Rated 3.98 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Didn't need falsies for my photoshoot!
Bought to replace my sample of an expensive brand I was scared to get rid of. So glad I did! I bought false lashes for a photo shoot and didn't even use them.
I always layer regular mascara under my waterproof lashblast because I have sensitive eyes and it comes off easier. Today I'm wearing uncensored without lashblast and it's just as great! Very impressed!
Most Helpful Critical Review Pathetic Applicator Wand
It was hard to get a picture to capture how pathetic the applicator wand is. It is nothing like the picture on the package. Many of the bristles were missing and weren't long enough to be of any use, it just globs on the lashes. Worse mascara I have ever purchased
Reviewed by 821 customers My new favorite mascara, don't change it!
Kat21 from Puyallup, WA
I have been searching for a mascara that didn't fall after a few hours, didn't clump, didn't flake and didn't budge. This is legit! AND thank you for finally bringing back an old fashioned brush on the wand! I hate the silicone brushes on wands. This will be my regular go to from now on.
Best mascara ever
T from MN
This is the only mascara I have used for about a year now. Pair it with the L'Oreal lash primer and your lashes will literally look like they have extensions.
rg from elkhart indiana
added a lot of of length for my short eyelashes, applied good but goes clumpy throughout the day, holds curl all day. i would recommend for going out rather than an everyday mascara
Gen25 from Los Angeles
I will not repurchase this mascara because it just weighed down my lashes and clumped them up.
Geee from Florida
I do not have a history of allergies and, until now, can wear any make-up. This mascara made my eyes itch terribly.
No. Threw away after two attempts at putting it on
Ufo12345 from FL
It has a nice color so I had high hopes..
Boy was I wrong. Dried out and clumpy as that one mascara you had for years as a teen and accidentally left open to dry more than once. It sticks to the brush, but doesn't really transfer onto lashes. And what does, flakes off horribly. I think you have better chances at making your lashes look fuller/longer using your dog's spit, Vaseline or melted Crayola crayons than this....mascara.
COVERGIRL NEVER DOES...
maeshah from undisclosed
COVERGIRL NEVER DOES ME WRONGGGG!!!! I love this it's so black and great price and packaging. So cheap. Perfect 100%. Go get yourself one asap. 10/10 recommended for YOU. I LOVE ITTTTTTT. YOU NEED THIS IN YOUR BEAUTY ROUTINE PLS. def buy again
I PURCHASED THIS...
CAT22 from ELIZABETHTOWN,KY
I PURCHASED THIS MASCARA 2 DAYS AGO AND ITS FULL OF CLUMPS
Doesn't Do What It Claims
LeynaBlue from Dallas, TX.
This mascara does none of the things it claims to - create full and defined lashes that won't smudge or flake.
The formula is very wet and messy. It clumped and flaked. And while it doesn't claim to curl my lashes, I would not have expected it to weigh them down, either.
I've tested it several times, including using one coat, using two coats, going out, and working from home. It failed each time.
I rarely throw away new makeup, but this mascara has no redeeming qualities and is going into the trash.
IMPOSSIBLE to remove
Steph from Utah
I cannot get this off my lashes at night, micellar water, oil make up remover, make up eraser, nothing gets it off even after several rounds of these.
It also gets clumpy very fast, I threw away my tube after a few uses because I can't deal with the hassle
So good! usually when...
whitneyban from undisclosed
So good! usually when I buy a mascara with cute packaging I don't expect it to work well, because all the mascaras I've ever tried that WORK are in super ugly packaging! this however is amazing and works wonders to my lashes. I love the applicator and since it is very feathery it adds volume to my lashes without making them clumpy!! not to mention the bottle is so sleek and cute to have on your counter. 10/10
Best Covergirl Mascara
MiMi from NYC
If you like a false lash effect this is the mascara for you! It gives volume and length and I highly recommend it! I only use waterproof mascaras and it doesn't flake or smudge. I usually buy 2 at a time.
I love this product....
abrilm54 from undisclosed
I love this product. My eyelashes tend to be straight and very flat. Nothing will get them to curl but this mascara helps them stay up for a while.
CJTriple from Terry, MS
I buy mascara products from various vendors. I like the Covergilr collection of long lashes and thick lashes. Because of the sensitivity of our eyes and using products for a long time, has it been considered to add an indication date somewhere on the tube so that after 90 days, you discard and buy another? Just wondering. I think it would be slick!!!!
I'm a die hard Cover...
teniaw from undisclosed
I'm a die hard Cover Girl Mascara fan! I've been using this brand for years. It's inexpensive, has great coverage, comes off easily when I need it too, makes my lashes look terrific AND they still make a wand that's straight not curved. Yeah, you can buy Cover Girl with the curved wand too, but at least we have a choice girls! I love that! I get tons of compliments when I wear Cover Girl. My eyelashes are very blonde, thick and long. When I put the mascara on it really makes my lashes and eyes pop! I recently tried Exhibitionist in Extreme Black. I really love it. Everyone is picky about their make up. I am recommending it to you. If it doesn't work for you it's okay. If you have short lashes or prefer waterproof or prefer lighter coverage it's all subjective to you, your eye type and what you like on yourself. If you want to save money, still look great and have amazing eyelashes I highly recommend Cover Girl!
it's not as amazing as...
isabellearianam from undisclosed
it's not as amazing as lash paradise by loreal, but i wanted to give another mascara a try and i do really like this. it gives me the volume but i wish it wasn't as clumpy? sometimes it isnt, and other times it is... i don't know, it's a hit or miss really. if you have one of those eyelash combs though, it is easy to brush through the more clumpy areas of your lashes.
Worst Mascara I have ever bought
KyRob from Michigan
Worst Mascara I have ever bought. Do not buy it. I have no idea if it's just bad or if this is what it's like, but it comes out in huge clumps everywhere - mascara absolutely everywhere
Dag56 from Zachary
This is the messiest, most clumping mascara I have ever bought. I have to scrape the wand so many times, then wipe the end before trying to apply, and it still makes a mess.
Worth a try!
Emily from Boston
I agree with the other reviews, the tube needs to be updated so more product is taken off, but, this is still a fantastic product! It provides lots of volume and length without getting clumpy of flakey. I prefer this over my more high end mascaras
Fudgey4 from NY, NY
I use it everyday and am very happy with it. I would definitely buy it again.
Jilli from Id
I have been a fan of specific Cover Girl mascaras since I began wearing mascara (more years ago than I will admit here ;) Most recent years I have been a Lash Blast (waterproof) fan. I saw this last weekend & thought always good to have another option... I really like that the ingredients are very similar to Lash Blast but no petroleum AND it also kept my lashes 'up' all day - the best thing about Lash Blast is that it also keeps your lashes 'up' ALL day & night! I haven't tried Exhibitionist w/ the primer, but alone your lashes have a natural look with lift. I have long lashes but they need a lash curler & an uplifting mascara to show the length off. :) Doesn't thicken lashes alone...maybe with the primer, but if I am honest I would stay a Lash Blast lifelong fan instead of buying 2 products what 1 does.
I absolutely LOVE this...
danielle475 from undisclosed
I absolutely LOVE this mascara. You don't need to use a lot to get sexy looking lashes, it goes on well on upper and lower lashes with no fallout when it dries. Also it does not clump which is a problem I have with most mascaras. I took a star off because for some reason when I go to screw the cap back on I always notice mascara all over the container that gets on my hands and I have to spend a lot of time to wash the product & get all the formula off, it makes a big mess.
This mascara clumps on...
meganelizabethfagnant from undisclosed
This mascara clumps on my lashes and also bunches them together. When selecting mascara I'm usually looking for length and volume... this definitely made my lashes stand out but also stick together too much for my liking.
This mascara is the...
janethe10 from undisclosed
This mascara is the best drug store mascara i have ever used! This is seriously very honest from the bottom of lash heart that this is the best. When I say it is very black it is truly black and the length i get is double what any other product has offered me.
Doesnt come off easy at all
Lauran from Shelby township, michigan
Using this mascara once and having a hard time getting it off at end of day. Who knows what to use that would make it easier to come off?