Product Reviews Rated 4.06 out of 5 stars
747 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best mascara I have tried! This mascara is definitely one of the best I have tried. It does a great job at volumizing, lengthening and separating lashes-- as long as you don't put on too many coats. I was amazed the first time I tried it. I went to this mascara as the non-waterproof version was out of stock so I tried this. So glad I did as compared to other mascaras (Milk, Too Faced..), this is the best by a landslide.
I see other reviews bringing up my only con, which is removal. I use an oil cleansing balm and found it a little difficult to even remove this mascara fully. I can't imagine removal with a make-up removing wipe as it probably wouldn't come off and would be irritating. I now use micellar water to get the mascara loose, get most of it off and then follow up with the cleansing balm. With this method it comes off a lot easier. I am going to try the non-waterproof version and see if I like it more, but so happy with this one!
Most Helpful Critical Review Worst mascara I have ever used I never write reviews, but after using this I have to. I had heard such amazing things about this line. Let me start by saying that when I use any other mascara, if I curl my lashes, by the end of an 8 hour day I will have some transfer on my brow bone. If I do not curl my lashes, this never happens. I also always use waterproof. And I do not have sensitive eyes. I put this mascara on without curling my lashes, let it dry, and FIVE MINUTES LATER it had smudged and transferred to both my brow bone and below my eyes. I cannot remember the last time I got smudges under my eyes, but I'm guessing it was when I was about 10 years old and had Claire's cheap makeup. So as I was on my way to work, I of course had to clean it off. I decided to try water since it smudged so easily. Guess what: water took it off without any rubbing. This is not waterproof! I don't know if it was mis-packaged or if it's just genuinely not waterproof, but every other waterproof mascara I have used from other brands has required makeup remover to get it off. And on top of all that, it turned my eyes bright red and they were burning for hours. And of course because I had to deal with all of this, I was late for work. It was a waste of $5 and I won't be trying any other mascaras from this company.
Reviewed by 747 customers Love it! 5
Abbie from Pennsylvania
This mascara is everything! I normally wear false lashes but with this I don't. My lashes look amazing! Will definitely be repurchasing.
It's good 5
Midnight from Ny
It's good but you could remove the mascara by rubbing your eyes
My holy grail :) 5
Lashluvr from Florida
Same praise as the regular lash princess, makes me look doe eyed and like I have lash extensions. But because this is waterproof it holds a curl better than the regular and doesn't smudge off in the Florida heat.
THIS MASCARA IS NOT IT 1
Mrod from Calexico CA
The only good thing about it is the price and luckily I didn't spend much money on it but this is THE WORST mascara I've ever tried it leaves your eyelashes super clumpy yes they look long but my eyelashes are naturally long and to remove it OMG I thought I was going to have to rip my eyelashes out
Really good mascara 4
Esme from San Antonio
Stays on all day without having to reapply.
I would not ever buy again nor ever recommend to anyone! 1
Mars from Myrtle Beach
Ulta sales person recommend this product. Said it was as good as the pricey brands. No where does it compare to any of them!
Very long lashes! 4
JK MI from Michigan
I have naturally long lashes and this mascara really makes them pop! Big negative is taking it off, it's very difficult. I use good eye makeup remover with cotton balls and even use the Ulta mskeup remover towels, too, and I still have this product on my lashes in the morning. I usually end up using remover again after my shower.
Every time I use this I'm reminded of why I shouldn't 1
js02 from US
It's very very waterproof, which is good until you have to run your eye lids trying to get it off (yes I've tried multiple forms of makeup remover). Brush is too big, so it makes a mess when putting it on. Super clumpy after 1 coat. Hard to shape lashes since it clumps up so fast
I will buy this product again 5
Leslie from Tennessee
I have no eye lashes and this mascara gives me long lashes and full lashes. I love it!!
cute and definitely waterproof 5
Julia from Texas
this makes your lashes go to the length of your eyebrows but it may get a little clumpy after 3+ layers, but that's nothing a spoolie brush cant fix! it doesnt run off with sweat either which has always been a problem for me. great and definitely recommend if you sweat a lot
Messed up my natural lashes 2
Michi from California
It was great in keeping up my straight lashes but it was super hard to get off EVEN with waterproof eye make up remover. I also felt like it really irritated my eyes and made a lot of my natural lashes fall out. Wouldn't recommend if you have sensitive eyes, but it does a good job for the price.
amazing, definitely waterproof 5
sad from georgia
ive been crying all day full on snotting sobbing every 5minutes and my mascara has not smeared at all. not one bit. definitely buying again. for all you sensitive and emotional babes 10/10 recommend.
I would not buy again 1
Joni j from Michigan
It's to hard coming out I like the green mascara better as brand but not waterproof
I would love to buy this product again 5
Queen from New York City
I have very short lashes when I use a product my ashes lashes a very long I love it I just bought another one a week
Best waterproof mascara I've ever used 5
Mary from Houston
I use it as a top coat to a non waterproof mascara since it it's harder to remove when used on its own. This stuff stays on and i love it.
I would buy this again 5
Lashes from Minnesota
Excellent mascara. No clumping. Really makes eyelashes look great.
Best mascara ever- and I have tried them all! 5
Sue from Indio
Price is awesome too
It's OK 3
Liz from Pennsylvania
The application is ok, occasional clumpiness but easy to fix. It stays put all day and doesn't budge - probably the most waterproof mascara I've ever used… to a fault. This stuff is so hard to remove. Micellar water, makeup wipes, full out washing my face, and there's still mascara on my eyes. I probably won't buy again for this reason.
Fantastic buy 5
Faith 1 from San Antonio, Texas
Love this mascara. Goes on lashes easily. Love the brush too, perfect for bottom lashes. Inexpensive as well.
New go-to mascara! 5
Miri from WA
This formula is very smooth. The wand is perfect and gives you very nice volume. It does not budge throughout the day like other waterproof mascaras I've owned before. Definitely recommend!
The only mascara I'll cry about if it runs out 5
Chey from Chicago
I LOVE! It makes my eyelashes look like false lashes, girl just order it.
Only mascara to hold up my straight eyelashes 4
—— from -
This has been the only mascara to keep my eyelashes curled! I don't like the raccoon eyes it gives me when I put the mascara on my bottom lashes though, so I use an old mascara that didn't keep my top lashes up, and it's perfect! Also I've read reviews that said it is impossible to take the mascara off, I use a cleansing balm (elf hydrating makeup melting balm) and I gently rub my eyes for about 30 sec and it comes off completely :)
Love it 5
Lele from Raleigh
Literally one of my favorite mascara
An Absolute Let Down 2
Jules from Omaha, NE
I've seen a lot of hype revolving around the Lash Princess collection & thought bout trying it out. Usually, my go-to mascara is the Benefit They're Real magnetic mascara, but wanted something a little more affordable. I wanted to like this mascara, but there was more cons than pros. First of all, yes it truly is waterproof since I accidentally took a nap when I was watching a movie on the couch. Had to use 2 different types of makeup remover products for the mascara. The cons are that my lashes appear clumpy & I don't want to take the extra time to separate lashes with my lash comb. It also deposits too much product onto the wand. The wand itself wasn't my favorite either since I prefer the flexible wands. I have tried warming the mascara by leaving it in a cup of warm water to hopefully help smooth the formula. I've even went into washing the bristles as well. Sadly, still appeared clumpy. Again, I guess you get what you pay for.
literally love 5
ravie from new jersey
Looks exactly like false lashes, i can shower and swim with this on and it doesn't budge !