Product Reviews Rated 3.81 out of 5 stars
264 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review A great mascara I really like this mascara it makes my lashes long and thick. it is a dry mascara but I like it cause I can build my lashes without it caking and sticking my lashes together. They don't feel dry or heavy. they just look long &thick and naturally pretty and it comes off easy .
Most Helpful Critical Review Very disappointing reformulation I have used Jane Iredale products exclusively for 8 years and used to retail them in a skincare clinic. However, I now find myself considering going back to the department store brand of mascara I wore before, due to the incredibly disappointing change in the formula of this mascara. After multiple coats, it barely looked like I was wearing anything. I took pictures with an old tube of the old formula on one eye and a new tube of the new formula on the other - huge difference. Even being old and on its way out, the old formula looked way better than the new. I know all the tricks - use a primer or D20, apply with a rocking motion, etc. The previous formula worked wonderfully for me, so clearly it wasn't an application issue. I tried going back to the regular lengthening mascara and remembered why I loved Longest Lash better. Please bring back the original formula.
Reviewed by 264 customers Flakes 3
Mommaoftwo from NC
I've tried this for a few weeks and it flakes a lot. The little fibers tend to end up falling into my eye. I'll go back to my other ji mascara. I do love the conditioner and have been using that for a long time.
No clumping. 5
DIane from Pennsylvania
Love this mascara! It goes on easy and doesn't clump.
Great texture and longevity, but... 3
Jill from Northern Virginia
I love JI mascara but this one takes several coats to reach desired color
Nothing like sample 1
Janet from Salt Lake, Utah
I received this as a sample and even with one coat it made my lashes look thicker so I bought the full size. I am disappointed because it's nothing like the sample. I've used it with and without the conditioner and I see no noticeable lash thickening or lengthening.
Don't bother 1
DBS454 from undisclosed
It does nothing. I'm not even sure if there IS mascara in this container.
Favorite Mascara 5
LMGal from undisclosed
I've been using this for several years and it is my favorite mascara by far! I usually have issues with mascara bothering my sensitive eyes and this is one of the few that does not, while also providing great lash coverage.
Great product 5
Lisa Greene from Mooresboro, NC
Good quality long lasting natural products been using for a few years now.
Fibers get in your eyes 2
The505 from Albuquerque NM
I've been using a sample of this mascara and it is okay, however the small fibers always get in my eyes which is painful and irritating. I don't think the use of fibers in the mascara is a good idea since they easily get in your eyes. They don't really help with volume either. I like the brush and tube style of this mascara and it is easy to get off with makeup remover. I will not be purchasing the full size of this mascara.
Great mascara! 5
Cheryl O from Bedford,NH
I love how soft the brush is on my lashes. The color is not too harsh and it is not clumpy. I like the shape of the tube so there is less waste and air in the tube. I will definitely purchase this again.
dissapointed 1
dissapointed from Ontario, CA
regular size is much less effective than the sample.
Had to get it 5
Cosmo from Va
I received this as a sample and I really liked it. So I bought the full size. Great spoolie and I like how easy it is to take off. No residue.
mascara and natural looks 5
Merry from Eugene, Oregon
this mascara feels "kind" to my lashes. It does what it's supposed to do and doesn't feel harsh!
Does neither. 1
mlavigne from Minneapolis
This was a disappointment. I've been using Thrive Causmetics mascara for awhile now and have been happy with it. In this case, I wanted to try a brown mascara and was making an order anyway. So, I thought I'd give this one a try. Unfortunately, this isn't thickening or lenghthening. I have to put on so many coats to make it look like I have anything on at all. I'm wondering if I got a bad batch?
Does neither. 1
mlavigne from Mpls, MN
This was a disappointment. I've been using Thrive Causmetics mascara for awhile now and have been happy with it. In this case, I wanted to try a brown mascara and was making an order anyway. So, I thought I'd give this one a try. Unfortunately, this isn't thickening or lenghthening. I have to put on so many coats to make it look like I have anything on at all. I'm wondering if I got a bad batch?
Not happy with this mascara 1
CourtneyL from Alpharetta, GA
I did not like this mascara at all. It did not add any length or thickness to my lashes and was definitely not worth the price. I love all Jane Iredale products except this one.
Wanted a healthy mascara 3
JanD from Illinois
I really liked the sample but the full size seems to go on differently. It is perhaps dried- it doesn't seem like the brush loads with enough product. This could be the dryness of the product. A bit disappointed. Maybe the one I received is dried
Quick Service 3
Debora from Little Rock Ark
This came highly recommended by a friend but I am disappointed Seems like I have to do several coats to get the desired look I want.
Mascara review 3
Terri from undisclosed
I like this mascara and will buy it again. My only concern is that it seems to be gone by the end of my work day. I wonder if I am applying to much of the lash primer.
But it is light, doesn't clump, and goes smoothly, giving my eyes a decent frame for the morning.
Mascara 5
Ei3862 from Suburb Chicago
The product really lengthens and thickens and I really love it. It is by far my new favorite.
Disappointed 1
MarianaW from Cochrane, AB
I have been using the mascara for a few weeks and I'm unimpressed. My eyelashes don't look longer or thicker. In addition, the mascara smudges under the eyes. I do not recommend this product at all. It doesn't have anything I like.
Natural look 4
Britt G from Florida
Not a bad mascara if you're looking for more of a natural look! I love the fact that you can add more layers with this mascara without clumps. What i disliked about this mascara was the fibers that would constantly fall down on my cheeks and get into my eyes during the day.
Doesn't work for short thin lashes 2
Susan from Lodi, CA
I have very fine & short eyelashes after chemotherapy and this mascara did not make them filler or longer
Amazing Mascara 5
Marie from Illinois
Longest Lash Thickening and Lengthening Mascara does what the title says. The black ice color is very nice, and my sensitive eyes do not feel any irritation. It helps to read the instructions on the website to learn how to apply the mascara.
Mascara that does it all! 5
Stacey47 from Hindsville AR
This mascara lengthens, thickens, is easy to apply and remove, and doesn't cause irritation. It is wonderful.
Mascara that does it all! 5
Stacey47 from Fayetteville AR
This mascara lengthens, thickens, is easy to apply and remove, and doesn't cause irritation. It is wonderful.