Product Reviews Rated 3.83 out of 5 stars
12 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great waterproof eyeliner They discontinued a waterproof drug store favorite of mine, the Milani Infinite liquid eyeliner. I used it for 10+ years most of which I was a competitive swimmer - it never budged during practice or swim meets. I needed an alternative and struggled, even with nicer brands (tried Stila, Urban Decay, MAC, etc.) I found this one off of a blog recommendation and I won't try any more. This is a great waterproof eyeliner, easy to apply, pretty quick to dry. Not proud of it but can sometimes go over 24 hours and it won't budge.
Most Helpful Critical Review don't be fooled by reviews if you're looking for an everyday eyeliner, for bolder looks, don't buy this. after one use it was already clumping up terribly. i've used this everyday for about 2 months now and it is the worst eyeliner i've ever used. the bottle is CAKED with hard clumpy eyeliner. i store it correctly, i clean the top off every time. still does this. stick with the NYX epic wear.
Reviewed by 12 customers don't be fooled by reviews 1
brooklyn from California
if you're looking for an everyday eyeliner, for bolder looks, don't buy this. after one use it was already clumping up terribly. i've used this everyday for about 2 months now and it is the worst eyeliner i've ever used. the bottle is CAKED with hard clumpy eyeliner. i store it correctly, i clean the top off every time. still does this. stick with the NYX epic wear.
Great waterproof eyeliner 5
Jess from New York, NY
They discontinued a waterproof drug store favorite of mine, the Milani Infinite liquid eyeliner. I used it for 10+ years most of which I was a competitive swimmer - it never budged during practice or swim meets. I needed an alternative and struggled, even with nicer brands (tried Stila, Urban Decay, MAC, etc.) I found this one off of a blog recommendation and I won't try any more. This is a great waterproof eyeliner, easy to apply, pretty quick to dry. Not proud of it but can sometimes go over 24 hours and it won't budge.
The best! 5
Audrey from Undisclosed
This is the only eyeliner that will stay put! I have greasy lids, and it's so hard to come by any liner that won't smudge. This lasts through swimming in the ocean, runs, and all night long ;) I will say it's hard to apply, but practice makes perfect. The best ever, please keep this product forever!
My go to eyeliner for years 5
Julia from US
Once you try this you won't look back. The black pigment is bold. The brush creates sharp flicks, It is the best!!!
Superb quality 5
Olivia from Undisclosed
This eye liner has put to shame a much more expensive brand that I've been using, goes without saying that it's the best one I've come across, it's a bold black, the main problem that I've had with all eye liners was the fact that my eyes become watery from the wind, and my eye make-up ends up quite ruined, however this one , not sure how it does it but it really stays, despite the watery eyes that have usually ruined a whole lot of effort! I'm very impressed and I do recommend, also the applicator is not as thin as I would have thought, I struggle with really thin applicators but this actually takes plenty of product on board and there's not much need to re-re-re-reapply for this reason, so it's a time saver too :)
Not what I expected at all!!!!! Very disappointed! 1
Meggie from US
Bought it a couple of days ago and was so disappointed when I tried it! It literally started smudging less then an hour after application and left black lines on the upper eye lid- it was embarrassing as I was at work!
Eyeliner 5
Maggy from US
Love this eyeliner!
Been using this for almost 3 years 5
Wilsie from US
If you want a bullet proof eyeliner this is the one. Have been using it in all conditions and it just doesn't smudge or come off. The best
great quality 4
Verity from US
Much better than other more-expensive brands I've used in the past - would recommend!
Brilliant all day 3
Honey from US
I used to buy another long wear liquid eyeliner, but after years they discontinued it!.. So tried this one, the bottle is exactly the same it glides on the same and lasts the same... Excellent... Only minus is it goes thick after a while so you never get you use all the product.
Not as good as i expected 3
Janet from US
It lasts really long but then it's kind of hard to put it on my eyes because the brush hair is too soft, so it easily attaches to my eyelash and messes up my make up...
Exactly as advertised! 4
Jassy from US
Love this eyeliner! This sets the base for long-lasting makeup. My only complaint is that I struggle to get it off!
