Rated 3.53 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The only mascara that matters anymore
This is by far the best mascara on the market and I've tried them all. I honestly can understand how anyone has had a problem with this product because I've rn blown away. I have naturally long and full lashes so Iv been searching for a mascara that will be volumizing but not clumpy or too thick. This mascara was able to wrap every lash in a perfect coat of mascara giving me the full dark lashes i've been searching for. I had no issue with the wand wing too big, the wand never even hit my eyelid or anything. On top of that I went to the beach later on in the day it was 93 degrees out and it didn't budge from sweat even a little. When I went in the ocean I was knocked down and completely submerged by waves multiple times and somehow the mascara stayed 100% in place, no smudging or racoon eyes or anything, just perfect lashes. By the end of that day the mascara was still in place and my lashes looked exactly how they did when Iapplied this. I never write reviews but this product deserves recognition. If your looking for dramatic eyes and want a mascara that is SERIOUSLY water proof this one is easily the best choice. My new absolute favorite product!
Most Helpful Critical Review Was excited for this product but it's a complete fail
Super disappointed. I was really excited for the release of this but it let me down in so many ways.
First, as many have pointed out, the brush is HUGE. I have medium-sized eyes with hooded lids. I was able to apply it without getting it everywhere, but it was not easy.
Second, the packaging itself is larger than it needs to be, and as a result I was unable to fit it in my usual makeup bag (which has always been able to hold my mascara). It also wasn't particular comfortable in the hand.
Third, while the product itself performed decently (the first couple of uses), I saw no improvement over other, less-expensive mascaras. Honestly, there really doesn't seem to be a point to having such a huge brush... it didn't do anything.
But this is where it really started to go downhill.
After just a few uses, the "hourglass" design of the brush showed its poor engineering. The product began to collect in the middle of the brush (in the "skinny" part of the "hourglass") where the tube couldn't pull it off. The brush quickly began to degrade from there; the bristles are soft, so they began clumping together and being sort of flattened, until it got to the point where you pretty much just got a huge dollop of mascara when you pulled the brush out of the bottle.
So after about a week, it became all but useless. I gave it a few more tries before throwing it out. I'm very glad I used points to get this, and didn't pay actual money, or I would've been pretty upset because this is one of the more expensive mascaras out there.
Would not buy again, and would not recommend.
Reviewed by 842 customers Just .. No
Lyss from SD
I got this for free and I was excited to try it ... The wand is just oddly shaped where it doesn't coat the lashes properly thus making them super clumpy. Also doesnt really do much for them, no volume or length. Pretty bad.
Not what I expected
Kari from Lv nv
Brush is dried out can not use, I will be returning, may just be old...
Very good but very thick
sbdnj from wisconsin
this mascara is amazing and makes me lashes look very long but it's just so thick that the brush on it gets stuck to the sides
Very clumpy - waste of money!
Steponeme from West Virginia
It is very clumpy and messy. The brush didn't have the hourglass shape the second I opened it. All the brushes are matted down with how thick this mascara is. It gets all over the tube when you close it. Lashes look like I am using old mascara when it is brand new. I LOVE Too Faced Better Than Sex and decided to try this and am disappointed that I wasted my money and didn't stick with the original.
I'm in love!!
Hangar18 from Warwick RI
I am a mascara addict and this has secured a spot in my top 5-my lashes are so full and long when I wear this mascara. Dries fast and isn't heavy-this is my second purchase.
Not what I expected
Mikka from Dearborn Hts., MI
I may have received a bad product, so I will probably purchase again, but this one came out clumpy and nasty.
It is definitely a good mascara but, not the BEST.
Mindy from Jonesboro
I really like the end result with this mascara but dislike the fact that it is difficult to get coverage on the top of your lashes with the wand that comes with it.
QueenB from TX
I am rating 1* because this mascara is horrible! Very clumpy when applied and gives racoon eyes. Definitely the worst mascara that I have ever used.
Vikki from New Orleans
It's hard to see what it does considering it's a super wet formula. I'll probably be using my better than sex brush while using this mascara and seeing how that goes. Kinda really upset I spent money on this, but that's what I get for trying something new 😩
It's a no for me
🌚 from America
I could not get the product off the wand onto my lashes!! It's a no for me
Not good for thin lashes
Julie from Minnesota
Was told this would increase lashes. Very disappointed. It was clumpy and stayed on brush. Really not worth the money
Makes my lashes so thick!!!
Missy from Moyock,NC
Love that it makes my lashes thick and the packaging is pretty to
i would be buying every time i run out
vicky from springfield massachusetts
I would never buy this product again!
MaryAnn from Hazlet, New Jersey
I couldn't wait to use this mascara. To my dismay I found it to thick and never will purchase it again. It also seemed that it was old not new.
Jackie from Georgia
This is a big negative for me. The wand had so much product on it, I was trying to get most of it off. My lashes was clumped together and it dried even worst. I've had better mascaras from off brands.
Stinks like chew!
LP from Florida
Formula felt nice and went on smooth, but the smell was absolutely unbearable. It smells horrid in the container and even hours after applying I was still catching whiffs. I asked my husband to smell it and he almost puked.
Cindy from Woodside
I've struggled to find a good mascara that actually kept my eyelashes up and this one was it .
I love it, buying this again for sure
7xama from Las Vegas
I was not sure how this was going to work for me but OMG I loved it the first time and then the second time . My lashes look long and lushes
Would not buy this mascara again.
liv from Long Beach, NY
Probably one of the worst mascaras I've purchased. The brush is big and clunky. The mascara itself is on the dry side. Doesn't lengthen lashes. Lashes look clunky even with primer. I never write reviews but this product was so bad that I had to.
The Best I've Found!
Pam from Indy from Indianapolis
I tried this just for something different! What a pleasant surprise!! The first time I used it I could see such a difference in how thick my lashes looked. I use a microfiber cloth and water to remove my mascara at night. Removing some mascaras this way pulls lashes out. With this mascara that doesn't happen. I just ordered 4 more tubes today!
If you like a thicker lash line this is for you
AnG from MO
It's certainly waterproof, you can cry your eyes out and this stuff ain't going nowhere, lol. But while I have a lot of lashes, my lashes are fine & this feels a little too heavy for my lash. If this is you, you might wanna use this sparingly
Deemac from Staten Island, NY
Leaves a lot of mascara on the wand and so you get a lot of clumped lashes that you need to keep spreading. Not the best, probably won't buy again
Wand is too big
A from Michigan
This mascara would be perfect if the wand was a bit smaller. Gets every lash and adds volume but the wand is just too big.
Very sticky and wouldn't dry, horrible product
What a mess from Brandon, MS
This was one of those sticky mascaras that when you blink gets mascara on your eyelids and basically down to my cheeks! Of course after sticking to my skin it dries and you can't chisel it off! Horrible product in my opinion!
Eyelashes looking great
Bonnie from Orlando, FL
I've been using the Better Than Sex mascara which I still love. My niece suggested I add this mascara as a finishing touch and I love it even more now.