Rated 4.26 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review It's good, not perfect, but good!
I wasn't going to buy this since I have so many palettes already, but when I was in the store I saw it in person and fell in love. I love neutrals and these are beautiful! I love the way the palette is laid out with different looks beginning with light shades for brow bone and base, then a light nude sections, a pink/mauve section, a bronze section, and a deeper brown section. I've used the palette the last two days since I received it and find that the mattes blend seamlessly and they are very pigmented! I've already created looks I've loved. The shimmers are stunning, but best applied with fingers, as they don't pack much pigment with a brush. I do think this palette leans more on the warm side, but it's still neutral enough that anyone can wear it. This is going to be my go-to travel palette! One thing I don't love is the cardboard packaging, especially at the price point that it is, but on the plus side, it is thin and lightweight so perfect for storing away without taking up too much room or throwing in your purse for on the go. I say that if you love neutrals, you'll love the convenience of having them all together in one cohesive and aesthetically pleasing palette.
Most Helpful Critical Review Shimmers are tough to work with, gorgeous colors tho
The colors are simply beautiful, and I like how they arranged the palette - complementing shades are together, to make creating eye looks easy. The shades are very pretty and work super well with my warm/light skin. The mattes blend nicely and I love the colors. *However, the shimmer shades are a massive letdown.* They're gorgeous in the pan, but come out far more chunky/sparkly than shimmery, and they don't give you much pigment payoff or coverage. Lots of fallout as well which was super annoying. My black shirt was covered in sparkle chunks. I got the shimmers to work out, but it took some trial and error. Best application method for me is to to wet a flat brush with setting spray, dip into the shimmer pan, TAP EXCESS OFF, and PRESS onto the eyelid. Start with a little and build, as it's easy to either have too little or too much. Wetting the brush also helped the sparkly shades look more shimmery and less 90's chunky. I tried pressing them in with my bare finger but that didn't work either, as that didn't give me nearly enough pigment/payoff and it was just too hard to be precise on my lid. If you do buy this, TEST IT OUT before you go out in public. It's going to take a little bit of trial and error to figure out how to work with it.
I love the colors, but I'm on the fence about keeping it since I'm not sure the shimmer shades are right for me. I already lived through the 90's - no more chunky sparkle. Plus, I agree with those who said the packaging is cheap. This was not a win, but not a huge fail.
Reviewed by 474 customers Born This Way The Natural Nudes
BurgundySpider from USA
I love Too Faced Cosmetics. I love the Born This Way The Natural Nudes eyeshadow palette. The shadows are highly pigmented and easy to blend and build colors. I was never a fan of mattes until after I tried this eyeshadow palette. The colors compliment each other. The shades range from light whites to medium roses to deep browns.
Great neutral palette
Brittney from Florida
It's Ben many years since I bought a dedicated neutral palette, so I grabbed this one on a whim because Neutral Eyes is such a gold standard small neutral palette, I figured this would be great. The mattes do pull a little warmer upon application than they look in the pan, but they blend smoothly, are pigmented, aren't chalky and look fantastic.
Too Faced makes the best shadows
Anna from Tennessee
Every Too Faced eye palette, going back a decade, is FABULOUS! They must mill their shadows through a finer process than UD, for example, because they blend into one another beautifully. This palette can provide every kind of look for nearly any color scheme. I add Too Faced glitter eyeshadow over the lid when I want to add a sparkle. Even more beautiful together!
Definitely worth the money
BamaTracey from AL
Best eye palette I have ever owned. Colors are so beautiful and zero fall out. My go to palette for everyday and a night out.
It's not bad but also not amazing
Sha224 from Kansas City, MO
I like how the colors look in the palette but when I put them on my medium-fair skin it all turns out more coral/orange in color in undertones or super dark. I can only use very small amount blended to actually look natural for everyday wear. The power also loosens extremely quickly. One swipe of a brush and the whole top layer is loose power. Also for the price I was surprised to see that there wasn't an applicator brush included.
Beautiful for day and night
Sherry S from Nashville NC
Feels so good and looks natural day and glam it up for night out!
I like the Naked palettes better
Czo5043 from Cleveland, Ohio
I always through eye shadows were all the same, after been using naked for 5+ years I thought I would give this palette a chance since I love the born this way foundation. Nope, I was wrong. It looks better online. I was upset. Doesn't blend nice
I wanted to love this…
Michelle from CA
I loved the colors until I used them. Everything seemed way too orange for me.. couldn't keep it :(
Nice Pallette, Colors a Little Off
Aaron's Mom from Kennesaw GA
I like this pallette, but what appears to be browns are really orangy-toned. They look nice on, but it's not the colors I expected.
Everything looks orange
Sassarella from Minneapolis, MN
I wanted to like this palette, but will be returning. The colors are gorgeous in the box, but everything looks very orange on my skin. While the mattes have great pigmentation, there's a lot of clumping and fallout from the glitter shades. I'm sure it looks good on some people, just not right for me.
Paola from New York
Casey from Indiana
Fabulous colors and easy application, rich and smooth.
Braps from Chicago, il
I'm really disappointed in this nude palette. Every color I try looks orange. I always wear nudes and for some reason this on does not jive with my skin tone.
Amazing Nude Palette!!
Br33b3rry from Florida
I love love LOVE all the eyeshadow I've gotten from Too Faced, but I usually get Colorful stuff. I needed a new nude Palette and this one covered all my bases, I've already done quite a few nice nude looks w this! O love kt!
Absolutely love this palette
Tracy from Bakersfield
This is my go to palette. I love these colors so much! Too face got this so right! Great pigmentation vibrancy ahhhhh!!! Just the best! You cant go wrong with this! Keep it coming too faced!!!!
BD from Arcadia
These colors are light natural looking eye shadows that look nice on my medium tan face complexion."and very dark brown eyes. Happy with my purchase.
Beautiful for blue eyes!
GirlbytheSea from virginia beach
I'm medium skintone with olive undertones and blue eyes. This palette makes my eyes pop! The matte colors are so beautiful. The glitter isn't that great though. Lots of fall out, it's somewhat chunky and doesn't blend well onto lid. Looks great in pan, not on though. I bought this palette for the mattes so it's okay with me.
Tati from PA
Very pigmented & stays on all day.
kellyc from AZ
I'm glad I got this on sale because the colors do not match what they look like in the pan. They are very orangey. If you were hoping for cool and neutral tones, look elsewhere. The shadows themselves have good color payoff and last well through the day. The shimmers are actually glitter and apply kind of patchy.
Wearable! Not for beginners
mia from Los Angeles
Unfortunate that others are having trouble with this palette. I love that there are so many shimmers in a range of depth! Shimmers show up pigmented on my tan skintone, NC42. Must use your fingers for shimmer. Different shimmer formulas included. The orange gold is intense but the other shimmers are softer. The stark white shimmer is too chunky for inner corner. Different formula from the TF tin packaging, which imo is more user friendly. More like tarte vibrancy than ABH but better for the office.
Not a "glam" palette imo but I think that's intentional.
The mattes are neutral undertone but seem to pull the undertone from your skin, so they pull warm on me and I've seen them pull cooler on fair skin. Finely milled and very soft, easy to blend but buildable intensity.
Have been using this more than Soft Glam or tartelette juicy. You have to adjust application for the unique textures so wouldn't suggest it for beginners.
Such A Letdown
T from Denver
Was so looking forward to this palette and finally got it when it went on sale and boy am I glad I didn't pay full price. The colors look beautiful in the pan but do not look the same on the face. The shimmers can barely be seen when on skin. These eyes shadows also crease badly throughout the day. Such a let down.
Jose from Long beach ca
My wife like this give for her baby
KMax from MN
I was on the fence about buying this based on reviews. However, I'm so glad I took a chance. I bought in the 21 Days, so I would NOT recommend full price for this. No way. But if you need an everyday palette for work, this is it. I am light to light/medium in the summer. I adore this. I love that the mattes are more product than shimmers, since I usually pan my mattes. This is a thicker / chunkier shimmer, almost like glitters. I still love it. I can imagine that the pigmentation isn't there if you are a deeper skin tone, because the lighter shades don't pack the punch needed to show on deeper complexions, but it works for me.
So disappointed :(
gab from Indiana
I've been using the Too Faced Natural Eyes palette religiously for YEARS as my everyday look. When I saw this in the 21 days sale, I was really excited because it appears to be kind of an extended version of what I already use. However, I am sad to say I was disappointed. Like others have said, the pigment just isn't there, ESPECIALLY in the shimmers (my favorite). The mattes are okay, but not worth buying the palette as a whole for me.
Noor from Home
I love this palette so much. It is amazing natural nudes colors ❤️💯