Rated 3.51 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Applies well and is long lasting!
This product does take a little getting used to if you are not use to using liquid liners, and use felt tip eyeliner more often. However, once you do learn how to apply it, you can make very thin lines and wings. This is especially important to me, because I have small hooded eyes. Any eyeliner that makes chunky lines does not work for me! The only draw back is that it is metallic, and has an overly shiny finish, I thought that it was going to be sparkly but matte. Not the case. Also, the formula is a little hard to remove a the end of the day. I link that this might have to do with the glitter in it. All in all thought, I do like the product and will use it again.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not the worst, but not the best.
Overall it's a good liquid eyeliner because it's affordable and OK quality performance. The tip is bit too firm and pokey, so it's not the easiest to flick out your wings with, but the firmness helps to hold it horizontally and line your lash-line with (no water-line needed). The color is nice, and lasts me all day when I use my Nyx primer, however the consistency of the formula is watery and causes patches so you may need a couple coats to make it a very dark black.
Reviewed by 92 customers Burns
Anjee from Texas
I have the gold, which looks pretty but burns my eyes & makes them water.
Only water proof on the hand than my eyes
Katie from Indianapolis, IN
I always like to rub my eyes even with makeup on. On my eyes chip after water gets to it a little bit, but not on my hand I tested out. That's definitely odd.....
Okay but only water resistant
Katie from Indianapolis. Indiana
I put water on my eyes on the heavy eyeliner style I'm wearing, from this eyeliner I used. It's only water resistant I have to say, but so far smudge proof because small chunks of the eyeliner came out a little bit. It's also because I rubbed the water out of my face too
Not good. Watery. Creased. Would not recommend
Jeanette from North Hollywood
User-friendly with staying power
Anne from Los Angeles, CA
As a relative liquid eyeliner noob this is the easiest-to-control tip I've tried. Makes it super easy for me to draw and fill in the weird hooded eye winged eyeliner shape, and stays on all day.
The black isn't super shiny and sparkly, it's subtle enough for every day, but it's not matte.
The biggest con for me is that it dries out pretty quickly. You can still use it, but you have to keep dipping into the bottle to get more product on the brush. This can make it hard to avoid patchiness.
I have bought this over and over again
Thena from Phoenix, AZ
Great angles, easily fixable, does not leave you with raccoon eyes when you try to take it off
Stays well have to keep dipping to get more
imherym2 from Sparta, Nj
So far I like this product. if I had to buy it again and had no other options I would. I don't like to have to keep dipping the applicator to get more product. Wish it was a continuous flow.
Really Easy To Use
Kate from New York
I'm new to eyeliner and this was so easy to use!!! I loved it and went through two of them so far. I would recommend this to anyone else starting off with eyeliner and anyone who doesn't mind metallic instead to matte.
Lizzie from Tx
Glittery, it does stay on but scratch your eye and comes right off
love it, need more.
sammi from harlingen
For some reason I keep buying, I wish it had more product though
Allie from OH
The felt tip applicator was very fine and good making fine lines. The product itself seemed faint. I had to apply 3 coats in order for it to not look grayish.
Burns my eyelids
Blonde69 from Waco, TX
I liked the look at first but then it started to burn and when I took it off my eyelids were swollen where it had been.
better than anything else i've tried
mallory from Dallas, TX
Love this stuff. I went through more expensive brand, like Stila, all kinds of liquid liners before finding Maybelline's, and this lasts until I peel it off my sheer dint of will. The day my mom died, I cried for four hours straight, and eventually my friend who was with me said, "This is going to sound weird, but you've been crying all day and your eyeliner hasn't budged." I will never switch brands!!
I like it
G-money from Dallas, Tx
Easy to apply. Stays on for a long time.
i would not buy this again
Marie from mesa, az
way to runny
Precise and pigmented
Siena from Oregon
Love this stuff, I've been looking for a good liquid liner and I'd tried must of the stuff from the drugstore until I found this!
Love this stuff
Laura from MS
Love this eyeliner! I do a thin line above my top lashes, and it goes on smoothly and easily and dries quickly. Honestly, I spend very little time on makeup, so this is perfect for me. AND IT STAYS PUT. I live in the South - it is hot and humid. This eyeliner does not budge through a long sweaty Crossfit workout. It does not "leak" onto my upper lid, leaving a line above my lid like most other "waterproof" liners. I agree with others, it takes a minute to get it off, but I have those makeup removing washclothes, and with a little Cerave moisturizing face wash, it comes right off. I was hoping to find a brown (I have teal and purple), but looks like Ulta is out. Great product.
I would Buy this again I like it, easy to put on
Letty from Temecula,ca
Easy to apply on
Honestly I love it
Snuggy Buggy from San Jose, CA
I got the Teal Galaxy and I'm not sure about the others but the color is very bold. It has a great glittery look and it was super easy for me to apply with a wing. I did use a primer beforehand (UD) and it lasted all day, even through a nap. I docked a star because it takes a while to dry and it leaves stubborn stains even after using makeup remover--but I guess that's the tradeoff for a good pigment.
The one i have is absolutely useless
Amytaffy from New York
honestly this is terrible. its watery, thin, un-pigmented, overpriced, the finish is ugly, overall garbage
Very pretty but...
Manda from Midland, TX
This is a very pretty liner. The color is bold and saturated, it's not patchy or sticky. My issue with it was that it stained my eyelids for 3 days, even though I had concealer, eye shadow base, and shadow underneath.
Solar gold color is basically trash
Anyllo from Dallas, TX
Finally gave up on trying to get my money's worth from this product and tossed it.
I would not recommend this product
Stef stef from Pontiac
No, I wouldn't
Ruth from Minden, NV
I didn't believe it was as advertised. It states that it is waterproof, yet wouldn't stay on my eye lids when I put mascara on my lashes.
Missa from Delaware
The pigmentation was not as bold as I had hoped. The metallic part of the liner turned out to just be glitter, not an actual sheen. It does have lasting power, but application was not consistent even after dipping more than once. When I attempted to go back and fill in the spots where the color wasn't opaque it just balled up with the product already on the lid and managed to remove that, too.