Rated 4.07 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The best!
This is truly the best mascara I have ever used. I like SB Indecent Exposure Mascara and Full Exposure Waterproof Mascara but this new mascara beats them all. It literally does everything it's states but I do curl my lashes and use an eyelash primer (not SB brand). My lashes are curled and thin so when I do all these steps(curl, prime, color), they stretch out very long. I have been using this mascara up against all my other ones by various brands and this one has won so far, even up against my Ives Saint Laurent, Lancome and Urban Decay. With each one, I have thrown them out because this mascara is so much better. Now, I usually use waterproof versions because my skin is dry and I use heavy moisturizer around my eyes, which cause my mascara to smudge often, but this mascara has held up. The only other mascara I have that is on par with this one is Estée Lauder Sumptuous Extreme waterproof which I will keep and use. This mascara takes a couple of coats to add volume since it is not advertised as a volume mascara but a fan mascara. It stays soft so you can build intensity. Estée Lauder's is a one and done mascara but it is a dryer formula. I can't say enough about how good this mascara is and the price is fantastic also, very affordable. Give it a try, you will love it too.
Most Helpful Critical Review X-Rated was better!
My favorite mascara for a time was Smashbox X-rated. I think they've discontinued that mascara for this one, and the two are not comparable. I thought X-rated achieved everything I needed: volume, definition, long-lasting and it was easy to remove. This mascara goes the distance, but then getting it off is difficult. X-rated went the distance and could be removed easily with baby wipes, makeup wipes, or cleanser.
Smashbox for me is so hit and miss, and the changeover in mascara validates my assessment there. And I'm not usually one to write reviews that are more negative, but I'm unhappy with this trade-off. This mascara is fine, but in comparison to X-rated, it is no substitute.
Reviewed by 305 customers Love love love
Pompom from Massachusetts
I got this as a sample and repurchased the full size one! Soo good! Doesn't clump, covers thickly but still separates lashes. Thus it gives lashes both thickness and length!
A great find!
Mir from NC
Got recommended this from a Ulta employee and now I'm in love. Such a pretty, buildable, flake and clump free mascara. Will be a repurchase for sure! Holds up even while at yoga and running when I get off work.
HURTS AND IRRITATES MY EYES
kath from San Jose, CA
I put it on and within minutes my eyes begin burning. It's the kind of burning eyes sensation you get when you haven't slept in 4 days. It really hurts. This isn't a natural feeling at all and no other product has done this to me.
my favorite mascara
manaal from illinois
i've experimented with a lot of different kinds of mascaras and this one has to be my favorite!
Great for lashes but not for under eyes
Nat C. from Madisonville, LA
This mascara goes on so easily and nicely. The wand is excellent! However, by mid day I had raccoon eyes because of the flaking. For this reason I would not purchase again.
Very long wearing
Molly from Phoenix
This is the only mascara I've been wearing in the summer humidity and high heat that does not smudge at all!!! It is lengthening but not too voluminizing. It can be build up without clumping. I don't know why there's so many negative reviews but it's a really good mascara. It replaced my IT mascara which was my holy grail.
favorite mascara ever
Megan Lewis from Hanover Park
I've tried so many mascara. drug store and higher end. this is the best. fanned out lashes with buildable coverage just use an eyelash comb and they're perfect. doesn't really clump
My favorite mascara
Kaylie from Spartanburg, SC
I can apply as much as I want and it won't clump now it will get clumpy after a while of having it but that's normal, all mascaras do that. This mascara is the only one I like to use
Curlygirl from Detroit
This is just not it. It's not buildable, just gets clumpy.
Emily from Annapolis
This doesn't provide an intense, thick coated lashes look, but rather a very natural lash. It doesn't seem to smudge or wear off easily.
Does nothing amazing for my lashes
Luz from California
Brush is okay it separates lashes but the formula isn't all that great. I prefer my L'Oréal telescopic (black tube) and Benefit roller lash (pink and black packaging) because they separate and lengthen and don't flake on me.
Ann from Concord, NC
This is a great mascara. It goes on without clumping lashes together. It separates and lengthens.
Brandie from ID
I switch my mascara up between two or three different brands. All 3 are awesome
Lulu from Toledo, Ohio
This mascara is junk, I might give it one more try but it's junk. Clumpy
Such pretty lashes
M from NC
Great thinner formula for a beautiful lash line. Can build up for drama or do a quick coat for low maintenance day. No clumps and wears well. Good separation. Will be a rebuy.
I will definitely buy this again
madi hackett from plymouth mi
it works so well and it keeps lashes up and makes them look amazing and no fall out in 24 hours.
actually the best
yayy from boston
this is the best mascara i've ever used, and i don't even wanna begin to explain the amount of mascaras that i own. this is THE one that will get compliments, it's seriously the only one i've had a thousand people ask about. it really really works and a ton of my friends have even bought it because they love how much it works. it doesn't clump, but it takes a little longer to dry than others so just try not to sneeze or cough lol
CJM59 from CA-California
It's a little clumpy at first but after using it a few times it's great! It lengthens, gives you volume, and doesn't flake.
O.Prime from Antelope,Ca
Super Fan Lengthing mascara is the best I've ever used. I've been using mascara for decades and this one works for me. I love the brush. The brush coats every hair evenly. The color is the perfect black meaning it's not dull. The formula is the perfect blend it wasn't clumpy and is buildable. Also, it is tear resistant even in a heavy downfall. I do have oily skin and this mascara didn't budge. Find a good makeup remover because this is hard to get off.
Brush clumps almost immediately
Brooke from Old bridge, NJ
I really liked this mascara at first, the deep black color is great and the brush really lengthened my lashes. After a few weeks of use though the top of the tube was full of mascara and no longer scraping the brush. The brush began leaving huge clumps of mascara in my lashes.
Sofia from Miami
This is the best mascara i've tried. It makes your lashes look so long and so voluminous and thick. It can get clumpy if you do too many coats so less is more with this one.
Perfect from Nashville Tn
I get so many people that ask me what mascara am I wearing or get accused of wearing fake lashes.
I just keep going back
Kdoll from Seattle
I keep trying other mascaras, I like trying new makeup but I just keep going back and going through tubes of this mascara.
One Of My Faves!
OwlieTheOG from OK
Normally I don't reach for this brand but I was curious and ended up liking it. I use this mascara often. So far I have no complaints. I will most likely purchase again.
Best MASCARA that doesn't have the hype!
Mascara Snob for thin and straight lashe from Virginia
This is the best mascara ever! I have thin eyelashes that ALWAYS are straight down. I've tried everything Benefit roller, bad gal band, new magnet, Lancôme Idole, volume, Tarte 4 in 1 to Low end mascara like Essence (false lash) which isn't bad compared to all the others I just mentioned. All of them did not work either I ended up with flakes, clumped,smudges and worse of all 2 hours later eye lashes were down straight again. This stuff is amazing it's bold, thick (but each lash defined. It clumped together) they tend to get a little hard which I love because one it dries they are like that all day (wonder if it has glue lol, it doesn't! But it's so perfect) MARKETING NEEDS TO STEP UP THERE GAME ON THIS MASCARA everyone seems to overlook it.