
I love this eyeliner. I've been using it for 5 years. I'm on my 2nd one! Last a long time and doesn't dry out. Also glides nicely and very black
Definitely worth the buy! 5
Uphreek from San Antonio TX
It glides on so well and is very matte black.
transfers 3
Vicki from Greenwood, IN
The color is great, however, this transfers onto my upper lid.
Pretty matte and pretty black 4
Cryingmylineroff from Santa Cruz, CA
I do drag (yes, women do drag too), and I love doing extremely exaggerated eyeliner looks in order to give the illusion of extremely large eyes. I needed something to fill in the eyeliner shape, and this was PERFECT. It's an extremely smooth formula and is a perfect shade of black. It's fairly easy to work with, though as others have stated it does transfer before it dries down, so I like to set it with some black shadow to avoid transferring. I will say that when removed, it does irritate my skin a little, though I attribute this to a combo of my sensitive skin and likely the gluestick used to cover my brows. I suggest if you have sensitive skin to try using coconut oil or a makeup removal balm to avoid having to use an actual wipe or makeup eraser towel and rub the skin. As far as it being waterproof, I have not tested this yet, though I will say the first time I tried removing it with water it did not budge easily, so this may be good for a swim day or something of the like.
Pigmented but Transfers Easily 4
TheonlyXella from Grand Rapids, MI
Very happy as I've just switched to an angled brush and pot for eyeliner vs. a felt tip pen, but this particular formula (simply because it's in a pot) requires setting with a black powder/eye shadow so it doesn't transfer throughout the day. I recommend even using a felt tip liner to go over the finished shape so it dries/won't smear!
I keep coming back 4
Bridget from New Jersey
Okay, so I generally only ever use gel eyeliners just as a personal preference. Of all they gel eyeliners I have tried (including Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner, Suva hydraliner and a handful of others), I have had the best experiences with ABH's. The color is an opaque jet black (with others i used, the color was weak or more grey), it goes on really nicely, it lasts all day, and sits nicely on top of all the eyeshadows I have worn it with. The only reason it doesn't get 5 stars is that if you have oily skin around your eyes especially by your brows, you might need to set it with a bit of black eyeshadow or translucent powder just to keep it from transferring. I've only had that issues a few times, but its really easy to just correct.
Terrible! 1
Mary McQueen from undisclosed
This eyeliner has to be the worst ever. I get to work and look into mirror black everywhere! Waterproof? I think not smudges and is a total mess! I am 57 and have been wearing eye liner since I was 19! This is terrible!
Great use with bent liner brush 5
Christine from CA
I wear this daily with my bent liner brush and it feels and looks so natural. This is a good high quality product. When you use with a bent liner brush you can just coat your lash line or do a dramatic cat eye. I like this for daily wear
not waterproof 2
mari from Chattanooga tn
i myself did not like it. I felt it was not waterproof and it also did not last long. I returned it
Hot mess liner 2
Amanda from New York
I purchased this hoping to love it as I do many abh products. But unfortunately this gel liner does not work with me personally. My skin is pretty normal, I'm never oily, and rarely have dry patches. I have tried this product multiple times desperately wanting for it to work for me and to love it. I've tried it with primer, without, with concealer, with setting powder, setting with black eyeshadow, and setting spray. It's nicely pigmented, the formula is smooth and applies effortlessly. But nothing I do keeps it from sliding down and under my lower lash line. I end up looking like a hot mess any time I wear it. I wish I would have returned it.
Disappointed 3
Deni from South carolina
I was so excited about this eyeliner I had been researching eyeliners for a while and set my mind on this one. It applies beautifully and I used very little and it went a long way. But at the end of the day it smudge under my eye and in the corner of my eye. I bought the waterproof one. I expected it to last longer than it did.
Great purchase 5
Holly from San Diego
I came in looking for Mac Fluidline which they did not sell in the store near me. I found this product and had concerns it would not be as good. I can tell you it exceeded my expectations. Doesn't budge all day even when applied under the eye and is easy to remove with micellar water. Don't hesitate to try this.
Very workable but doesn't last 2
Sarah K from Virginia
I tried this after both the Tarte clay pot waterproof liner and the Tarteist clay paint liner, both of which I had problems with the products drying out. This was great to apply and really smooth. But I blinked once and it was all over my crease. I tried to set it with black eyeshadow (which I don't think I should have to do if it's advertised as waterproof), and yet at the end of the night it was terrible. Returning the product ASAP
by stephanie 3
steph from my house
I wanted to love this because I LOVE this brand but it smudges too much I wont buy it again store brand is better then this one kinda makes me sad cuz I use all of Anastasia makeup
Transfers and smudges everywhere 2
Alex from San Diego
Nearly impossible to use on oily lids even with setting powder it transfers and smudges everywhere!
Best eyeliner ever! 5
Loveisabelle from undisclosed
This is genuinely the best eyeliner I've ever used! It's incredibly long lasting super black and easy to apply! It's my favorite!!!
I would buy this product again! LOVE IT! 5
Glam girl from Clovis, CA
I use this product for top and waterline eyeliner. It's better than others I've used in the past not too creamy which I love! Lasts all day long no smudging.
Yes 5
Samar from Springfield va
Easy to use
Liner is runny 2
Kari from Grand Junction CO
I would return this product if i still had the box it was in. I'm super unhappy with the product. I was hoping for the price i paid it would last longer and not smear as much through out the day (not the case). I had this liner on for possibly 4 hours and it began to smear to the point i looked like a racoon. VERY DISAPPOINTED.
My new favorite eyeliner!!!! 5
Jezzibee from Seattle, WA
I LOVE this product. I just picked it up on a whim while I was looking for a new eyeliner to try and after one use, it became my new favorite. With my angled liner brush it glides on smoothly and stays all day. It even sticks to my water line where it stays after an 8 hour day and no reapplying. I had a pretty rough day the other day and might had had a cry fest and my liner still looked great. Not to mention the pigment is fantastic and doesn't fade. I definitely recommend.
