Product Reviews Rated 4.34 out of 5 stars
788 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review SHADE BAE I have a ton of Colourpop Super Shock singles. Bae, just happens to be one of them, thats listed above. I'm surprised that the description is off as much as it is. Detailing the shade as Egg Plant, if you think about it, egg plants are a deep burgundy color. When you look at the color Bae in the pot, you will assume, it will swatch or be true to that appearance, on your lid. Think not! Its a burgundy shade on the lid. Its a pretty burgundy but, beware of you who can not wear reds or burgundy. Burgundy can make your eyes loom tired, or give the appearance of blood shot eyes. I use BAE sparingly as accent shade in my crease or "V". It has tiny flecks of teal.....which is pretty but, beware again, if you stay away from any size glitter or flecks of tiny glitter. I'll leave a swatch down below. Please don't take my review as a negative response to BAE or ColourPop. I only want to leave my honest feedback to alert others of BAEs true identity!
Most Helpful Critical Review Beautiful and easy to use, but hit pan WAY TOO FAST I used Wattles 3 days in a row as a one and done... and hit pan. I love the formula of it and how easy it is to apply, but I almost never hit pan on my eye shadows. To hit pan after using it literally 3 days is awful. I didn't think to check the size of the pots before that and now realize how SMALL the amount of product is, it is less than half the amount you get with most other cream shadow pots, so if you compare the value of this to other cream shadows, it comes out as costing a lot more per oz. As a satin shadow where you can use it as a one shadow look, the formula is a bit thick and so you end up using a bit more than you mean to. I'm sad that this shadow won't last long.
I also got lady bird, which is the glitter formula, and using this as a topper you use a lot less, so this one will last a lot longer. The glitters are all absolutely beautiful, but the colors are really similar.
Reviewed by 788 customers Itchy 2
CR from WI
I was excited to wear this, but had to remove it because it makes my eyes ITCH. Not worth returning for the cheap price. It's a shame because I like the color. Maybe it's just the one I got (ice dream). Guess I'm going to try to use it as a highlighter, but will not be purchasing again.
Not much product 3
AW from MN
Love the color and love the eye shadow but I feel like there's such little product.
Love it 5
Panda from Muskogee Oklahoma
Love the color and lasts all day
Yes, I would buy this product again in a different color. 5
Annette the Biker from Buffalo NY
Love the color.
Some of my favorite glitter shadows! 5
AlexisLobsta from Knoxville, TN
I have been using these shadows for a few months now and they're a great glitter formula that lasts all day and is super affordable. I typically apply the shadows with a flat brush to pack it on the lid, and I've gotten 10+ hours of wear with no creasing or fallout. I personally don't care much for the matte shades that have sparse pinpoints of glitter. I just don't see the point in buying the super shock formula if my eyes won't glitter in every light. These are a staple in my makeup bag and they're definitely worth a try!
crumbly mess 1
K from Milwaukee
Looked like it would be pretty but it came crumbled. Very disappointed in how ulta packaged it. Better off buying this brand elsewhere.
Different formula than most shadows 4
CR from WI
This has a very unique texture to it. I mainly got it for inner eye highlight, but it is itchy. Oh well, still have other uses for it. Have to layer it on.
In love 5
T from chicago
This is such a beautiful pigmented eyeshadow! I got this one shade of white that is like iridescent or something i love it sm
No pigment in twitterpated 1
Leanne from Raleigh
The texture of this is really nice. However this shade has zero pigment and just all glitter. Just look like I smeared glitter on my eyes … I am pale as pale can be, and realistically, a pink this dark should show up on me. Disappointed :(
Wanted this sooooo band BUT……. 2
Ms Royale from California
I really wanted to enjoy this color however I ordered it and it came crumbled just as another one I ordered came as well. All crumbled. Now I have to waste my gas to return it after paying shipping fees not to.
Now I gotta waste me gas !!!! 2
Ms Royale from California
Beautiful color … ordered and came crumbled
Looks pretty but leaves a mess 3
J from USA
I got shade bubbly, and while it's pretty, there's so many micro glitters in it that even after double cleaning there are little pieces of glitter all over my face :( I would use it more if it weren't for this issue
Love it! 5
Nadine from Maine, US
Very soft in texture, good color, stays on, and lots of glitter. I am so thrilled I discovered Color Pop! I have to get some more colors!!
creases fast 3
kayjaysan from Texas
These look great upon application, but then after a while it starts creasing very badly. Whether I use primer, concealer, paint pot, or just leave the lids bare, these always crease. They don't even last an hour on me. Perhaps those with hooded lids won't have this issue. Unfortunately these just look terrible on me.
Awesome 5
… from Th
Colorful and smooth. Goes on like velvet and lasts
I would not buy this product again. 1
Mags from Indianapolis, IN
After the second use I could already see the silver bottom. The packaging is misleading. It takes several applications.
AMAZING!!! 5
CPR Loves To Shop from Carle Place, NY
I had a cocktail attire wedding. I wasn't able to have my make up professionally done, so I purchased some new make up. The make up artist was super helpful. Suggested this eye shadow along with other suggestions. I ended up purchasing everything! My make up ended up looking excellent.
I would buy these over and over again 5
Avs from PA
They looks great in any shade and stay on great when wearing makeup all day.
Good formals, Incredible Wasteful packing 2
Tiredofwastingmoneyonemptyproducts from Stockholm
The pan is like 2-4 centimeters deep. Not even 5% of the package is utilized so it's wasting my limited space and on top of that feels very deceptive. It's a very shallow pan, so this large pot seems rather ludicrous.
Love 5
Sweetpea2487 from Arizona
super vibrant Rich color and it has soft feel to it almost like a moose. Love it
super pretty 4
a from tx
these super shock shadows are so glittery, i love them. i have ladybird, frog, and slave2pink and i love all of them.
BIRTHDAY CAKE DUPE!!! 5
Stephanie from Texas
If you loved Colourpop's limited edition "Birthday Cake" shade, you will love "Plume" too! Pretty much identical!!!
Super buttery and pigmented! 5
Jess from USA
It's like butter and looks great super easy to blend
Great single shadow! 5
Meg from Florida
The Super Shock shadows are a great single shadow formula. They look beautiful as both a one and done shadow all over the eye or incorporated into looks. I have several (Ritz, Plume, & Mint 4 U are my favorites!) and I find them to be super unique, sparkly, and great colors. Especially for the price!
Some hits, some misses (color-wise) - love the formula 4
Katie from Mooresville, NC
I am very late to the makeup game and only just tried the Super Shock Shadows this year. I have purchased a lot over the post few months and love quite a few (Shore Thing, Empire & Dreamlover to name a few) but others are WAY too light for my medium skin (except as toppers, but I don't want to only use them like that). The ones that work for me are stunning though! And the formula is incredibly unique - a soft cream-to-powder that applies much better with the fingers. Overall I love these, I just know I have to stick with the darker colors.
