Product Reviews Rated 3.11 out of 5 stars
883 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best eyeliner ever! I have been searching for the perfect eyeliner for years and have finally found it! I just got this yesterday and wore out for a birthday gathering and then again today at work. I have never been able to apply my eyeliner so perfectly and as fast as I can with this. I'm talking SHOCKED at how amazing it is. I will *never* buy another eyeliner again. The tip is small enough to go with a modest, thin look(like today for work) but dark enough to get a bold, dramatic look(like last night). I have always spent at least five minutes on my liner trying to get the look I want with both eyes while have them being the same effect. With this eyeliner I was done with both eyes in under a minute. Love, love, love this eyeliner! On my next order, I will be stocking up because the price is amazing and the quality is second-to-none. Like I said, I have spent a lot of money on different eye liners and I have finally found "the one".
Most Helpful Critical Review Almost a great product but... This eyeliner is super easy to apply precisely, but it's not pigmented very well and came out more gray than black.
Reviewed by 883 customers The best! 5
Irma S from Murrieta Ca
I've tried so many ink style liners. This is by far the best.
Dry! 1
Crystal from Wisconsin
Not even one use I got out of the eyeliner. It was so dry I threw it out immediately!! What a waste!
No from me, dawg. 1
MC11 from Indiana
I knew this was going to be a hit or miss product with the reviews. I love ELF products, but this one was not it. As soon as I got home from buying it, I went to apply the eyeliner. The tip was dry. Even after bending the tip a little. Hardly any eyeliner to use. I'll stick with the liquid liners.
So fun and easy to work with this eyeliner! 5
Ambellina311 from Washingtonville, NY
I have been eager to try an eyeliner pen with a thicker tip than the one I had previously been using. So when I stumbled across this eyeliner, I knew I had to give it a try because e.l.f.'s liners have never let me down before! This one has been no exception. I love the way it glides on. How easy it is to hold and use. I find that storing it upside down makes it more "inky" which is great depending on how wide of a line you are trying to achieve. So happy I purchase this and definitely will again.
Dry and empty! 1
Charlidot from undisclosed
As soon as I got home with my purchase I went to use it, it was dry! No eyeliner liquid at all, to get any out I have to bend the tip and then obviously it's just a blob. Absolute waste of money and looking at the other reviews they've had the same issue.
Streaky 1
daph24 from montreal
someone bought this for me thinking it would be great but omg dont buy this!! it is so bad. the black is very translucent and as soon as you try to go over it to darken the colour it gets streaky and weird. i love elf but i hate this eyeliner.
I love eyeliners and... 5
Lupee1996 from undisclosed
I love eyeliners and this one accomplished my wing look with no issues
I love eyeliners and... 5
Lupee96 from undisclosed
I love eyeliners and this one accomplished my wing look with no issues
Empty Containers 1
Tiff5432 from St. Paul, MN
I bought one for my daughter, the tip is completely white and the container is bone dry. Thought it was a fluke and bought a second one - same thing. Are we supposed to buy some kind of eyeliner ink to fill these ourselves?
Easily applied stays on long 5
Ruta from Uk
Easily applied, great shape to draw, stays on for long time.
intense eyeliner 5
nohemi from sacramento, ca
i needed a new eyeliner and for the price this product is amazing!
I love the intense black color and it doesnt come off or smudge
Literally so bad 1
Emilie Florkowski from Cinnaminson, NJ
This is the most frustrating eyeliner I've ever purchased it's dry the brush tore so easy, I'm not sure how the reviews are half as good as they are I wanna cry every time I use it
One of the worst liners out there 1
sam from florida
I usually never review a product but this liner was so hard to use that it adds 20 min to my makeup routine in attempts to fix it. Quite awful and would never buy again
It sucks. 1
mulletgürl1404 from Toronto
I literally just now bought it. And I opened to test it. The tip dried by the time i even tried to put it on. It's already not working and i've had it for 2 mins. At least it was cheap. But their brushes are great:)
eh 2
lilly from philly
it was ok the first use and after that it was so thin. the tip is also so wide.
I would not but this again 1
Lyta lyn from California
I know most of the people on here saying this is a good eyeliner are liars. The first use of my eyeliner pen it was clumpy, wiped off within an hour of application. And just overall disappointing. There's plenty of product in the pen but the tip isn't a good material.
Pretty disappointed 2
Emma69420 from undisclosed
Very pigmented, but it rubs off when going over an already existing bit of eyeliner and you have to press the tip until it bends to get any to come out at the very end, which means no thin lines.
Don't recommend 2
Ddawnn from Vancouver BC
It's so hard to use the tip because the ink doesn't go all the way. It makes your liner drag the liner you put on before and makes it so patchy
the worst eyeliner i've ever used 1
m3li from undisclosed
unless you want your eyeliner to be streaky and clumpy every time you put it on, stay faaar away from this product
Didn't even work 1
Ellenc from sacramento, ca
Maybe I just received a lemon, but this felt very dried out when I got it. It literally preformed like an eyeliner thats been used for a few months. It's unfortunate, because I like the tip and thick base a lot!
E.L.F. should fix its design cuz it kinda sucks :/ 3
jessica from Isla Vista
Liner works so deliciously, super waterproof and chips away after like 9-12 hours of wear rather than smudging you like a raccoon, but can get pricey because the pen caps dont stay on securely and they dry out meaning you gotta buy em again and again :/ worth? idk but im tryna find a new one
Awesome product 5
Ananas_30 from San Diego
This eyeliner has changed my life. It's so easy to apply unlike other ink eyeliners. You can easily make wings and it stays as long as you don't touch it! I bought several for my friends and family members.
super dry 1
shehnila from Morristown, NJ
I bought this about two months ago and I never got to wear it out because it came very dry and unpigmented. I shook it and all but you can't even see it on my eyes. even eyeshadow as liner is more visible. I usually love elf products but this is just not it. Pen shape itself is nice, but it'd be better if I could actually use it.
Used to love this stuff so much... 2
SaraBean from Buffalo NY
Seriously no other manufacturer makes a fat marker like this with and extra large tip that doesn't stay stiff when contacting your skin and end up dragging.... But it dries out SO fast I can only do one eye at a time and therefore I have to have two pens at all times so I can replace the cap on the first one and let the moisture return. I definitely store them upside down, and shaking the tube does nothing to introduce more ink to the tip. The asthetics of the pen itself is great, but the actual ink NEEDS TO BE REFORMULATED and with higher pigmentation. So disappointing.
dried out 1
user from ulta
the tip was dried out and it's not pigmented