Rated 4.34 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Pretty Liner
So I bought this liner in the shade Brooklyn Thorn because the end of the pencil that shows the color is my perfect lip nude, which I was trying to find in a liner. But the actual color from the product doesn't match at all. It is a very dull purple. If it were one shade more brown instead of purple it could easily be a nude for people like me with deep complexion. The online swatch it horrendously inaccurate. If you are using the site as a swatch reference, don't. The product itself is actually very good. It's a comfortable smooth formula that glides right on. I prefer this formula to my Makeup Forever lip liner. If I found my perfect lip nude in this formula, I would never buy another liner again.
Most Helpful Critical Review Quality isn't the best compared to the other lip liners.
I've bought quite of few lip liners that are the same collection and they worked great but this one was hard to apply and rubbed off quickly
Reviewed by 1434 customers MY HOLY GRAIL
Kay from Arkansas
The best texture and the best colors!!!!
Sammiemakeupface from California
The color is perfect for my vampy lippies. This is my second favorite formula besides the Italia lip pencils
it's the shade.
Ari from Arizona
I got the color "Alien" which is the black shade, It's more of a grey it's not very pigmented. Goes on and stays on well but definitely skip this color if you want a true black.
Nice Medium Brown
TaliGirl from Virginia
It's a nice medium brown pencil. It does have a cool undertone. The pencil is creamy and easy to apply. I'm not sure how good it has at sharpening yet.
Dj from Cincinnati, Ohio
Used this underneath a regular lipgloss, it popped ! I thought this was gonna be darker brown, but it worked very well.
Perfect for the Price
h99 from New York
Love this product. Will continue to repurchase over and over. So inexpensive and the colors are super nice!
No I don't think I would buy again
Yessica from Anaheim
I thought the color would apply smoother.
I want to get a couple other colors.
Sha from New York
Been looking for a purple like this. Love it.
A little drying, but works well with balm or gloss on top
Brinson from Tennessee
I got the shade Spicy and it is a perfect true red color. It is easy to apply, but is pretty drying at first. However, as long as I use a balm like Aquaphor or a clear gloss on top of it, it is comfortable.
Love Cold Brew
DBrew from Virginia
I was looking for a nice brown lip liner to use with some of my lighter lipsticks and this fits the bill! For reference, my Fenty shade is 440. Cold Brew is a slightly red brown on my skin tone which is just perfect. I also have Downtown Beauty which is an exact match for me with more a deeper golden brown tone and Club Hopper which is a raisin / plum tone brown. All of them are creamy, can last a full work day and sharpen easily.
Lexi from San Diego
I got this shade and it's matte and a pretty red that will go well with vampy / darker red shades :)
Love the shades, Hate the formula
MaeMae from Oakland, CA
It's been mentioned in a previous review, but after trying a few different shades, I can say I agree. They colors are beautiful on my lips, look great paired with my lipsticks, and they are pigmented. But WOW, do they dry out your lips. Even if I pair it with a hydrating lipstick/gloss or a lip balm, it still dries out my lips. It's a bummer because I love the shades Los Angeles, Soft Spoken and Moonwalk -- especially Moonwalk, which is a unique gray-beige that's perfect for contouring a nude lip. I know they're super affordable but I'm not sure if I'm going to keep getting these. There are other affordable brands out there with better formulas...
Creepy from Outpost 31
This is the driest product I've ever used. I don't know if these are old, or what. I ordered 3 different shades: Little Demin Dress, Amethyst, and Pink Lust.
They are all so stiff and dry that it hurts to apply, and there is very little color payoff. I tried to "warm them up" on my hand, to no avail. One of them even broke, and I was NOT being rough.
The Liquid Suede lipsticks are my favorite lipsticks ever. I have 8 shades. I was really excited to get matching liners for them, but these are awful. =[
Dee from Port Sulphur , LA
For the price it works just fine
LOVE the Copenhagen Shade
HollyBelle from Virginia
I have very fair skin with cool undertones and dark hair. This liner in Copenhagen is my holy grail for a berry red or wine lip! I have been using this color for a long time because it gives my (often dull) skin a brightening quality. Would highly recommend for those who love a good cool tone berry lip! The formula is creamy and long lasting too!
Diane from Charlotte, NC
The first time I used it the point broke. Tried sharpening it and the pencil broke. I returned it.
I love this product from Select State
love this lip pencil
Leah from California
These liners go on like butter and look amazing on their own or with a lipstick or gloss on top. Will be purchasing more shades!!
I would not buy this product again.
Barbie from Medford Oregon
Shade - Cold brew
MJ from Va
My absolute favorite lip liner ever. I've been through so many. It's a great nude shade for my skin tone (400 in fenty), blends well with all my lipsticks, and even looks great alone with a gloss over top.
Best Lip Pencils
Victoria from Atlanta
These lip pencils are amazing !! They are buttery and soft so they glide so easily on your lips . These lip pencils are definitely a MAC dupe if you don't want to spend as much money but still want great quality . I always recommend these of MAC , nothing else .
Got Los Angeles! Perfect nude !!
Maya the bee from Denver, CO
I love the shade I got Los Angeles And matches great with my Kylie mattes ! It's a perfect shade of nude to me and love the color and texture. Great price too I was tired Of spending $20 for a lip liner.
Great neutral lip color
mpgorst from Pulaski, TN
This is my new "everyday" lip color. I have medium-light skin with warm undertones and what has been called an "olive" tone to my skin. I find this shade is just a bit more than my natural lip color, so a nice way to add some subtle color.
Beautiful Natural Color
Karen from Los Angeles
Line lips and Fill as lip color with gloss
Not what I imagined
Luce from Wisconsin
Used for lips but have to be careful about for what because it gives off a small hint of purple which worries me is a bit more sassy than I thought it'd be. Looking for great shade of brown but this was not it.