Product Reviews Rated 3.26 out of 5 stars
673 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Midnight brown What the heck r you people doing to me ive been using midnight brown for the past 20 years , it make my brows perfect .... I need this color back , i have my husband looking at every pharamacy to buy up all the stock in montreal
Most Helpful Critical Review Please bring back old formula in midnight brown!!! I have been using this brow pencil in the color midnight brown for years. Now that the formula has changed it doesn't go on as well and the closest color to midnight brown is rich brown which I'm so unhappy with. I sadly will not be purchasing this item anymore. Please, please, please bring back the old formula in the
midnight brown color so I can come back to being a loyal customer of this product!
Reviewed by 673 customers price went up,pencil got smaller,horrible quality 1
Ang781 from Boston
I'm a makeup artist and was using this pencil for 15+ yrs, everything about this pencil is horrible now! Price went up 50% pencil has got soooo much smaller, and just doesn't work the same anymore, breaks every time I go to sharpen it! What happened Cover Girl?!?!?!
terrible eyebrow pencils 1
sadeyes from michigan
i bought these and thought they would be great However they do not even work! you need to change quality control and product ingredients.
Not very satisfying 1
Sandra20 from Brownsville,Tx
I've bought it for awhile but it just not the same
Midnight brown 1
Midnight Brown from New York City
Why did Cover Girl discontinue this color. It's the most popular one. I've used this for the last 10 years. I'm devastated. Please bring it back.
Change for the worse 1
Kittysue6 from NC
I have been using midnight brown for nearly two decades. This new formal and color (rich brown) are horrible. It barley shows up. It is nowhere near as dark. The amount of pressure and force needed to leave color is ridiculous. This loyal Covergirl will be looking elsewhere for her eyebrow needs.
Broken Pencils 2
Moni20 from Richmond VA
This has been happening to me for a few years- at least one is the two in the package breaks off as I sharpen. I'm using the sharpener so my only guess is the ingredients aren't holding up or they're sitting in a hot truck or warehouse. Please note the pictures- the second one shows how large the piece is when it falls out.
This has been happening for several years. The color is perfect for me otherwise I'd be gone already.
Broken pencils 2
Postina93 from San Antonio, TX
Why do the pencils constantly crumble? When I sharpen a pencil the tip falls off 3 or 4 times until I barely have an inch of pencil left. I'm gonna have to give up on them. I really like the color so I keep buying them but this happens so often. I'm done now.
I have been using this... 3
majorn from undisclosed
I have been using this for years and it has been my go to but is does pull out the brow hairs. I can find the perfect colour for me. Soft brown in this brand is not the same in others and this is why I have stuck it out. I do want to try other options. Let me know what works for you in the comments. For the record I have fair skin and brown hair and do not want super dramatic eyebrows.
Im a simple person who... 5
biswas16 from undisclosed
Im a simple person who cannot live without doing her eyebrow! So this is perfect for me to wear everyday. Its very easy to put on and its cheap as well. Its a great value! Ive been using this product for more than 3 years now! Really changed the way I look. COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Fill + Define Brow Pencil
Most definitely love... 5
denisef10 from undisclosed
Most definitely love this. It fills in the portions of gaps in the brows. Very easy to use product
Instead of using the... 5
monica_1 from undisclosed
Instead of using the Tame N Frame from NYX I love using this. Mostly for school because its natural but also your eyebrows are given shape and look darker.
I would recommend for... 5
leslie55 from undisclosed
I would recommend for people to try this eye brow pencil it outline ur brows its really good I would definitely buy this product again
The actual worst brow... 1
throbyn_graves from undisclosed
The actual worst brow pencil I have ever used. It clumps. It does not go on even. To get any shade transfer on your face, be prepared to have a backwoods bumpy road look from all the chunks of the pencils that come off and attach to your brow hairs. Actually terrible. To the point I'm not even sure I want to buy Covergirl anything again.
Its Amazing, it keeps... 5
member10ea2 from undisclosed
Its Amazing, it keeps your eyebrows on place for really good and long time. Its easy to use. And easy to put on as well. I would recommend it for girls who have that eyebrows that are just flying on the air the whole time.
These are great... 5
ambermb from undisclosed
These are great quality pencils that create good bold brows. I like that it comes with a sharpener because its nice to have a new sharp one every once in while because it keeps the pencils sharpened more nicely.
This product is really... 5
keziad1 from undisclosed
This product is really pigmented depending on the product color you choose. What I like about it even though it is pigmented you can still build upon it when your creating your brows.
Nice affordable... 5
antonellat4 from undisclosed
Nice affordable eyebrow pencil, isnt amazing but gets the job done for a beginner, would recommend
Its easy to work with.... 5
emilyr239 from undisclosed
Its easy to work with. Makes you look fabulous. It doesn't smear. Its not messy, it stays on, looks natural
This product is great.... 5
alanaa29 from undisclosed
This product is great. I like a product that is user friendly and easy to use and this is it. I don't like to spend much time on my eyebrows and this pencil makes the process faster and easier. I like a natural look with my eyebrows and this achieves it nicely. The best part is Covergirl is cruelty free now!
Great basic pencil to... 5
sarab172 from undisclosed
Great basic pencil to keep in the makeup bag, Im very fair skinned and the color matched well. Great price for drugstore and I like the spiral wand on the other end for blending and shaping eyebrows
Overall this was a... 3
jennah60 from undisclosed
Overall this was a really good product, except I got the wrong color so it was darker then what I usually use but if I would have gotten the right color this product would be amazing!!
Is really nice when... 5
lesleya7 from undisclosed
Is really nice when you use it your eyebrows are on fleek also its very good quality
They work to fill in... 3
bethanylee215 from undisclosed
They work to fill in my eyebrows lol I think I have used this since I was bout 8 and love it still
I thought it was ok... 1
is21 from undisclosed
I thought it was ok not my favorite product but the color matched my eyebrows perfectly. I need something with a pointed tip.
the pigment is very... 2
eleanory3 from undisclosed
the pigment is very weak. barely shows up, and rubs off your eyebrows even with touching it only a little. i didnt like it , and i probably would not repurchase
