Rated 4.45 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The Ultimate eyeliner combo
I'd been eyeing this a while, but was hesitant to spring for a $25 eyeliner. You guys, I am seriously so stoked on this product. I love the liquid felt tip side for quick, thin cat eyes and also for bolder, Amy-esque looks. It is so easy to apply, it's basically fool proof. The crayon side is perfect for painlessly lining lower lids and filling in your upper lid at the water line. I applied this yesterday morning at 6AM before work and it lasted (I'm not exaggerating) my 10 hour work day AND a seven mile walk/jog AT THE BEACH, YA'LL. I sinned and didn't wash my face last night and had a sleepover with the man friend and this morning it honestly looked so pretty, I had to review. I did spritz Urban Decay's All Nighter before work, but still. Amazing. This is a great investment/staple for your bag. I love you, Tarte.
Most Helpful Critical Review Ridiculously bad.
Congratulations to those who have gotten positive results from this product, I envy you. This eyeliner is ridiculous. The liquid end bleeds everywhere, it's impossible to get a clean line. The pencil end is waxy & cheap, plus smudges everywhere. The only thing this product has going for it is that it's double ended. Too bad both ends are bad quality. I have been eyeing this pen for a long time & have had it for months, trying to make it work. I wanted to love this product but it is so bad it's hilarious. I can understand the pencil end, a lot of companies like to sell smudgey, waxy liners, but the liquid was such a disappointment. Even with the lightest hand it bled like it was watercolour. I would avoid buying this liner. I thought it would work with the thousands of such amazing reviews but man was I wrong.!
Reviewed by 723 customers It does sharpen!
Debbie from NJ
Bought this product in brown and really like it. Until I read some of the reviews, I had no idea that you could sharpen the other end by turning the cap. Nice feature.
This is the worst on both ends!!!
Make Up Lover from Salem Oregon
This eyeliner is so bad! The pen side leaked out all over the place in my makeup bag. The pencil side breaks off in little chunks every time I use it. Also the product from either end does not stay on throughout the day. Don't waste your money on this!
I can't get over this liner!!!
faithcat from New Hampshire
I'm absolutely IN LOVE with this double sided liner!! It is perfect and I love how it has different options in one.
Double ended bliss
Perfectlypepperdee from Los Angeles
Whoever the genius is that designed this deserves an award. Not only does the product apply and wear well, it's thoughtfully designed and easy to use. A space saver when it comes to travel or just your makeup bag in general. I love it.
Ashley from Monterey Park, CA
Very dark and easy to put on but had a glossy finish. I returned it, more of a matte finish girl.
Best Liquid Eyeliner Out There!!!
Stephi Why from San Diego, CA
This has been my go-to eyeliner for years and I only wish it came in a deep navy or sapphire color so I could alternate between the black (I have hazel eyes)! I have combination-oily skin and LOVE how this stays matte all day (even through the heat) and how it offers the best of both worlds between a liquid and rich pencil liner! I have tried several other liners and this one by far offers the best wear and shape! So easy to creat a day-to-night cat eye look! Will continue to buy over and over again!
Its nice but not enough product
Shaunty from CA
Its convenient because its double sided. The liquid side gives you a lot of control. I like the pencil of the black one, but the brown one isn't as dark as I thought it would be. It comes off but not too much, so I would have to reapply a few times on my waterline (maybe that's a given for all bc the waterline is wet..) However the quantity of the pencil bothers me, I used to maybe like 7-10 times and it was already gone.
Could be better
cricket007 from New Orleans
Nice but needs a thicker brush
Absolutely will buy this eyeliner again.
Pattig from Howell, NJ
I usually use liquid eyeliner. I saw this Tarteist eyeliner with felt tip .
Love it , easy to apply
Aly from North Carolina
It's the second time I bought this product, but the second time is not good as the first one.
Liquid side is great but...
SHS09 from Wisconsin
Pencil side is not! It does not glide and seems too dry. I don't use pencil liner much except to tight line once in a while. It does not work for tight lining at all.
I would not recommend
V. J. from oak park, IL
The coal side the pen does not glide and tugs on the eye. It seems like the formula is too dry. The liquid side is ok, but not a huge fan.
ELopez from Fort Worth,Tx
Super happy with this eyeliner. Gliders perfectly and doesn't run. Literally he best eyeliner I've ever tried.
I do not recommend.
xlittlgirlbluex from Los Angeles, CA
I have been wearing eyeliner for as long as I could remember. I've tried countless liquid eyeliners and honey, this ain't it. I actually am a fan of their clay gel eyeliner. That's works amazing but this pen? No. The liquid side is ok but the other side doesn't contain slide on well.
One of the best on the market
sweetcdt from TX
This goes on smoothly. Lasts long. Great quality. Love that it is two products in one.
definitely a must have
Yupyupyup from Stone Mountain GA
I swear by this eyeliner
Not enough product
Sali from Virginia beach
Love that this was double ended but there wasn't enough product in the crayón part. Sadly, I ran out after daily use over a weeks time. The product is easy to apply with staying power. Still good but not enough for the $$
Loved it! from Chicago
So, easy & smoothly it is to put on & it stays on for almost the entire day.
Got it as a gift and now I can't stop buying it.
Shoys2000 from Olympia, WA
My favorite pencil. I just dislike that the pencil part always finishes so much faster than the liquid liner. I wish they sold this pencil in a stick by itself.
I would buy this again!
Terry from Arlington, TX
Using this on the upper lid for a tight waterline. I have deep set eyes.
Love! Try it you won't regret it!!
Lori from La puente, ca
I've always used Mac liquid eyeliner (the cone shaped one and liquid last) but during the quarantine I wanted to try something new and I'm so glad I did!! I love this eyeliner!! The pencil comes out smooth and dark the liquid too!! The Mac cone eyeliner always ends up smearing under my eyes and this one didn't!! Love it!!
Elizabeth from San Antonio
I had bought this before and liked it. But my recent purchase the pencil was hard, could not lined my waterline. It may be an old stock
It's a no from me
Cat from Phoenix
I usually love everything that Tarte puts out but I honestly have had better luck with drugstore brand eyeliners than this one. I have hooded eyes, so I end up spending a little extra on eyeliner in order to not have it all over my lids. Bought this guy in the check out line and used it twice now and both times had me wiping away black from my lids all day.
Hesitant about buying again
Tammy from Lima,Ohio
I use this product on a daily basis. My liquid side lasts forever and holds up great! The retractable side constantly has broken off. It usually last me a week from opening it. Makes me very hesitant to buy this product due to how many problems I've had with every one I've had. I've also bought this multiple times.
Laura from Philadelphia, PA
This is my new favorite eyeliner. I love both sides, they both last all day. I bought the brown one, as I feel black looks too harsh on me. Love the color.