Rated 2.29 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Most Helpful Critical Review Reviewed by 7 customers So disappointed
Meg from MO
I was so excited to try these - I saw them on Stila's website and couldn't wait to swatch them and wear them. I got the color Rose Gold because I fell instantly in love with it in the pictures. As a lip product it's ok I guess, but I was more excited to wear on my eyes and that's exactly where it fell short. It didn't really give me any color payoff at all and it just absolutely creased like crazy about halfway through the workday - I couldn't wait to wash it off it looked so bad. I wish I could return it.
Kitten is Marvelous
Kimberly from San Antonio, TX
I got the shade Kitten and use it to brighten my inner corner, highlight my top lip, center of the eyelid, ect. It works well as a precise cream highlight, and gasnlasting power. Very brightening and opaque, sheers easy if you choose.
Allie from Atlanta, Georgia
Stila needs to go back to the lab with this one. Kitten looks gorgeous when applied on the eyes as a cream shadow but creased terribly within an hour. If it was formulated to last on the eyes it would be a beautiful product!
I love glitter but do NOT like this
Gracie from Washington DC
Wow. I don't write reviews hardly ever, so to be writing this should give you an indication in and of itself of how this product performs. This was a product my mom bought without really reading the package or marketing around, so when I swatched it, we were surprised to find glitter. We gave it a good shot though, because you never know. She tried it on the lips, and it was not a good look. She gave it to me, knowing that I love glitter, and I tried it on the lips, eyes, and face, and it was awful there as well.
There was not a lot of pigment behind the chunks of glitter, the glitter was chunky and not evenly distributed, it felt gritty on the lips, etc. we got the rose gold shade, which on my porcelain skin is a strange shade on the lips, eyes, and face, which is what this product is marketed for. It's too bronze on the lips for my taste, yet the pink and bronze combo is weird on the eyes, and it's just too dark and glittery for me as a face product.
Bottom line, we'll be returning this. It was a roller coaster from beginning to end, and not the good kind.
Creases like crazy
Astorian from Queens
I unfortunately bought 3 colors; Kitten, Rose Gold and Topaz. The kitten is sheet sparkles, isn't as perfect as other Kitten products.
Creased like crazy super fast. Never set and smeared all over my eyes. Primer did not help.
Stila usually knocks it out of the park, but not with this product.
Beautiful color but not for hooded eyes
Phyrra from Tampa, FL
I wanted to love this product. I bought 2 shades, Kitten and Pink Sapphire. They're gorgeous when swatched on my hands. However, they're a disaster when I try to wear them. I've tried with eyeshadow primer (Urban Decay Sin, Urban Decay Eden, Too Faced Shadow Insurance), without eyeshadow primer, with a setting powder, without a setting powder. This formula is horrible for hooded eyes like mine. It does not set, it immediately starts to gather in the crease of my eyes, pulling it off the lid. So disappointed I wasted my money on these. I would only recommend these to people who do not have hooded eyes.
Jay from Rochester, NY
I just got this today and couldn't wait to try it. I got the shade Kitten because it was pretty universal and looked like it would go with any color story. It's stunning! I used it to cut a crease and fill in the inner corner of my eye. The formula glides on so smooth, and blended out so well. This looks so amazing I hope they come out with more colors!!!