Rated 4.16 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best mascara I have tried!
This mascara is definitely one of the best I have tried. It does a great job at volumizing, lengthening and separating lashes-- as long as you don't put on too many coats. I was amazed the first time I tried it. I went to this mascara as the non-waterproof version was out of stock so I tried this. So glad I did as compared to other mascaras (Milk, Too Faced..), this is the best by a landslide.
I see other reviews bringing up my only con, which is removal. I use an oil cleansing balm and found it a little difficult to even remove this mascara fully. I can't imagine removal with a make-up removing wipe as it probably wouldn't come off and would be irritating. I now use micellar water to get the mascara loose, get most of it off and then follow up with the cleansing balm. With this method it comes off a lot easier. I am going to try the non-waterproof version and see if I like it more, but so happy with this one!
Most Helpful Critical Review Worst mascara I have ever used
I never write reviews, but after using this I have to. I had heard such amazing things about this line. Let me start by saying that when I use any other mascara, if I curl my lashes, by the end of an 8 hour day I will have some transfer on my brow bone. If I do not curl my lashes, this never happens. I also always use waterproof. And I do not have sensitive eyes. I put this mascara on without curling my lashes, let it dry, and FIVE MINUTES LATER it had smudged and transferred to both my brow bone and below my eyes. I cannot remember the last time I got smudges under my eyes, but I'm guessing it was when I was about 10 years old and had Claire's cheap makeup. So as I was on my way to work, I of course had to clean it off. I decided to try water since it smudged so easily. Guess what: water took it off without any rubbing. This is not waterproof! I don't know if it was mis-packaged or if it's just genuinely not waterproof, but every other waterproof mascara I have used from other brands has required makeup remover to get it off. And on top of all that, it turned my eyes bright red and they were burning for hours. And of course because I had to deal with all of this, I was late for work. It was a waste of $5 and I won't be trying any other mascaras from this company.
Reviewed by 356 customers I love this mascara.
Cathy from Lake Worth, Texas
I love this mascara
Didn't work for me
Waterproofneeded from Henderson
It didn't have a waterproof effect that I need. It became waterproof once it was on my skin.
Leslie from Denver
this mascara doesn't clump, and it creates such a nice effect for my lashes
Not for people with monolids/super short lashes
Person with monolids from San Jose, CA
So I have monolids and short lashes. And when I say "short" I mean like when my eyes are open you cannot see my lashes. The most you see of my lashes when my eyes are open is the veryyyyy ends. So if you are like me, I wouldn't recommend this mascara because it doesn't do much in terms of length, you can see a bit more of my lashes but not much. It makes no difference.
I was excited to try it but it just isn't for me :(
mrsarvu06 from Illinois
I love it. Its my go too.
One of my new favorites
Lyss from IN
This is such a great affordable mascara. It puts quite a few of my $20+ high end mascars to shame. It makes my lashes look almost like false lashes. My lashes are straight and my eye lids are oily, but this doesn't smudge or fall throughout the day. It's one of my new favorites!
I plan to buy more
EM from SC
It is a lot better than I expected.
c dubs from Fjxfistisridgixgjchkvohcho
I love it!
Landi from Stockton, ca
Love this mascara!
Long lasting. Doesn't flake!
Deborahlee from San Diego
I wear it everyday, comes off with micellular water easily.
Veganbeauty from Jacksonville Florida
I really like the effect on my lashes, but be careful not to apply to much at one time.
Go on nice
Kimberly from Pensacola
It's a really good price and lasts a long time for the price I've had it on for 24 hours ago and it still looks like I just put it on
wanted to like it
buyer from ny
ended up with raccoon eyes in just a few hours
THE BEST MASCARA EVER
Cailean from TX
I love this mascara so much! It really makes your eyelashes look fake and the best part is that it's waterproof as well! Will continue to purchase!
didn't work for me
ultafan from ny
left me with racoons eyes. Didn't rub my eyes and wore a mask for just a few minutes
Sarah from California
By far the best mascara I have ever tried, and the price point is crazy! Highly recommend to anyone who will listen.
I have been using this mascara for a while and I love it
Flemington Mom from Flemington, NJ
I have oily skin and oily eyelids and this is the only mascara that doesn't make me look like a raccoon at the end of the day...love it and cheap too.
Nice mascara not really waterproof
Monkalt from Columbus, MS
I got this to wear for workouts but it gives me mild raccoon eyes.
Channell5 from Philadelphia
The best cheap mascara & it's not expensive! Don't waste your money on all those expensive mascaras. I've tried them all & they don't compare to this one.
Lisa Lane from Texarkara, AR
This is the best mascara and waterproof
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE
Savanna from Texas
I recently saw this on Tik-Tok, and had to try it. And I am SO glad I did! This mascara is so awesome, especially for the price. I usually spend at least $30 for good mascara, and this brand is just as good, if not better than the brand I usually buy. It's totally worth it, and I will be buying more once I run out!
Was better than expected!!
Rachie from Pennsylvania
I bought this on a whim because I usually use urban decay perversion mascara but didn't wanna depp the money for a product that won't get used as much due to quarantine/isolation. And I always heard good things about this mascara online. I started by brushing my lashes out with a regular spoolie brush to separate my lashes, then applied this mascara and WOW! My lashes looked so much longer from just one coat! I love this mascara and for the price, who can beat that? I still wanna grab my urban decay next time to have both but this is really nice! Gonna try it with the Lancôme lash primer next and see how nice it is!!
Nene from Jackson, Tn
First mascara I have ever found to stay on my eyelashes.... I usually look like a racoon before noon, so I just quit using mascara many years ago.
I love this brand!!!
I love it
Liz from OH - Ohio
Will buy again
JennyJ from Virginia
I love this mascara. It works as well as the $28 mascaras