Rated 3.95 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review New favorite mascara!
I was buying and trying some new mascaras to find one that was magic. I decided to pick this up and wow hello! This mascara holds a curl so well. I haven't tried it without curling my eyelashes first though. It takes a few minutes to apply and I do have to apply it carefully because if you are heavy handed, it will get clumpy fast. But when on, it's magical. My eyelashes touch just under my eyebrows. It's waterproof, and like and waterproof, it takes a little effort to remove.
Most Helpful Critical Review Works great, on some...
This Maybelline CAT EYES mascara looks quite wonderfully, but is made with some extremely toxic ingredients, SADLY. Your eyes will turn red and become irritated quite quickly. NOT PRETTY. Too bad, I'd love this mascara otherwise and throw the other mascaras in the trash, but the irritants in CATS EYES is UNBEARABLE.
Reviewed by 199 customers Perfect
Leynerrr from NYC
Every single mascara I've used after curling my lashes immediately ends up straightening my lashes. But this mascara is the one and only that works for me. I curl my lashes and put on two coats of this waterproof mascara and I look like a have natural falsies. The formula hasn't changed also i have been using this for about five years, I love this mascara.
Waste of money
Ariel from Denver Colorado
When I first untwisted it the wand was extremely bent out of shape - I had significant trouble getting it out of the tube. I had to reshape it into a normal shape with my fingers. The bristles were short and bent and ugly. I still tried to put it on. It was horrible and I am extremely unimpressed and disappointed
Mimi from Bay Area
I saw someone use it on Tiktok. Changed my life!! Waterproof, kept my stubborn lashes up all day. Plus, great price :)
gEveL from Salinas, CA
I love this mascara I wear it when ever I put on makeup it leaves my eye lashes looking full.
Nothing amazing about this mascara
Ash from Dallas
I didn't see a difference in my lashes using this mascara then anyone I have used in the past
Tara from Wyoming
For starters the brush didn't look much like the picture at all. The formula comes out very dry. It immediately transferred to my eyelids (top and bottom). No volume whatsoever.
Best maybelline mascara or any!
JJ from WA
Once you use this mascara you will never go back to any other mascara seriously! It grips on to every lashes gives it both length and curl you don't even need a lash curler even for the bottom the wand fits perfectly I LOVE it!
I love this product and have used it for years!
Judy from Plymouth,MN
I use it daily. It never runs when swimming!
I love it!
Layla from WA ST.
I use this all of the time, and I have lots of mascara's. It doesn't flake, and it give great color payoff without having to load it on. I do use a lash primer always. It also gives great lift, and with 1-2 coats, I have beautiful cat eyes! Will be repurchasing!
Love the look!
Layla from WA ST.
This mascara works great for me! I'm able to curl my lashes, and I get the perfect cat eye look. I will always repurchase this!
Good for straight, Asian lashes
WatKat from San Leandro, CA
This product is good for straight, Asian lashes (or if you JUST have straight lashes lol). Of course, i use a lash curler before I apply this and what I like about this product is the curled wand as it helps lashes sustain a curl. It definitely volumizes and lifts my eyelashes, though the one downside is if you aren't careful, it can clump your lashes together from multiple coats of application. In order to prevent this, I wait in between each coat to dry down - if it's too wet, lashes are more likely to stick to each other.
Would never buy this again
College chick from Tennessee
Just not satisfied at all. It randomly transfers to your under eye. I tried it for three or four days and this happened within 3 hours. Not from flakes or clumps, because it goes on smooth. Even though it is water proof it does this, very disappointed.
Heidi from Kingman, AZ
Easy to apply with out getting all over the place. Does not clump.
My go to mascara
Sylli from Riverside
My eyelashes are very straight, requires waterproof mascara in order for the curl to stay. This is my number one mascara I go to. I've tried all others from other lines, my eyelashes did not stay up like this one. It's a keeper
Jordan from Orchard Park, NY
This is one of my favorite mascaras. I have recieved many many compliments on it when I wear it. When I first started wearing it ), I had switched up brands to this one and people noticed immediately and showered me with compliments. It's definitely my favorite low-cost mascara. I like Better than Sex, but I would ditch it for this one. You can't beat the quality and price. Keep it up, you're doing something right. < 3
Good but only for lower lashes
daze from vegas
I've tried this mascara on my upper lashes and it made them look horrible but I use it for my lower lashes so my money doesn't just go to waste! Not sure if I would purchase again though..
Not so great
CYNN from Shelby Twp, MI
I reas good reviews on this mascara but this mascara SUCKS. It barely applies nothing on, it does not lengthen nothing. It's like I'm just brushing out my eyelashes. Will be returning ASAP.
Brush is Great!
Jen from Racine, WI
I love the brush! Good product!
Favorite every day mascara!
Zanna from Seattle
I really love this mascara—I have super thin eyelashes but this is enough to make them pop. 4.5/5, only reason it's not a full 5 stars is because it's not entirely waterproof. For the most part it stays on pretty well, but if your face gets wet enough/you rub your eyes there's still potential for major raccoon eyes. Just something to be mindful of! But this is definitely something I'll purchase again!
Abby2023 from Spokane, WA
I use this product every day
I absolutely love this mascara!!!! It defines and lengthens
Wera from New Jersey
MJ from Florida
The best ever
Love this Mascara
Angelina from Azusa
What I Love is that it doesn't flake or run makes My lashes look full and with volume
LMW82 from AL
I was expecting a little more from this mascara based on previous reviews. I was disappointed with my very first application. The brush does not evenly distribute and I noticed zero volume. The product will not be a repeat purchase.
Not the best
Meg from Colorado
Dry, did not go on very well. Ended up returning the next day. Don't waste your money