Rated 3.18 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review New "Go To" Mascara!
This product is amazing! I have natural long lashes, but I love how full it makes them look. Definitely gives volume as well. Love how I don't have to put 7-10 coats of mascara like I used to do because of how long my lashes are. Now I do a solid 4. Of course like every new mascara, you have to get used to it, so of course it doesn't separate as good as I would prefer it to do, but even then, I would rather use a dry mascara brush to separate it. The one down fall of this product is how difficult it is to take off. Whether I try makeup wipes, baby wipes, soap and water, let it come off in the shower, it still leaves residue. Even to get it to a point where there's small but visible mascara, takes an unnecessary amount of time and just leave my face and/or under eyes irritated or red. But I don't mind it that much, only because my face ends up extra clean. Other than that, sold 4/5 stars! Would definitely recommend to anyone!
Most Helpful Critical Review What mascara should not do
I normally don't write reviews. But this mascara is so bad that I felt like I had to warn anyone who uses mascara. The formulation is not bad, it has that typical maybelline wet formulation. What is terrible is the wand. It does not fan out your lashes. It clumps them together! (And VERY badly)
I tried to give it a chance. But every time I attempted to use it, I ended up wasting time removing it. Will not ever purchase again!
Reviewed by 352 customers Worst mascara I've ever tried
RVT from Indiana
Extremely wet formula. Very messy and my eyelashes just kept sticking to each other. Absolutely terrible. Only thing I like is the packaging.
I use 5 year it's really good product
Yaneth from Aliso
SZ from rochester ny
Really clumpy, eyelashes sticking together. My eyelashes litterly look terrible after i use. Cant even return it. Waste of money that i dont have
not the best.... at all
Masooma from Michigan
I got this product because I heard the lash sensational mascaras are geat. Maybe I got the wrong one, because the pink tube of this mascara has great reviews. However this mascara leaves my eyelashes clumpy and sticky, and feels like I have a bunch of product on even with a regular coat. To really make this look decent on my eyelashes, I have to do a super thin single coat on my lashes. Anymore than two coats will make your eyelashes blocks of mascara with clumpiness, and minimal, but some, length. not for me personally.
Clumps on clumps
The Tea on Scara from DFW
I gave this a good 3 weeks and it's still terrible! This clumps my lashes horribly. I figured "oh, it's a new tube of mascara so it's extremely wet and will get better with time." WRONG! It's also hard to wash off (no, it's not waterproof). So that could be a pro/con. Upside, it doesn't flake while wearing. It's still the worst mascara I've ever used.
clmurphy from Warminster
This has decent coverage, maybe a little too much by going on a little too thick. I would much rather a mascara go on evenly so I could apply another layer if needed. This seems to go on very thick and has a tendency to clump especially at the tips of my lashes.
Hurts to apply if you want long lashes
Jaydenn from De Moines, Iowa
Again, when you apply this mascara is hurts lashes.
Kate from Boston
This mascara has been my go to for years! Makes my lashes look thick and voluminous. Only thing that I don't like is that it takes a lot to wash off. Other than that it's great. Doesn't flake during the day
ADS from California
I hate this product, it made my lashes look clumpy and gross. Definitely would not recommend. I try to give drug store brands a chance but they always blow it.
R from Florida
This is my favorite mascara, I see reviews saying it's hard to get off- DO NOT GET THE WATERPROOF ONE, then remove your face makeup like normal avoiding your mascara then wash your face like normal with warm water and go back in with your makeup remover (preferably micellar water)
on your eyes, it softens the mascara and never rips out my lashes and gets it ALL off. I use this mascara FOR COLOR AND LENGTH once I apply this mascara I go in while it's still wet with the better than sex mascara for volume! Mascara is about layering sometimes so try to use different mascaras on top to get the look you want. Truly my go to I have naturally long eyelashes and always get compliments and this is my favorite, repurchased too many times to count.
Don't let the 1 reviews turn you away
GNess from Palm Springs
This is actually a great mascara. You have finesse it though, I have to remove some Of the product from the wand before application Bc it holds too much product. When I do that I love the length it gives, it is super black, and it does not flake.
My only issue is the removal, I use makeup forever eye makeup remover, I feel like I have to use more product and let it set longer when I remove this mascara. So of course you never want to tug at your eye or risk pulling out your lashes. So I personally have to be more thoughtful when removing this mascara which is why I gave it a 4.
No stars wasn't an option
MyLashesGrewFingers from Home
Terrible. This is the worst mascara I've ever used. If you're into super clumpy spider lashes, then this might be your feel. Applying this mascara ruined my day. Don't do it.
dupe for badgal bang
ostacy94 from tn
I personally love it. finally found a dupe for badgal bang. I just cant justify spending near 30 bucks on mascara anymore. this is an advanced mascara, it goes on wet and you have to know how to work this type of wand with your type of lashes. it may not work for everyone but I'm very happy I got this one. I will be buying the original because I hear it separates more.
Lash sensational luscious mascara
Southern Belle from Louisiana
There is nothing bad about this product! It's awesome. My eyelashes look great and I don't have to apply it one thousand times to get the look I want
I've never disliked a product enough to write a review
Samantha from Orlando, FL
Awful- this is easily the worst mascara I've ever used. While the formula is very black, it's far too wet and heavy. It bunches my lash in a way that makes them look very sparse. I don't typically have an issue with having mascara transfer to my under eye area but it is HORRIBLE with this mascara. It transfers within a few hours and I'm embarrassingly stuck at work with raccoon eyes. Setting with obscene amounts of powder doesn't counteract this either. Lousy.
MelissaAnn from anaheim, ca
I've used this mascara many times and this time it's so clumpy. I'm hoping it's just a bad batch because I loved this mascara. very disappointed this time to not be able to use it.
Lashes lashes lashes
Liz from Bluffton sc
I love my new mascara it seriously made me look like I had full eyelashe extensions!!!!
Impossible to remove
KimNYC from New York, NY
This mascara is nearly impossible to remove. It acts like a "tubing" mascara- so you need to use warm water and literally pull it off your natural lashes. I used Clinique Take the Day Off balm, L'Oréal micellar water waterproof formula, and Philosophy Purity Made Simple to attempt to remove it, and even after using all of these, balls of mascara remained on my lashes. This mascara leaves black stains under your eyes too. It's terrible.
My favorite drug store brand mascara.
Rosy from Chicago IL
I use it basically everyday, 8hrs a day, it smudges a bit.
Awesome Mascara!Just be aware of amount of product on wand!
Angelica from GA
I LOVE this mascara! I have long lashes without the volume. When I want to wear hardly any makeup I can control the amount of this mascara applied to create a subtle effect, and when I want a dramatic eye I just apply more. You HAVE to be aware of the amount of the product on the wand so that your lashes do not clump together.If you are aware of this, it is a great product! I have used Loreal to Estee Lauder, Mac to IT and I find this to be just as great if not better than the more expensive products.
InSeekofMascara from Kempner, TX
Really struggling trying to find the right mascara. I love Smashbox's Super Fan, but it's $23 or more and the contents literally lasts 2 weeks before it stops doing what it's supposed to do. Tried this mascara to see if there was a cheaper option to purchase every 2 weeks, but this mascara just clumps and doesn't allow you to volumize and lengthen.
Straight Eyelash Girl from DC
I am half asian and half white and my eyelashes are very straight and go straight down. I always curl my lashes then use certain waterproof mascaras to hold the curl. Better than sex waterproof is my go to but I'm a broke college student trying to find cheaper mascaras that work. This mascara has a horrible wand application, the bristles are so small they don't even run through and comb your lashes. It comes off so clumpy even when I brushed it out it was just awful. I tried wearing it for a day and it just looked worse and worse and the curl didn't hold. It was also super difficult to come off which was awful. Honestly I'm never buying this again. For all my asian ladies or SUPER straight eyelash ladies do NOT get this mascara.
Kelly K from New Jersey
Very wet formula, the wand traps so much product in the bristles that it just messy and sometimes clumpy if I'm not careful. They will look long and thick but I've tried much better
Thick lashes without the clumps!
Lisa P from Lansing
LOVE this mascara!! I have sparse wimpy lashes that need so much help and this mascara does the job. It lengthens and thickens beautifully, and stays put all day.
It doesn't flake either.
My only negative would be that it's a bit tough to take off.
The best ever!!!
Randall from Santa Rosa, California
I absolutely love love love this mascara it gives me life!!! I personally have the hardest time finding a mascara that works. I've been through a lot!!! But I'm happy to finally find a great mascara again.❤️