Rated 4.19 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Five Stars
I tried this mascara after my usual was discontinued. It was the second I tried following the discontinuation. Normally, I have an AWFUL time finding replacement products--especially mascara and foundation. So many mascaras have flaked into my eyes, worn off after a very short time, etc. Not Buxom Lash Mascara, though. It is the perfect combination of volume and length, withstands the nine hours per day I generally wear it, withstood a nap, and is all around awesome. I did touch it up after taking a nap even though it didn't really need to be, and it didn't turn into a flaky, dry mess even the way my discontinued one that I loved did with touch ups (its only flaw). My lashes look naturally long and voluminous with this mascara. Buxom, PLEASE don't discontinue or change this mascara at all! I will stop my search with this one and use it as long as it's on the market.
Most Helpful Critical Review Good for separating, but not much else
I am always on the hunt for the next mascara. I am an Urban Decay Perversion user but am always willing to try new brands and types. This was recommended by an Ulta consultant so I picked it up. The brush is nice. I don't typically go for plastic bristle brushes but the bristles are super soft. This mascara does separate your lashes really well. Unfortunately there's not enough product on the brush and the formula is somewhat dry and thin. The coverage is just not there for volume or length. Ultimately I use it to separate my lashes for the next application of a better mascara. I will keep the brush, other than that it's not really worth the money.
Reviewed by 607 customers Trash.
Kargon from Indiana
I purchased this mascara due to positive reviews from beauty influencers such as Lara Lee, Nicole Concilio and Babsbeauty. This is the worst mascara I have ever used. Does absolutely nothing for my lashes. Very disappointed and will think twice before trusting these beauty influencers.
Not Worth It
Jade from San Jose, CA
I was very disappointed I spent the money on this product. My drugstore mascara does more than this one. This did absolutely nothing for my lashes. Did not lengthen and did not increase volume. I tried to layer and it did nothing but clump.
Sarah from U.S.
One of the best Mascaras you could buy. If you are going to buy any mascara buy this one.
I'm super picky & this is the only mascara i'll buy
Hannah from Indiana
I have tried A LOT of mascara both brand name and drugstore, and this particular mascara wins every time. -I wear contacts everyday until late at night, and i can wear this mascara for 9+ hours without it causing any extra dryness or irritation!
- I also have very oily skin and always had an issue with other mascaras smudging, and just overall looking a mess but this mascara actually stays put!
- I don't have super short lashes but they're semi-straight and definitely not long but this mascara surprisingly lengthens/ curls them a VERY good amount along with adding volume!
- doesn't get clumpy/ does a good job at defining the lashes, the only thing is that near the end of the tube i have to start inspecting the wand to make sure there's not clumps on it before i apply but that's expected when it's almost empty. overall a great mascara!
Emma H from Westminster, Maryland
Seriously love this mascara. Definitely one of my favorites and so worth the money. The wand helps to separate your lashes perfectly and lift them up. Love love love !!!
Best Mascara hands down
Brookie from Maine
I have been using this mascara for years and its by far my favorite. I love the brush and it separates and coats nicely. Not clumpy at all. I try new brands here and there but I ALWAYS come back to old faithful BUXOM.
Holy Grail mascara
95azbb from Arizona
I always gotta have it on deck, it's been my go to for 2 years now.
Rachel from Soldotna, Alaska
Really thickens lashes
Love Love Love
Dee from Port Sulphur, LA
This it my all time favorite mascara!! When it goes on sale I buy 4 to last me for the year 😍 I wear contacts and it doesn't bother my eyes
Best Mascara Ever
Aim from OH
The brush and formula are amazing. Doesn't bother my eyes
Best mascara out there!
Makeup lover from Asheville NC
I have been looking for a mascara that doesn't smudge for years. This is THE ONLY one. I love this product! Lengthens lashes, thickens lashes, goes on sleek. Wear all day and does not smudge!
Love this mascara!!
Bailey from St Paul, MN
I've tried tons of different mascara's... high end and drug store. This is my favorite of all of them! I always branch out and try different kinds but I always find my way back to this!! I love how it separates my lashes and it gives a good boost of volume! Perfect for everyday use, and works well with falsies! 11/10!! Highly recommend!! It lasts me a couple months, I know you're supposed to switch out every month but I can get a good 2 months out of this!
T from MA
very sleek, polished finish
LOVE LOVE LOVE
BW from Columbus, Ohio
Probably one of my favorite mascaras ever, it lasts for a Long time, isn't clumpy, separates and accentuates my lashes really well.
E from New York
This mascara did nothing for my lashes. Only good when your wearing lashes.
I love this mascara
Marr from Detroit Michigan
It brings length and volume!
have to return
troosmimi from Alabama
I have used this mascara many times over the years but this tube - either the hot display lights ruined it or its just defective. Giant thick glops on the wand and the on the brush at tip and where the brush meets the wand. Obviously the mechanism that is supposed to remove the excess is malfunctioning but the mascara itself is way thicker than usual.
This is my go to mascara!
Alwx from Greensboro NC
I have naturally long/thick lashes, but mascara for me can be clumpy. I found this mascara a few years ago and I haven't bought anything else since! The wand itself helps separate and define each individual lash and it feels so light on the lashes. I hate a heavy feeling on the eyes and THIS works well and makes my lashes look FULL AND LONG. It's definitely buildable too, again, without getting clumpy. It's such a great product, I recommend it to anyone who compliments me on my lashes. I can't rave about it enough. Give it a try!!!!
Skincarelover from Anchorage
I love this so much it's my favorite!!!!
i LOVE this mascara
alivia from ga
i usually put it over the too faced better than mascara
Amy from Ohio, USA
I love how volumizing this mascara is. It goes on very nicely and looks great. However, I always seem to have an issue with mascara under my eyes by the end of the day. It's hard to know if it's from the mascara itself or due to other causes.
Best mascara ever
Mandy from Nashville TN
Does not bleed under eyes.
Ronna from Pendleton
Love the wand and brush and the mascara has wonderful, no clump, lots of length coverage. Also, no flaking during the day.
reviewer from New York, NY
Very disappointed with this mascara. Their previous version was so good! My lashes aren't the best, but this mascara makes my lashes look worse. Gives no volume. I get long and stubby lashes to the point where I wonder if it's making my lashes fall out. I may be allergic to an ingredient in this formulation. I gave it a solid week and now it goes in the trash.
I would not buy this again
Linnie from Langhorne, pa. 19053