Rated 3.55 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The only mascara that matters anymore
This is by far the best mascara on the market and I've tried them all. I honestly can understand how anyone has had a problem with this product because I've rn blown away. I have naturally long and full lashes so Iv been searching for a mascara that will be volumizing but not clumpy or too thick. This mascara was able to wrap every lash in a perfect coat of mascara giving me the full dark lashes i've been searching for. I had no issue with the wand wing too big, the wand never even hit my eyelid or anything. On top of that I went to the beach later on in the day it was 93 degrees out and it didn't budge from sweat even a little. When I went in the ocean I was knocked down and completely submerged by waves multiple times and somehow the mascara stayed 100% in place, no smudging or racoon eyes or anything, just perfect lashes. By the end of that day the mascara was still in place and my lashes looked exactly how they did when Iapplied this. I never write reviews but this product deserves recognition. If your looking for dramatic eyes and want a mascara that is SERIOUSLY water proof this one is easily the best choice. My new absolute favorite product!
Most Helpful Critical Review Was excited for this product but it's a complete fail
Super disappointed. I was really excited for the release of this but it let me down in so many ways.
First, as many have pointed out, the brush is HUGE. I have medium-sized eyes with hooded lids. I was able to apply it without getting it everywhere, but it was not easy.
Second, the packaging itself is larger than it needs to be, and as a result I was unable to fit it in my usual makeup bag (which has always been able to hold my mascara). It also wasn't particular comfortable in the hand.
Third, while the product itself performed decently (the first couple of uses), I saw no improvement over other, less-expensive mascaras. Honestly, there really doesn't seem to be a point to having such a huge brush... it didn't do anything.
But this is where it really started to go downhill.
After just a few uses, the "hourglass" design of the brush showed its poor engineering. The product began to collect in the middle of the brush (in the "skinny" part of the "hourglass") where the tube couldn't pull it off. The brush quickly began to degrade from there; the bristles are soft, so they began clumping together and being sort of flattened, until it got to the point where you pretty much just got a huge dollop of mascara when you pulled the brush out of the bottle.
So after about a week, it became all but useless. I gave it a few more tries before throwing it out. I'm very glad I used points to get this, and didn't pay actual money, or I would've been pretty upset because this is one of the more expensive mascaras out there.
Would not buy again, and would not recommend.
Reviewed by 747 customers Clumpy but good
ELL Dee from Milwaukee WI
I liked the recipe but the applicator is way too thick and doesn't separate your lashes well-clumpy.
But! If you use Benefits "They're Real" applicator with it, it's pretty good.
I won't buy it again, though.
Holly from CT
I pair this on top of the Revlon So Fierce mascara and this just fluffs/feathers out my lashes so beautifully. It curls and gives volume without looking clumpy. I have never loved how my lashes look as much as I do when I'm wearing this combo!
Best mascara ever
lisamp87 from Palm Springs, CA
I have naturally long eye lashes and hate using an eyelash curler and these take care of that and make them look fuller as if they're falsies, just a few layers is all you need and no need to worry about running throughout the day
Full Lash- Love
mleedream from Idaho
I got a travel size of this mascara in a gift set with their other mascara: Better Than Sex.
I brushed over my lashes once and they looked very full. I added a few layers to get a fuller look. My lashes don't feel thick and stiff.
I have oily eyes and a lot of mascara tends to run. Currently, I've been wearing the mascara for 5+ hours and don't have any run.
I have to scrape off the tip of the brush to prevent eyelash clumping,, but other than that, I definitely recommend.
fancy from Illinois
I love this mascara. It makes my lashes thick and curls them. I don't have any problems with it clumping. I use the corner of the brush to get the inside lashes. I will purchase again.
Rita from IL
i get.lots of compliments on my lashes. Everyone wants to know what mascara I use!
Gwen from N.C.
I love this
Gwen from N.C.
Despite the low rating this is my favorite mascara ever and I swear I have tried them ALL high to low I'm so picky and this one omg
LOVE THIS NEW PRODUCT
Abby from Duluth MN
I normally buy the too faced better than sex mascara, but this new one caught my eye so I thought I'd try it. I ended up loving how it not only lengthened my lashes (what I liked best about the better than sex mascara) and also volumizing them. My lashes have never looked better! It wears for at least 16 hours, no fallout no smearing. The only thing I didn't like is when I use two coats or more it tends to clump on my lashes.
Honestly so good
Gg from N.C.
Natural but glam looking lashes I'm in love
Raerae from Alaska
This is the most lightweight mascara I've ever used! Didn't feel like it weighed my lashes down, and looked great without being clumpy. My new favorite mascara!
Nurse Annie from Elizabethton TN
I love big long lashes. This mascara was amazing. It gave me the Muppet eyelashes as my kids call it. Fantastic product. Will buy again
Jasmine V from Georgia
Prefer the original to this one. The brush always makes a mess on my eyeshadow. It does make your eyelashes big, but you could get the safe volume. With a different mascara without the mess. I've also just started using this and already the brush is starting to get dry. Not enough mascara in the tube.
Not for me
Robyn from 29464
I have used Better than Sex mascara for years and s sales person persuaded me to try this one. She said it didn't seem to dry out the lashes and flake. I had noticed some flaking lately(but now I think that was because my other mascara was getting old) so I thought I'd try it. But it is just too messy and too much mascara comes out on the giant brush. Too difficult to put on without messing up my other eye makeup.
Jules from Mesa, AZ
the only brand of mascara I will use!!
Love the mascara---love the brush!!
Emma from Los Angeles
I love love love this mascara! Worth the money for me. Gives me those big, fluttery bad girl lashes. People think they are fake!
DarthXana from North Carolina
Adds lots of volume to my lashes. Sometimes I use it with the Better Than Sex mascara to add a boost of volume. It isn't clumpy. It applies evenly and I love it.
Sky from Everywhere
Very clumpy right from the start. I mean maybe if you like that "street girl look" lol I'm gonna stick with
"IT lash blow out" it was a fun try but not for me.
Pros and Cons
Brooke from Idaho
If used right this can be a great mascara. Pros: adds a ton of volume and length. Cons: clumps easily and can make lashes look spidery if you're not careful. This product does stay on very well and doesn't flake which I love.
I keep buying it!!
Jane from Wyoming
I love this mascara! My only complaint is that after only like 2 weeks the brush starts to clump all together and the bristles get all stuck together. But I love it so much I buy it anyways!! Gives nice full lashes without clumping or wearing off into skin. Better than Better than Sex mascara and Big Ego, simply because Better than Sex is clumpy, and Big Ego wears into skin under my eyes.
I mean I like better than sex better but it's not BAD
Tay from Spfld mo
Nothing really stands out about this product to me
Definitely putting this on my rotation
Beth from Oxford, AL
I bought this product because my lashes cannot hold a curl and this was advertised to help with curl. While the curl in my lashes still falls with this product, it is still a good mascara for volume. With one coat, my lashes were super thick. I always love the fluffy brushes better. The one con would be that the brush picks up so much product that my lashes would get clumpy if I used too much.
Echo from Springfield, OR
This mascara definitely gives a dramatic look through length and darkness but the wand is too unpredictable. One one eye, it caused my lashes to clump together with each other and the other eye had separated lashes. I had to comb out my lashes and mess with them longer than normal to get a decent look but I'm still lacking that satisfaction of a good mascara
Fake Lash Look
Amira from Cali
When I think fat, voluminous, bold lashes, I go to this mascara. It does have a flaking issue, as this is a dryer formula. I find that most volumizing mascaras hace this weird quality. I wouldn't recommend it if you live somewhere hot or if you're wanting it to last the entire day.
my go to
bloo from us
i have tried every mascara ive ever passed, this one is my favorite. theres a noticeable difference in my lashes without being clumpy. i love it.