Rated 4.12 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I got the wrong color but I love this
I heard it was very similar to the tarte shape-tape concealer but I like it better! I never set my eyes and I don't get that much creasing only the minimal because I live in a very hot city therefore creasing is inevitable. When I do set it it does not crease at all and it lasts throughout the day. I used to use the L'Oréal one with the sponge at the top (I don't recall the name) but after a few hours it would look like I didn't have makeup on. I would also use the Morphe concealer and it would last a little longer than the L'Oréal but the E.l.f one lasts waaay more! The formula is high coverage but it's very lightweight. I have really dry skin so concealer always hurts my eyes but this one doesn't because it doesn't dry my eyes out. My only complaint would be that at first when the product is brand new it can get a lot on the brush and sometimes this makes a very messy container but it's manageable, I'm a little bit of a clean freak and I could work with it so if you're not you're good.
Also, I didn't pick the right color and I got a very dark color so I had to change it. I do think the descriptions are very accurate online but I got a "light beige" when my foundation is a light beige so I chose the wrong color. I chose a lighter shade and this one worked really well.
Most Helpful Critical Review Cakey and drying on skin
I ordered directly from elf's website so the complaints about customer service have nothing to do with ulta itself. I received a much lighter color than what I ordered, and although I was disappointed, I thought that maybe I could mix it with something more my color to get the best fit. The concealer ended up looking dry and splotchy, and I had to redo my entire face so I wouldn't look as if my under eyes were cracking. The next time I used it, I applied a small amount as I usually would do concealer (without mixing), and I had the same result. Drying, cakey, cracked, splotchy, and all around just not a product I'd reach for again. Every once in a while I try again in hopes that I had done something wrong, but I get the same result every time and either have to re-do my entire base or cover it up with my foundation. I've wondered if it was maybe because the color is too light and just looks bad on my skin, but I'm not willing to buy another concealer from elf to find out. I'm considering using it as a base for eyeshadow, but I dont want to risk having the same cracking/drying effect on my eyes. I really wanted to love this product since I didn't have a concealer and don't want to be harsh, but bottom line is that you get what you pay for, and I won't be using this concealer ever again.
Reviewed by 398 customers Amazing product
Dazhanea from Saint Paul
I just bought some and loved it right away the coverage, the finish and the feeling are all amazing since I have dry skin I would definitely recommend this!
Cakey and drying..
Me from Here
Pretty drying and cakey. Not goo for one with any eye wrin.
Fantastic concealer for dry skin
Ally from Columbia, MD
This was suggested to me by my cousin since I have dry skin and concealers usually get cakey on me. Not only is this not cakey at all, it is the most full coverage drug store concealer I've found! It actually covers up my dark spots without looking cakey. 10/10 recommend if you have issues with cakey concealer!
Jessica from IN
I know this is a cult favorite... however I feel like it creases on me... maybe because I am 43?
Mashelle from GEORGIA
Love this product! Especially as someone who does a lot of people's makeup, this product holds well and isn't as expensive! I like being able to do numerous faces without trying to proportion what I have due to expenses.
Lady from NY
Very good product
Chris from Tarpon Springs, FL
Blends easily with brush.
Works surprisingly well!
J from Grand Blanc, MI
This stuff straight-up smells like nail polish when you open it up, but if you ignore the smell, this stuff works like a charm. I have pretty pigmented acne scars, and I only really need one layer of this stuff to cover them up. The formula doesn't feel too heavy and you can't smell the chemical-like smell once it's settled on your face. I really like this!
Best Concealer I've Ever Used
Alicia from WA
I've been looking for a good, cruelty-free concealer for a while. My undereyes are very dry and dark, and I've struggled to find something with good coverage that doesn't dry me out. This concealer does everything I need! I got a shade too dark which is unfortunate, but the formula is so perfect.
This blew me away.
Melinda from Issaquah, WA
I apply with a sponge and set with Laura Mercier powder
MY ALL TIME FAVORITE CONCEALER
Emma from Chicago, IL
My holy grail concealer used to be tarte shape tape and I loved the way it looked and had a great finish but it felt so dry on my skin. I tried the 16 hour camo concealer and it was ok. Had the same problem with it. but THIS was so mind blowingly amazing. It looks and feels so perfect my skin looks airbrushed and it doesnt dry out my face or cake up. It's similar to the nars radiant creamy concealer but it's so cheap and the doe foot is my favorite kind of applicator. 10/10 my new go to I cannot reccomend this enough
elf concealer from north carolina
it's not mind blowing. honestly it's not bad definitely not buy again. it's not hydrating at all and leaves dryness.
I LOVE IT !!
Moolee from Florida
I love this concealer, I'm the type of person who swears by the tarts shape tape, although that one give me beautiful coverage it does tend to crease on me A LOT! But this this one I love the converse it's very buildable and it does not crease. I'm in love 🥰
Covers red under eyes. No creasing or skin drying
Helen from Long Island,NY
Goes on smooth. Covers redness. Doesn't sit in wrinkles. I think I look younger. Wish i could spread it all over my face...maybe I'll try it!
Tips for eyebaking
Abg from Sac
If y'all experience dry under eyes and you bake. Girl quit bakinggggg. You're gonna look a mess. Take a sponge and tap the excess off and press on the powder like it's your second skinn.
That One Abg from Sac
Gorllll, lemme tell you, if you have dry to normal skin. This is a blessing!!!! The matte version didn't work well for me because it cracked and oxidized on me 🤨. Not a pretty look. But this hydrating one, CHEFS KISS. Effortlessly blends, like girl what more could you ask for
Cecelia from Santa Barbara, California
This is a fantastic concealer. It is definitely hydrating and has a satin finish. I love it. The only problem is that the chart and color online isn't true to color. I was looking for a color that matched medium peach in the original camo concealer, so I looked at the chart and they said it matched. So a week later, I got the package and compared the two, and it was a lot darker, especially for undereye. So don't believe the color chart. I still love the product though, even though it's also a different undertone than the 16hr camo as well.
Tehe totally not biased
Alan from Oklahoma City
This is literally the best affordable concealer!!
Good for the price
Ash_Bick from Texas
This product is good for the price, but it definitely could be better. I am on a quest to find an under eye concealer that does not crease. This concealer still creases and shows signs of wear by the end of the day (approximately after 5 hours). I will say, although this product did not wow me, it did better than the regular camo concealer.
Not the worst but not the best
Maybe I'm bad at makeup from Atlanta, ga
I was disappointed when I tried this after reading rave reviews everywhere. It was very heavy and cakey, and kind of drying. I haven't tried the original Camo concealer so I can't compare it to that, but maybe I'm just not moisturizing enough or I have really dry skin. I blended to the best of my ability but you could still see it in splotches. Maybe I'm just bad at makeup lol but if you're looking for heavy coverage, this is for you.
Lydia from Philly
I love this concealer. It is super hydrating and blends so nicely! I love the color ranges and how well they compliment my skin. I like mixing a few colors for the perfect brightness. Women of color friendly for sure. This is the best concealer I have used. Still needing to try the Huda Beauty one as well because I heard that was pretty good too.
I will keep buying !!!
Sel from Coachella,ca
This is the best drugstore concealer for $6. I tried out the camo matte version and loved it but it was too dry for my liking. Then this one came out and BEST THING EVER. Super creamy and hydrating and won't make your under eyes look old.
I love this
Mel from California
If you're gonna cry make sure you're wearing this concealer your makeup will not get messed up 😭😂
M from Alabaster Alabama
This was awful it's over hydrating and gets in the lines! Moved all over my face Even with setting powder
Kaira from Florida
I love that it doesn't dry down like the original Camo Concealer but it also doesn't have as much coverage and the shades compared to the originate a bit darker. Like I use the Fair Warm and it's noticeably darker than the Fair Warm in the original Camo Concealer. But overall, the application is nice, it lasts all day but it's just more of a Medium coverage concealer