Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I'm in Love !!
This product GREAT!!
I'm terrible with eye makeup and with EVERY other eye pencil I've never been able to get a perfect application on my waterline and I was almost in tears when I got it finally with this pencil
I think this pencil is great for beginners and others like me who struggle with waterline application
It's not getting a 5 star from me because with my 2nd pencil my tip broke on the first try..ugh
But that being said I'm returning a pencil I bought before to exchange it for another one of these
Formula is amazing and I love it!!
I always fall in love with super dark eye pencil and this pencil in black onyx is one of the darkest I've found
Most Helpful Critical Review Absolutely not worth it.
This eyeliner pencil was okay in my opinion. The texture is pretty soft and creamy. I personally don't think eyeliners like this are easy to apply, but when I did apply it, it looked pretty good. It worked really well when I applied it onto my waterline. However, it but was hard to apply to the top of my eyelids and make a wing. I also found it smudged easily and expected that it won't because the description said it supposed to be "long wearing and 36-hour coverage" I probably wouldn't repurchase it. I received this product free for testing. I received this product complimentary for review purposes. Do not waste your money.
Reviewed by 195 customers Yes, I would purchase again
Betty Bbop from Clovis CA
Really like how it slides on smooth but not too dramatic
I'd prefer a liquid eyeliner
Lisa from New Jersey
The product glided On very nicely although the pencil picked up some of my makeup that it went over. It's a nice pencil but it breaks fairly easily
This product irritates my eyes and makes them red
Tare from Ceader Hill Texaa
I would not use this product again
What you see is all there is!!
Andrea from Pittsburgh
The small tip of product that you see upon purchase is all there is! There is no way to advance more eyeliner. Disposable eyeliner at non-disposal price. Don't waste your money.
Deep rich color
Prissy from San Antonio tx
Very pretty color
Allyh214 from Austin, Tx
It's not waterproof or long wearing.
Cfletcher from Houston
this stays on ALL day without smudging or smears! Absolutely love it!!!
I was surprised at how much I liked this eyeliner
PAULA from TN
I needed a new eyeliner and bought this in two colors because it was on sale and had good reviews. I was surprised at how much I like it. It goes on smoothly, looks pretty, and lasts all day.
Stays in place
Linz from Fl
The dark brown is my favorit and it is a must with any eye look.
Ash from Dallas
This is a repurchase for me. I love this eye liner it never fail!
no don't like to have to sharpen it
denise from charlotte hall, md
it goes on good and last all day but way to messy when sharpening it
Stuck home from Illinois
The grey is a really pretty color and the pencil is easy to use to tightline. I was apprehensive to sharpen because of all the negative reviews but it was not that hard. You just have to be very careful. The price is great!
I would buy this product again
Jamie from Pingree grove il
I recommend this product to everyone I know. I love all the Maybelline tattoo make up. Ever since they come out with this product. I will be a returning customer.
I will repurchase
momofthree from Chicago,IL
Great for tightlining
kbluvs2sew from Michigan
first time buying/using this product. love it. great price.
I wont ever buy it again!
Dee from Cle elum
I opened it and didnt even get it to my eye and the tip breaks off, I can't twist it up to even use it. I'm taking it back.
Stays out all day.
Kat from Georgia
This may be my new favorite eyeliner! Glides on easy, no smudging, or smearing. Stays on until I take it off.
Kat from Jesup, Ga
I used this above black eyeliner. It stays all day and makes your eyes pop! So pretty!!
I wouldn't purchase this product again.
Thanks but no thanks from Somewhere, NC
Love the boldness. I hate that it still smudges. Even though it states that it's smudge proof.
DebbieH from Pa
Use to accentuate my eyes. Prefer this to liquid eyeliners. Doesn't smear.
Will buy again!
Bookkeeper from Kentucky
This eyeliner is great! It is as good if not better than IT Cosmetics Eyeliner. Price is much more affordable than IT and the eyeliner last longer too.
Misya from California
I bought this because it said smudge/waterproof and it seemed like a good purchase, but alas... I was deceived~ Perhaps I have oily eyelids and maybe it's also because I have monolids, but this eyeliner pencil smudged and was completely gone when I came home from work. Nope, I don't have a strenuous job that makes me sweat or anything so, I have no idea what happened. However, I must say that the formula of the pencil glides on super smoothly.
I will buy this product again.
Jillifred from Tn
This is the only eyeliner I will use now. Stays on all day no smudging. Glides on smooth and has bold color. Love love love it.
I will never pick this out again!
Andie from Fort Walton Beach Florida
This was my first time trying this brand and I am not thrilled about it.
Works great, no tugging
Stephanie from Michigan
Smooth application, sharpens well