Rated 3.94 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Outstanding product! Stila magnificent metals dupe!!!
Let me start off by saying I was not expecting these to such a wonderful product. I have tried other products from J.Cat and have not been impressed. I didn't like the pigmentation of the Holographic 3D eye toppers. I was surprised to find this and discover it's a dupe for the Stila magnificent metal shadows foil finish in the pot. Those retail for $32 each. These are just as good!! They are extremely pigmented in their own but if you wet your brush before application this just becomes glitter and shine on crack. I have every color and hope they expand the shade line bc I would collect them all, they're that good!
Most Helpful Critical Review lots of glitter
These are ok. They are very glittery, if you like that effect. I bought this directly from jcat beauty online and would not recommend you do that, if you want this, as their customer service is really, really bad and Ulta has really good customer service, so stick with Ulta. I won't buy from this brand again from anywhere, as they have the worst customer service I have ever encountered and don't stand behind their own products. Also, I tried to leave a review on their website and, weirdly, it didn't get posted. They obviously only post the reviews they want to so it is not an accurate representation of their products. This is a shady company.
Reviewed by 85 customers So pretty
Licia from Hayward CA
Got the shade 'Dreamer' and I absolutely love it! It's the prettiest shade of light blue with iridescent reflects. This is the same exact formula as the colourpop super shock shadows so they're really creamy! This is a perf glitter topper.
bad consistency between product
Nikiitasha from Portland
I bought Orange you happy, Coil braid and 1st attraction. I loved those since they are pigmented. I found if i put more effort into setting the eyemakeup it sisnt crease as easily. However as a hooded eye girl this mousse texture does crease so you have to be partocular with application. I bought Fiery bolt since i wanted a res but that was a mistake. The red isnt as easily to apply and definitely not as pigmented as the others. I was rather disappointed.
Kay from Fresno, CA
I LOVE these. They add just a nice touch to your eyeshadow look. The creamy mousse feeling is sooo nice, lol. They can get patchy so there is kind of a learning curve to use these, but once you know how to use them they're amazing. Finger application is best. I have them in various colors.
Not terrible, but not what I was expecting
Heather from Florida
I bought this product thinking it would perform similarly to a Colourpop Super Shock Shadow, but it didn't quite hit that mark. The product is a lot drier and chunkier than a SSS. If you apply too thick of a layer it becomes really patchy and looks scaly. I do love the way the shade Chrome Galaxy looks and will use up the rest of my product but when it runs out I'll go back to Colourpop. On a side note, the packaging is a lot smaller than a SSS and I found it a little trickier to get my finger in there.
This eyeshadow is fantastic
Eye from WA
This eyeshadow is the best! Color is true to picture no base required. Such a beautiful glittery effect. It's so beautiful I intend on buying more for sure!
Just enough glittery glow
Super Ulta fan from Santa Clarita, CA
It's so beautiful! I love that this gives you a great highlight on your upper eyelid!
Ulta super fan from Santa Clarita, CA
Every time I use this with certain pink
eyeshadows I get so many compliments! It looks exactly like the pictures & goes on really well.
Came dried out
Dawn from Clearfield, Utah
I ordered several of these during the spring haul sale and I could only keep 2 out of the 7. They came extremely dried out. Lids were not on tightly at all. Another negative mark is the colors are not the same as they appear online. The 2 I did keep were really pigmented and beautiful though.
Atlantis from Salt lake city
That this would nice as eyeshadow topper. Bought because the texture was describe as fluffy mousse like. Nope dried and chunky with no color payoff. Terrible product.
Cin from AZ
Pretty, but the description was misleading because it did not say one had to use fingers to apply it. Brush or applicator does not work with it.
Still learning how to use this formula
Sami from Northbrook IL
It's super creamy but it's a bit patchy... I'm still new to makeup so it's probably a user error. It's super metallic and pigmented though so I hope I get the hang of it 🤞🏻
Will be returning when Ulta stores reopen
Makeup Girl from Los Angeles
Pretty colors, but this has to be the worst eyeshadow I have ever used.
Belle from USA
This is the worst eye shadow product I have ever tried. Splotchy, patchy, horrible pigment. I'm not sure how this has any positive reviews. It was like using a very expired product.
Emakep from San Francisco
I tried these out after watching Tati rave about them and they looked so beautiful on her. I don't know if it's idk how to apply them or if it's the product but I always regret putting them on. They never seem to turn out how I expect it too. It's a lot more glittery than metallic.
McKenzie from USA
I got the color Chrome Galaxy. It is chunky and creases. I tried straight on the eyelid and on top of eyeshadow and it was uneven both times
i love this so much!!!!
danny works at a petrol station ⛽️ from az
i used the shade dreamer to replicate the makeup look that matty healy had in the "love me" music video, and it is such a good sheer blue.
Jennifer from Cali
Different from the ones bought at jcat website
Candice from California
I used to have two eye mousse bought directly from Jcat website. Those were super buttery and pigmented with a wet/soft texture. I lost my original Chrome Galaxy so I bought another at Ulta. It felt different. Not as pigmented and buttery. I have to really press into the shadow to get pigmentation. It's still a beautiful shade but the texture is definitely different.
Ehhhh it's okay
sant6654 from San Jose, CA
I like the colors (I got the yellowish one & orange), but they're not going to be my go-to. They were a good price, but the quality isn't totally there. The orange one is beautiful but really chunky & hard to apply & blend. The yellowish one wasn't super pigmented & I'm just not sure how I'll use it. Getting the product from the container is weird, too. It's almost like a cream, but not..
Patchy and chunky
Jackie from Minneapolis, MN
I had such high hopes for this product because I heard so many people raving about this. Unfortunately when I got my hands on the Chrome Galaxy shade, I applied it to my lids, and it crumbled instantly and was very chunky and patchy. Throughout the day, I ended up with loads of glitter particles all over my face as well. It did not create a smooth look of glitter on the lids and just appeared thick and patchy.
Would buy again
Denise from Cascade, MD
Talc free and great color
I would buy this again
Denise from Cascade, MD
Can't have talc products. This is a great eye color for brown eyes
I will buy this product again
Denise from Cascade, MD
Great for color or as a highlighter.
stephanie from usa
This is beautiful.
Very sheer and pretty!
Deb from Hudson MA
Very happy with this eyeshadow! It doesn't scream "blue eyeshadow!" it's very soft and light. Creamy. I'm very pale and it gives a whisper of color and shine to bring out the blue of my eyes. It could be buildable but if you are looking for a bright or bold look this is a soft "angelic" look. Also great for teens just starting out with makeup, or those of us who are mature and don't want a harsh look.